What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

No Regrets.

The Colonel

Immortal
Messages
41,992
No Regrets.

With 2004 practically over, unless by some minor miracle the Eels make the eight, its time too look ahead at 2005.

2004 promised so much but delivered little in way of results and the fans needed some hope. Hope arrived in the shape of some smart new signings and the return of some prodigal sons. There is excitement building in the air out Parramatta way and the future looks remarkable bright after some extremely disappointing seasons since 2001.

Firstly, the possibility of Smith moving to the role of “coaching director” leaves Parramatta fans salivating at the thought. Few doubt Smith’s desire, however many question the length of time Smith has now taken to win the elusive premiership he has promised for so long. The possible return of Daniel Anderson and the signing of Peter Sharp could quite possibly add a new edge to a tired, faltering outfit. The fact that both Sharp and Anderson helped kick-start the careers of the likes of Hindmarsh, Cayless, Vella, McKinnon, Burt and Marsh should not be missed amongst all the attention given to their return. They hold a rapport already with many of the players, which will be important as a new side emerges from the rubble of 2004.

One player, in particular, will benefit most from the arrival of new faces. Nathan Hindmarsh has been the rock on which the Eels have relied upon to hold them together in 2004. The arrival of Glenn Morrison, Paul Stringer and Mark Riddell will ease the focus on Hindmarsh and bolster a pack down on confidence and go forward. An injury free season for Aaron Cannings and Nathan Cayless will see a pack that on form can dominate any other in the competition.

A solid platform is a must for any backline and an embarrassment of riches is possessed out wide in 2005. The exact make up still remains to be seen however the likes of Tahu, Grothe, McKinnon, Morris, Witt, Burt, Petersen and Marsh will be praying the forward pack can stand tall and deliver them the metres they need.

A confident side has done well for the likes of Hunt at Brisbane and Williams at the Dogs, so a couple of youngsters also need to make their mark in 2005. After debuting in 2004, the likes of Feleti Mateo, Ben Smith, Brett Anderson and rookie of the year Jack Afamasaga need to ride the coat tails of the senior players and show the form they have displayed in the lower grades. Other young talent could also force their way into the top grades.


The 2005 squad will be well served for depth across all positions with only the centres lacking the experience of years past.

Fullback – Wade McKinnon, Joel Reddy, Brett Anderson, Luke Burt, Ash Graham

Wing – Timana Tahu, Eric Grothe, Luke Burt, Matt Petersen, John Williams, Brett Anderson

Centre – Timana Tahu, Luke Burt, Ben Smith, Luke O’Dwyer, Brett Delaney, Josh Davis, Matt Lantry, Matt Nicholas, Dean Widders, Daniel Wagon, Ash Graham

Five-Eighth – John Morris, PJ Marsh, Feleti Mateo, Marcus Perenara, Blake Green, Michael Witt, Jeremiah Pai

Half – Michael Witt, PJ Marsh, Tim Smith, Marcus Perenara, Dane Queenan

Lock – Daniel Wagon, Glenn Morrison, Feleti Mateo, Matt Keating, Chris Muckert, Jeremiah Pai, Henry Perenara, Guy Williams, Ian Henderson

Second-Row – Nathan Hindmarsh, Nathan Cayless, Glenn Morrison, Chad Robinson, Henry Perenara, Jack Afamasaga, Brendan Oake, Weller Hauraki, Chris Muckert, Mark Riddell, Ben Taia, Daniel Backo, Kurt Sorenson

Front Row – Paul Stringer, Aaron Cannings, Justin Tsoulos, Michael Vella, Nathan Cayless, Weller Hauraki, Josh Cordoba, Jim Curtis, Fui Fui Moi Moi, Zeb Taia, Ben Taia, Adam Peek

Hooker – Mark Riddell, PJ Marsh, John Morris, Scott Jones, Ian Henderson

The off season will determine many positions in the top side however every player needs to be on top of their game with players certain to push for selection if they miss out.

The return of PJ Marsh, back after leaving the fold in 2001, is the most important acquisition of all. After injuring his neck, which looked as if it could end his career, Marsh will return to the Eels in the position which was earmarked for him before his departure - halfback. Despite playing hooker at the Warriors, Marsh has the maturity and skill to guide the team around the park while allowing the youngsters in Witt and Smith to fully mature.

When it all boils down, the embarrassment of riches coupled with a possible change at the helm leaves few excuses for the management and coaching staff of the Eels in 2005. Hopefully the players can also adopt the attitude of the 1999 World Cup winning Aussie Cricket side and end the 2005 season with No Regrets.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,240
When you look at that list it makes you wonder if we have too many options

Then when you think what we have been throught the past two seasons, it makes me think we now have the required depth we need to cover all our options.
 

PB

Bench
Messages
3,311
So our 25 man NRL squad should look something like.......

1. Wade McKinnon
2. Ash Graham
3. Eric Grothe
4. Luke Burt
5. Matt Petersen
6. Timana Tahu
7. Dean Widders
8. Daniel Wagon
9. John Morris
10. PJ Marsh
11. Michael Witt
12. Glenn Morrison
13. Nathan Hindmarsh
14. Nathan Cayless
15. Chad Robinson
16. Mark Riddell
17. Paul Stringer
18. Aaron Cannings
19. Justin Tsoulos
20. Michael Vella
21. Adam Peek
22. Jack Afamasaga
23. Luke O’Dwyer

Positions 24. and 25. between:
Chris Muckert, Henry Perenara, Guy Williams, Ian Henderson, Josh Cordoba, Jim Curtis, Fui Fui Moi Moi, Feleti Mateo, John Williams, Brett Anderson, Ben Smith, Joel Reddy
 

bradeel

Juniors
Messages
911
well written Colonel and i think you have certainly summed up the way most of us would be feeling about the 2005 season. :clap:


Its been a very disapointing year as we all know, and the team reached seemingly new lows on at least 3 different occasions that i can think of throughout the season. The Rd 1 loss to the Bulldogs to kick things off, the 5 match losing streak featuring losses to mostly beatable sides including the Reserve Grade Dragons, and those losses to the Cowboys and Tigers late in the season after beating the Roosters.

Through it all however the side did manage to make us fans smile with a few bright spots: The Roosters and Broncos wins, beating the Knights twice and a few big wins over Manly, NZ, and the Sharks and certainly the signings for next year bring renewed hope yet again.

Hopefully the boys can put on a really big effort to spoil Fittler's party this Sunday and give us all reason to believe that we can be the most improved side in next season's comp.
 

The Colonel

Immortal
Messages
41,992
The weight of expectation is the only thing, reasonably, that should upset 2005.

Something I think everyone should remember. ;-)
 
Messages
17,711
Colonel,

With the squad we have next year, anything less than a top 4 finish and then a GF win is a failure. They will have to learn to live with the expectation.
 

The Colonel

Immortal
Messages
41,992
Jake the snake said:
Colonel,

With the squad we have next year, anything less than a top 4 finish and then a GF win is a failure. They will have to learn to live with the expectation.

I'll be happy with top 4 - anything more is a bonus. ;-)
 

GoParra

Juniors
Messages
1,667
Colonel Eel said:
Jake the snake said:
Colonel,

With the squad we have next year, anything less than a top 4 finish and then a GF win is a failure. They will have to learn to live with the expectation.

I'll be happy with top 4 - anything more is a bonus. ;-)

Right with you there Colonel, No team can just EXPECT a Grand Final, not even the 80's teams from Parra could just EXPECT a grand final win.
There will be plenty of other sides going around with just as good a chance as us.
What i do expect is one hell of an improvement on this season .
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,843
people seem to forget the calibre of opposition that we will face next season. If we come 5th and not in the top 4, it's basically because the Roosters, Dogs, Broncs and the Dragons are ahead of them.

And if you only go by the talent available on paper you have to agree the clubs mentioned have more talented players and probably greater depth.

thats where Smith/Sharp and maybe Anderson steps in waves their wand!! :D
 

The Colonel

Immortal
Messages
41,992
eelavation said:
people seem to forget the calibre of opposition that we will face next season. If we come 5th and not in the top 4, it's basically because the Roosters, Dogs, Broncs and the Dragons are ahead of them.

And if you only go by the talent available on paper you have to agree the clubs mentioned have more talented players and probably greater depth.

Certainly don't forget them - though I think the Roosters will miss Fittler and their early season form will show it. Reasonably, Top 4 is acheivable and should be where they aim. If they finish fifth its still as big an improvement as fourth. ;-)
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,281
Colonel Eel said:
Jake the snake said:
Colonel,

With the squad we have next year, anything less than a top 4 finish and then a GF win is a failure. They will have to learn to live with the expectation.

I'll be happy with top 4 - anything more is a bonus. ;-)
I'm right with you on that one Colonel.
I'd be happy with top 4 as well.

It will have shown an improvement, not a continuing decline.
I don't need a comp, just a show that we have REALLY put in.

I'd even pat Smithy on the back for that. Don't forget, I think he is a good coach.

Suity
 

Ron Jeremy

Coach
Messages
25,689
Luke O' Dwyer should be now where near out top squad.

We have far better talent in Anderson, Mateo, Moi Moi, Reddy, Smith.......he shouldn't even be a starter in our Premier League squad.

What has he done to justify his spot??....oh that's right, a soft try against the Rabbits when the game was already won, but that's right.......it was the way he scored it :roll:
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,623
Well written Colonel. I especially appreciate and agree with your comments re: Marsh. My tip is that Josh Davis and Marcus Perenera will make an imapct and possibly start next year.
 

ParraMatt

Bench
Messages
3,668
Witt will be our half-back, Not Marsh, Marsh will play the role he did in 2001. Number 14, Coming on for Riddell.
 

parra_princess

Juniors
Messages
605
Is anybody else absolutely thrilled about PJ Marsh coming back. I'm so excited about 2005, I can't wait. Bring it On I say!
 

ParraMatt

Bench
Messages
3,668
Ron Jeremy said:
Luke O' Dwyer should be now where near out top squad.

We have far better talent in Anderson, Mateo, Moi Moi, Reddy, Smith.......he shouldn't even be a starter in our Premier League squad.

What has he done to justify his spot??....oh that's right, a soft try against the Rabbits when the game was already won, but that's right.......it was the way he scored it :roll:

I don't think you can rate his second half of the season on playing centre in premier league, He is clearly a Lock, And at times, A good lock at that which he showed at the early stages of this year. I believe he may be scraping for a bench spot in First Grade next year.
 

ParraMatt

Bench
Messages
3,668
parra_princess said:
Is anybody else absolutely thrilled about PJ Marsh coming back. I'm so excited about 2005, I can't wait. Bring it On I say!

I can't wait either, Aslong as he doesn't steal Witt's position.
 

Latest posts

Top