Panthers All Time Wingers 2024 Version

[soc123_au]

I think one spot here is a lock, but the other will be hotly contested. I'm torn between Sauce and Flash for one of my choices, and even then Critta keeps popping into my head.

Pick two. I've set it so you can change your vote if someone comes up with something to force a change of heart. Poll closes in 7 days.

 

[Chins get the wins]

To'o is the sports best ever winger so that's one easy pick.

Also SOC I don't see Taylan May as an option on the poll?

 

[Goonji]

Ray Blacklock?

 

[Whino]

Alan McIndoe was named as one of the wingers in Panthers 40th season inaugural Team of Legends in 2006.

From some of our older posters. What was he like?

 

[Whino]

Like most I have gone To'o.
My 2nd vote I will give some thought.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Luke Lewis is 100% in the best ever 13 players to play for Penrith. Will be interesting to see where he fits for everyone

 

[MugaB]

Luke Lewis is 100% in the best ever 13 players to play for Penrith. Will be interesting to see where he fits for everyone

On my bench, very versatile

 

[Munky]

Second spot is difficult.

Lewis went to centre in 2004 while Rooney like the rest of the 2003 side declined fast.

I'll probably go Flash despite never having great success as a Panther.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Second spot is difficult.

Lewis went to centre in 2004 while Rooney like the rest of the 2003 side declined fast.

I'll probably go Flash despite never having great success as a Panther.

Playing Origin from a Elliott coached team is some success

 

[Hooked]

Of course I went Sauce as my 2nd winger.

I'd forgotten how acrobatic he was prior to Dugan wrecking him.

His last try against the Dogs (finals) is my still my favourite try. His try at 1;21 was a beauty as well.

 

[soc123_au]

To'o is the sports best ever winger so that's one easy pick.

Also SOC I don't see Taylan May as an option on the poll?

Nah, not enough games to be considered. I did just add one I cant believe I missed. If he doesn't make the cut here, dont panic, will get another shot in the backrow.

 

[TheEroticGamer]

Was close between Flash and Sauce but leaned towards Josh because of his performance vs Dogs in 2016 finals and how much he carried our lesser packs early on.

 

[Pomoz]

Its all subjective of course, but the way I see it the centres decide the wingers. Critta can play both, but good though his defence is, Girdler was our best centre followed by Brad Fittler. Critta gets a wing spot and To'o the other.

Fittler did everything Critta did but at a younger age and played rep football at a younger age.

Lewis would make the bench as a brilliant utility.

 

[Whino]

Only 3 Panthers have won Dally M Wingers of the year.

Amos 04
Sauce 16
To'o 21 & 24

 

[soc123_au]

Only 3 Panthers have won Dally M Wingers of the year.

Amos 04
Sauce 16
To'o 21 & 24

I wouldn't put too much stock into that. Dally M awards are a meme.

 

[The yak]

I went Sauce. I thought his 2016 was sublime. He carried our pack during the tough years. It was a tragedy he suffered 2 serious injuries at his peak.

Gordon had a great season in 2010? @ Fullback. His last two years here were injury ravaged unfortunately.

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Here Comes the Hotstepper
https://g.co/kgs/BoJgw1y

Used to love to watch Boom Boom play!!

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Also, initially read this as All Time Whingers and so was expecting to see a few regular posters get a start in the poll…

 

[Bred not Bought]

Hey @soc123_au . When this is over you could do a poll on Penrith's favourites. Plodders and Plonkers.

After all, the greatest Panther team needs an opposition to beat up on.

We can fill the team with Purtell, Brendan Worth, Adamson and a few other stiffs. Coached by Matt Elliott of course.

 

[Kilkenny]

Man’s our and To’o for me.

The one season of Amos Roberts was something to behold, I remember that season fondly.