Most under rated players

[The Colonel]

Following on from the thread re: over rated players - name your most under rated 17.


1. Ashley Graham
2. Scott Donald
3. Steve Bell
4. Vinnie Anderson
5. Craig Hall
6. Matt Geyer
7. Matt Orford
8. Steve Price
9. Shayne Dunley
10. Willie Manu
11. Ian Hindmarsh
12. Logan Swann
13. Mark O'Neill

14. Lance Thompson
15. Chris Flannery
16. Robbie Mears
17. Terry Martin

 

[Anonymous]

John wilson for a centre spot!

 

[paulquinn49]

1. Patten
2. A Graham
3. V Anderson
4. Bell
5. Donald
6. Hoahia (spelling)
7. Monaghan
8. Laffranci
9. Smith
10. O'Hara
11. Wilson
12. Thompson
13. Hilder

14. M Minichello
15. T Thompson
16. Parker
17. Orford

 

[EdBurton]

When O'Meley first came onto the scene he was a little over-rated, then he caught up to and surpassed those ratings and nobody seems to notice, so I'd put him up there as an under-rated player...

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Joel Monaghan, Ryan O'Hara, Mark McLinden, Simon Woolford & Ian Hindmarsh from the Raiders.

other teams - Ben Hornby, Matt Geyer, Matt Orford, Kevin Campion, Glenn Morrison, Tai Williams, Danny Nutley & Michael Monaghan,

 

[Raiders_Champion]

1. Adam Mogg
2. Joel Monaghan
3. Sione Faumuina
4. Paul Franze
5. Matt Geyer
6. Thomas Leuluai
7. Michael Monaghan
8. Ryan O'Hara
9. Michael Sullivan
10. Peter Robinson
11. Ian Hindmarsh
12. Henry Perenara
13. Dene Halatau

14. Terry Martin
15. John Wilson
16. Michael Weyman
17. David Myles

 

[Kasper]

Glenn Morrison- Does the same thing as Ricketson week in week out in defence and does more in attack. Even so Ricketson gets all the media attention and representative selections.

 

[Special K]

Danny Nutley. The NRLs hardest worker and yet he never gets a mention for rep teams.

A front rower, plays 80 minutes, always tops the hit ups and tackle counts and never stays down. I wouldn't swap him for anything.

 

[Mr Angry]

George Kanaan - never heard of him? How under-rated can you get.
If your playing first grade or even PL you go OK.
Never has been a place for the faint hearted.

 

[Disco]

From Manly

LUKE WILLIAMSON
Scott Donald
Micheal Monaghan
Shayne Dunley

 

[Kasper]

Joel Monaghan, Ryan O'Hara, Mark McLinden, Simon Woolford & Ian Hindmarsh from the Raiders.

other teams - Ben Hornby, Matt Geyer, Matt Orford, Kevin Campion, Glenn Morrison, Tai Williams, Danny Nutley & Michael Monaghan,

Ty Williams ;-)
I agree with all of those players.
I think Williams will be playing origin within the next few years. I am tipping Singy to retire in a couple of seasons and then Ty to take over his role, but with better defence ;-) .

 

[Michael_Ballack]

Daniel Abraham-very under rated, strong running backrower, good speed, good defender and kicks goals.

 

[roofromoz]

Paul Whatuira.

He didn't exactly set the world on fire when he was at the Warriors and the Storm, but his form for the Panthers this year was a contributing reason towards their success. Good defender, and has a bit to offer in attack. And he also gained Kiwi selection for the recent test against Australia, even though he didn't make the 17.

 

[Princess]

i would have to say Daniel Abraham, Ben Hornby, Matt Cooper, Lance Thompson.

 

[**DrAgOnS_gUrL**]

I would say Ben Hornby for sure. As well as Ryan O'Hara and Lance Thompson

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Glenn Morrison- Does the same thing as Ricketson week in week out in defence and does more in attack. Even so Ricketson gets all the media attention and representative selections.

Morrison should do more shampoo ads.

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Talk about underated players, Sione Faumuina comes on my list of players.

9. Shayne Dunley

What a pity hes left the club, I mean another year at Parramatta wouldve been great.[/code]

 

[Booyah]

Danny Nutley.

 

[thomo]

From Souths - Ashley Harrison and Luke Stuart

 

[raz]

Maybe being overrated and underrated has something to do with the players you play with or what team you are on?[/code]