What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

My Wests Tigers Ratings

Engine

Juniors
Messages
1,959
I am so ANGRY with my team atm. Why in hell did we have two small men in Moltzen and Flanagan on the bench? Great decision coach.

1. Brett Hodgson 7....tried hard today (as always). Siome forwards twice his size should be ashamed to see this guy take the ball up instead of themselves.

2. Taniela Tuaki 6 ..a shadow of what he was last year. His kick returns just have no venom. Still works ok out of dummy half.

3. Dean Collis 4...done nothing....only positive is it's his first game back. If he plays like that again, a mafia snniper should look for him.

4. Chris Lawrence 4 ...this guy has no excuse. He is NOT a centre and cannot defend there at all. Put him back on the wing NOW!!!!!

5. Shannon McDonnell...3 this asswipe needs some grip boots. What a pisspoor player.

6. John Morris....4...this wanker still in the halves????? Jeremy Smith will show you up next week.

7. Matthew Head...6...promising start. He'll be better for the run. At least the guy is a natural half.

8. Todd Payten....7... Made a heap of tackles and runs. At least he can collect his paycheck without a mocking grin.

9. Liam Fulton...7..not an attacking hooker, but I gave him the 7 due to making a heap of tackles. Take note Te'o and friends.

10. Keith Galloway....4...Keith, a props job description is to make room for the rest of the team to do their work. YOU are NOT holding your end of the bargain, you useless oversized Ginger Meggs!!! GO back to Cronulla now!!!

11. Ben Te'o 4...you useless man. Stop the SBW routine and roll up your sleeves.

12. Bryce Gibbs.....3... NOT a second rower. Judging by todays performance....not really a prop either.

13. Chris Heighington....7...thank goodness for Chris.

14. Tim Moltzen....did he play????

15. Corey Payne.4..no impact.

16. Stuart Flanigan...5...he offloaded more than any of our forwards.

17. Bronson Harrison....6...he had a go and got rewarded with an injury. WHY did it not happen to John Morris instead????
 

Callan Pk

Juniors
Messages
705
Moltzen warming the bench for 75 mins, when we had four players back with no match finess,(McDonnell, Head, Collis, Gibbs & one more with only one game(Tuiaki) match fitness under the belt...all while we lose a player just after half time.
Surely they could see we'd be running outta puff at the back end?
 

rupertpupkin

Juniors
Messages
512
Moltzen warming the bench for 75 mins, when we had four players back with no match finess,(McDonnell, Head, Collis, Gibbs & one more with only one game(Tuiaki) match fitness under the belt...all while we lose a player just after half time.
Surely they could see we'd be running outta puff at the back end?

I know this is really "out there"... But could it be possible that Coach wanted to get a win, without fielding him? He is a half. He might have gone... a little too good... Nah. Coach wouldn't do something like not play someone off the bench for some weird motive. Surely? Don't mind me. Just being cynical...
 
Messages
15,406
for a start Fulton played 5/8 and Morris played hooker.

Secondly Morris was one of our better players, Head was our best.
 

Eddie.

Bench
Messages
4,188
Galloway was woeful today.

He was loafing and struggling to get back the 10 metres after just five minutes.

Then the big useless slug slips over and the elusive Dan Tilse is under the sticks.

shocking.
 

rupertpupkin

Juniors
Messages
512
They seemed to be switching roles around, not just those 2 either IIRC. Morris did play most in at 9, however. It didn't appear to be very clear what was going on there.
 

Latest posts

Top