What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Half-Yearly Report Card

Fangs

Coach
Messages
11,505
Where are we? I say A-

Equal 1st Position
12 games played 12 to go
8 Wins 4 Losses
Best defence in the competition

No word yet on Cleary so a lot can change over the next month of football. Disappointing we couldn't snag more wins earlier in the season as its a very tight competition. Otherwise we are well placed.

Run home:

Roosters (Away)
Cowboys (Away + No Origin Players)

Origin 2

Knights (Home)
Storm (Away)

BYE
Origin 3

Dolphins (Away)
Bulldogs (Home)
Sharks (Home)
Storm (Home)
Sea Eagles (Away)
Titans (Away)
Eels (Home)
Cowboys (Home)
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,289
I think overall given a few one point losses early on we have done reasonably well, West Tigers game excluded. That loss could come back to bite us.

Our defence is obviously our strength and that is keeping us competitive and in the running for a critical top four position.

This season is really competitive and we are going to have to grind out a few wins in the weeks ahead to maintain our position in the ladder. It’s going to be really tough.
 

Iamback

Coach
Messages
17,277
Where are we? I say A-

Equal 1st Position
12 games played 12 to go
8 Wins 4 Losses
Best defence in the competition

No word yet on Cleary so a lot can change over the next month of football. Disappointing we couldn't snag more wins earlier in the season as its a very tight competition. Otherwise we are well placed.

Run home:

Roosters (Away)
Cowboys (Away + No Origin Players)

Origin 2

Knights (Home)
Storm (Away)

BYE
Origin 3

Dolphins (Away)
Bulldogs (Home)
Sharks (Home)
Storm (Home)
Sea Eagles (Away)
Titans (Away)
Eels (Home)
Cowboys (Home)

The 4 points from Bathurst and Souffs games would be handy right now
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
11,505

Panthers halfback Nathan Cleary is set to miss the remainder of the 2023 Ampol State of Origin series after picking up a hamstring injury in his side's win over the Dragons on Sunday night.

Penrith confirmed on Monday that the Blues star would be sidelined for up to six weeks, ruling him out for selection for the remaining two Origin fixtures.


---

So that's the Roosters, Cowboys and and Knights fixtures. In his mind he will want to return early against Melbourne. That is 4 weeks away and it gives him one opportunity to play before Origin 3.

More realistic is the Dolphins game after the bye and Origin.
 

Iamback

Coach
Messages
17,277
He would of missed the Cows game anyway.

Knights game was a 50/50 due to backing up.

Throw in the bye.

Really only is 3 games missing, puts more pressure on Soni Luke to find whatever he needs for more minutes.

Spine of

Edwards
Salmon
Cogger
Kenny

won't offer much. Soni getting up to 40 min a game of quality
 

snickers007

Juniors
Messages
1,474
ValueComparative RankScoreNotes
Win Percentage67%2ndA-Just the 4 losses, with our biggest loss being by 4 points is pretty decent.
Still it's hard not to be disappointed that we didn't win all 4 given the match circumstances, and the chances we had.
Points For (avg)24.24thB+Hard to get a gauge on.
Some games we've created plenty of opportunies, but bombed half of them.
Other games we've only created a few opportunites, but taken them all.
And others we've been scoring points for fun.
Points Against (avg)11.91stA+Head and shoulders above everyone else.
Broncos are the 2nd best team at 17.4 points per game.
Players Used231stAHave done well to navigate short-medium term injuries to guys like Fisher-Harris, Martin & Tago.
Have also been able to pivot to a new starting second-row pairing, and are starting to see some good signs from Lindsay Smith.
Perhaps missed an opportunity to bring in Tom Jenkins with the Tago injury - but Peachey did a good job, scoring 3 tries in that 4 match stretch.
About to enter our biggest test, with Cleary out, and State of Origin.

Overall probably an A-

There is no doubt that we have come back to the pack a bit, while the general level of competition has also increased significantly. Our defence is still head and shoulders above everyone else, and that should ensure we finish at the pointy end of the competition.

The lack of class out of dummy-half is still an issue - although we have improved significantly since the opening rounds. And we really have no other options either - especially with the Cleary injury, we've missed our chance to see Cogger get a shot at 9.

All of our losses have been super-winnable games, which is disappointing. We're obviously struggling a bit in the wet this year, which impacted the Broncos, Eels and Tigers losses. But all these matches we had enough ball to win, and struggled to convert into points. We also seem to have lost a bit of patience when chasing points, and outside of a few outliers, we haven't been able to find that killer blow with the game on the line. Then there is the Rabbitohs game which we dominated for 75mins and lost.

We also made some pretty big game-management blunders in regards to penalties in the red-zone, and leaving the 2 points begging. 3 weeks in a row we got it wrong - which resulted in a win in Golden Point (which could have been avoided), and 2 point loss (which could have gone to Golden Point), and a 4 point loss (which again could have gone to Golden Point). Sounds easy in hindsight - but when the attack has been as clunky and hit/miss as ours, we should have banked the points.

I think the competition is going to blow open over the next 4-5 weeks, and we'll see the Top 6 teams pull away from the pack. And we'll be well inside that group. If we can keep the majority of our squad healthy for finals, the 3peat is well and truly on the table.
 
Top