Injuries - who has had more?

[hazmak]

List of injuries:

1- Patten (Round 19 - Round 26) 8 weeks
2- El Masri (Round 21 - Round 26) 6 weeks
3- Reni Maitua (Rnd 1 - Round 4*, City Ctry Rnd 9 - Rnd 19, Round 24 - 26) 18 weeks
4- Willie Tonga (Round 10 - Round 26) 16 weeks *****
5- Cameron Phelps (Don't Know, AT LEAST 2 weeks) 2 weeks
6- Brett Oliver (Rnd 4 - Rnd 26) 23 weeks
7- Brent Sherwin (Rnd 23 - Rnd 26) 4 weeks
8- Mark O'Meley (Rnd 2 - Round 4, Rnd 7 - Rnd 13)* 10 weeks
9- Adam Perry ( AT LEAST 4 weeks, but I don't know when) 4 weeks
10- Nate Myles ( Round 9 - Round 15) 7 weeks
11- Willie Mason (Rnd 1 - Round 17) 17 weeks
12- Trevor Thurling (Rnd 3 - Rnd 26) 23 weeks
13- SBW (Rnd 6 - Rnd 12, Rnd 14 - Rnd 26) 20 weeks

14- Hughes (Rnd 9 - 10, Rnd 12) 3 weeks
15- Morrin (rnd 13 - Rnd 26) 14 weeks
16- Trent Cutler (Rnd 20 - Rnd 26) 7 weeks
17- (Nothing wrong with a 3 man rotation!)

TOTAL: Roughly - 182 injury weeks = 3.5 years.

Also, Daniel Conn & Daniel Irvine have been injured in PL, and they BOTH have played FG this year...

NOTE:
* = If they were due to return during a bye week, I did not count that week
***** = Willie Tonga and a few others had the mumps, but I don't know when, or to whom else, hence I didn't add them into the calcs.

 

[hazmak]

Compare that to the Raiders list (games missed in brackets)

Clinton Schifcofske (6)
Marshall Chalk (6)
Craig Frawley (17)
Phil Graham (6)
Adam Mogg (3)
Jason Smith (10)
Josh Miller (2)
Simon Woolford (12)
Troy Thompson (3)
Matt Adamson (8)
Ian Hindmarsh (2)
Jason Croker (1)
Alan Tongue (1)
Michael Weyman (20)
Ryan O'Hara (21)
Michael Hodgson (10)
Alan Rothery (8)
Ben Cross (3)
Nathan Smith (24)
Terry Martin (24)
Damon Alley-Tovio (21)
Terry Campese (6)
Tyran Smith (7)

That's not to mention the Premier League back-ups who, if not for injury, may have taken the place of some of these players in first grade. I'm sure the Knights would have a similar list. So once again Dodgy, cry me a f**king river.

take away about 20 weeks becoz of suspensions....

Out of those injured players, name 10 of those who have played in a grand-final, and those that have played in a grand-final, name 6 that have been missing for more than 8 weeks...

Canberra has a bunch of no-name son the sidelines, and u just can't hack that the team sucks....

 

[Dogaholic]

List of injuries:

1- Patten (Round 19 - Round 26) 8 weeks
2- El Masri (Round 21 - Round 26) 6 weeks
3- Reni Maitua (Rnd 1 - Round 4*, City Ctry Rnd 9 - Rnd 19, Round 24 - 26) 18 weeks
4- Willie Tonga (Round 10 - Round 26) 16 weeks *****
5- Cameron Phelps (Don't Know, AT LEAST 2 weeks) 2 weeks
6- Brett Oliver (Rnd 4 - Rnd 26) 23 weeks
7- Brent Sherwin (Rnd 23 - Rnd 26) 4 weeks
8- Mark O'Meley (Rnd 2 - Round 4, Rnd 7 - Rnd 13)* 10 weeks
9- Adam Perry ( AT LEAST 4 weeks, but I don't know when) 4 weeks
10- Nate Myles ( Round 9 - Round 15) 7 weeks
11- Willie Mason (Rnd 1 - Round 17) 17 weeks
12- Trevor Thurling (Rnd 3 - Rnd 26) 23 weeks
13- SBW (Rnd 6 - Rnd 12, Rnd 14 - Rnd 26) 20 weeks

14- Hughes (Rnd 9 - 10, Rnd 12) 3 weeks
15- Morrin (rnd 13 - Rnd 26) 14 weeks
16- Trent Cutler (Rnd 20 - Rnd 26) 7 weeks
17- (Nothing wrong with a 3 man rotation!)

TOTAL: Roughly - 182 injury weeks = 3.5 years.

Also, Daniel Conn & Daniel Irvine have been injured in PL, and they BOTH have played FG this year...

NOTE:
* = If they were due to return during a bye week, I did not count that week
***** = Willie Tonga and a few others had the mumps, but I don't know when, or to whom else, hence I didn't add them into the calcs.

Daniel Irvine missed making his debut several weeks ago for the Dogs due to injury, so I guess he can take the no 17 position.

 

[SOULS 04]

take away about 20 weeks becoz of suspensions....

Out of those injured players, name 10 of those who have played in a grand-final, and those that have played in a grand-final, name 6 that have been missing for more than 8 weeks...

Canberra has a bunch of no-name son the sidelines, and u just can't hack that the team sucks....

your full of s**t

you take that many players out of a first grade side and say it wont effect your season... you are a dead set tool... how many of your blokes would have played in a grand final if not for last year. alot of them have only really just proved themselves and alot of these younger raiders were starting to do the same...

im not saying they are better players than yours... far from it but they are our first grade side and if they were all in a majority of the year we'd be sitting well higher than we are.

you would be too but if you think your injury list is worse your kidding... at least your halves combo hasnt been stuffed all season... your only just dealing with that now.