Mass Injury Update Rd 8 to Rd 10

[Magpies Forever]

From the WT website:

NRL INJURY LIST
As of April 27, 2010
Player: Robert Lui
Injury: Ankle
Return date: Rd 10
Player: Todd Payten
Injury: Calf
Return date: Rd 10
Player: Arana Taumata
Injury: Ankle
Return date: Rd 10
Player: Alan Schirnack
Injury: Knee
Return date: Rd 10
Player: Jason Schirnack
Injury: Knee
Return date: Rd 10
Player: Jason Cayless
Injury: Knee
Return date: Rd 12
Player: Taniela Tuiaki
Injury: Ankle
Return date: Indefinite (no set date or round marked for return)
Player: Tame Tupou
Injury: Knee
Return date: Indefinite
Player: Tim Moltzen
Injury: Knee
Out for rest of the season.

Incredible all the rd 8 expected returns are now rd 10- mass diagnosis? What are they doing out there? Can all of the rd 8 returns have got suddenly worse?

 

[gronkathon]

No it's just we have the Bye in round 9

Makes sense to rest them an extra week of competition and effectively gain 2

 

[Magpies Forever]

No it's just we have the Bye in round 9

Makes sense to rest them an extra week of competition and effectively gain 2

Oh, I suppose.

 

[steven_tiger]

Bit concerning they are all leg issues.

We have some more firepower coming back in Rd 10 it seems!

 

[Vic Mackey]

every single one of them originally said due back round 6.

once again great work by the staff at wests tigers, my theory of doubling the expected time of return seems spot on again

i guess we'll expect to see timmy moltzen back in 2012

 

[Spot]

So long as we don't have to needle them up!!

 

[gronkathon]

every single one of them originally said due back round 6.

once again great work by the staff at wests tigers, my theory of doubling the expected time of return seems spot on again

i guess we'll expect to see timmy moltzen back in 2012

It is either "they are taking to long" or "look they bought them back to early and now they are injured again"

Which would you prefer

 

[Vic Mackey]

It is either "they are taking to long" or "look they bought them back to early and now they are injured again"

Which would you prefer

id prefer they come back from a 2 week injury after 2 weeks, not 6

 

[gronkathon]

So you know how long each injury takes to rehab and the progress of each individual I take it

 

[Vic Mackey]

i know that if a player is said to be out for 2 weeks and it takes 6 or out for 6 and it takes 12 then he hasnt had his injury managed properly.

 

[gronkathon]

:lol: It is clear you know nothing.

You assume alot as we all do but knowledge is a different thing

 

[Vic Mackey]

:lol: It is clear you know nothing.

You assume alot as we all do but knowledge is a different thing

so you think there is nothing wrong with the rehab staff if a player was originally ruled out for 6 weeks, but instead comes back after 12?

 

[gronkathon]

It is not ideal but injury management is a very fluid process to manage

 

[N.C.]

maybe they're just too optimistic from the outset?

 

[Magpies Forever]

Anybody else notice on the WT website they list Cayless now as indefinite with knee injury. Any news? What gives? What was his magnificent playing record with WT this year?