Hindmarsh named greatest player to never win a grand final

[mozza91]

Like Johns in 97

You’re trying so hard. Johns played hardly any football in 1997.

He did win the next 2 Dally M medals when the competition was full strength again though. Which is what you’d expect from the greatest Rugby League player of all time.

 

[gUt]

You’re trying so hard. Johns played hardly any football in 1997.

He did win the next 2 Dally M medals when the competition was full strength again though. Which is what you’d expect from the greatest Rugby League player of all time.

I did expect that to be honest but with the obvious 9/ARL bias Johns was always going to get it instead.

 

[gordsy]

I'd say Blocker, Sirro and Pearce all in front Hindmarsh. Brasher too. But Hindmarsh might be the better club man than the others.Having met both, one thing Pearce and Hindmarsh have in common is they are both dumb as dog shit.

 

[President Trump]

Laloa Milford

 

[horrie hastings]

I never saw the pole to vote because i was away but i would have added Kevin Hastings to the list.

 

[kdalymc]

No Palmer Wapau?

 

[simmo05]

I'd say Blocker, Sirro and Pearce all in front Hindmarsh. Brasher too. But Hindmarsh might be the better club man than the others.Having met both, one thing Pearce and Hindmarsh have in common is they are both dumb as dog shit.

Tim Brasher, highly underrated, and still my favorite player

 

[Walk On Home Boy]

I thought Hindy's first 3 or 4 seasons were far superior to the rest. He started out a far more dynamic player, ran a good line and was a genuine threat with the ball in hand. He declined slowly and became a tacklebot, granted, a tough one. Too tired to make any impact in attack, due in part to the awful Parramatta squads and coaches he was forced to endure. I liked him though. Was good at rep level too.

 

[super_coach]

The best third man flopper ever to play. Over rated is the first thing that comes to mind with Hindmarsh. Very good club backrower but not elite. Steve Rodgers, Wayne Pearce, Back door, Stacey Jones are just a few who come to mind without giving it much thought...I guess the survey was done in the Parramatta local rag

 

[LittleWayne]

Needs more Jason Smith.

 

[From Where the Sun Rises]

No love for Wally Lewis?
Guess only 80 first grade games and 2 spoons isn't that good

Playing three great games a year doesn’t make you great - only over-rated.

 

[From Where the Sun Rises]

That’s adorable. Trent Cutler used to be dominant in the weaker competition aswell.

This. Lewis was impotent in week in, week out competition at NSWRL level.

 

[This Year?]

Needs more Jason Smith.

Jason Smith eh...

Can't say I've......

 

[TheDalek079]

Jason Smith? Rugby league Star?


Never heard of the f**ker

 

[This Year?]

Jason Smith? Rugby league Star?


Never heard of the f**ker

Me neither!