Nathan Cleary "Try"

[some11]

Try, why argue about a decision that was correct?

Why bother having a forum?

We're having a discussion.

 

[bileduct]

No try.

 

[Surely]

You can ground it with a forearm but not after your hands have rolled over the top

 

[Grapple]

It's like zooming in with a telescope to see if you have the odd skid mark on ya underwear. Quite often you'll find what you're looking for if you look hard enough.

It's not really helping matters, just redefining them, and if ya gonna do that be consistent with all the rules in microscopic fashion... Some things should be left undiscovered, otherwise you're just changing the way you rule the game.

(glad Penrith got knocked out, Go Sharks!)

 

[Fangs]

Why bother having a forum?

We're having a discussion.

There is nothing to discuss. Unless you want to discuss whether we should use a different shade of green for the word TRY on the big screen.

I'm partial to shamrock.

 

[McLovin]

Cleary had zero control and one angle even showed separation. Appalling decision and if you think it was a fair try, you don't know football.

Case closed

 

[some11]

There is nothing to discuss.

A few disagree.

 

[Fangs]

Cleary had zero control and one angle even showed separation. Appalling decision and if you think it was a fair try, you don't know football.

Case closed

Thanks, who doesn't like reading a fairytale?

Trust a sharks fan to get the shits even after they win a game. Biggest wingers in the bloody comp.

 

[9701]

Thanks, who doesn't like reading a fairytale?

Trust a sharks fan to get the shits even after they win a game. Biggest wingers in the bloody comp.

Nah there are bigger wingers in the comp then the 2 at the sharks

 

[Griffoshark66]

Agreed. Feki is knee high to a grasshopper.

Nah there are bigger wingers in the comp then the 2 at the sharks

 

[Card Shark]

To the letter of the law, if the ball is on the ground, ya only have to touch it to be a try.

However there is no way any “control” over it, his wrists glanced the ball as he went past.

In the end, all Holmes had to do was place himself between the ball & Cleary & no way he gets a hand near it. Was lazy.