What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Parramatta Eels Juniors

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,119
Nice try... But some players peak at 21.
Nice try... But neither of the players you named peaked at 21. Taylor's best season was in 2020, aged 25. Idris had his best season in 2014, which was the year he turned 24. Idris might've peaked but if mental illness hadn't cut Taylor's career short he would probably be even better today. There's no substitute for experience.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,119
Because he isn't them...

Harry Siejka is 31 did he get better with age?

He debut at 20 for the Panfers.
He debuted while contracted to the under 20s side and played four games in two years, as an emergency backup, for zero wins. His 2016 reserve grade season was his peak in rugby league, aged 24. But this bloke probably never had a full time contract in Australia. Like most halves his defence probably held him back. Get your body in front merkin
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,119
Revisionist history. You said "no rugby league player peaks at 21".
It's the same thing. They don't peak at 21 because they still have improvement in them. If they leave the game by 21 it's not because they peaked at 21. It's because their junior contract ran out and no club offered them another, or because they didn't want to stick around earning $50k as a backup. But these days even the lowest paid top 30 players earn a living wage so they can stay in the game and continue to develop.
And you know that was a silly thing to claim.
I said "any player who remains a full time pro", which you even quoted. Now you're trying to misrepresent me, on a forum where our words are on record you silly merkin. Don't be calling anyone else silly until you sort your own shit out.
 
Messages
11,696
It's the same thing. They don't peak at 21 because they still have improvement in them. If they leave the game by 21 it's not because they peaked at 21. It's because their junior contract ran out and no club offered them another, or because they didn't want to stick around earning $50k as a backup. But these days even the lowest paid top 30 players earn a living wage so they can stay in the game and continue to develop.

I said "any player who remains a full time pro", which you even quoted. Now you're trying to misrepresent me, on a forum where our words are on record you silly merkin. Don't be calling anyone else silly until you sort your own shit out.
Hmmm.... I might leave this here for your future benefit:

1689464601059.png
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,261
He debuted while contracted to the under 20s side and played four games in two years, as an emergency backup, for zero wins. His 2016 reserve grade season was his peak in rugby league, aged 24. But this bloke probably never had a full time contract in Australia. Like most halves his defence probably held him back. Get your body in front merkin

Man you can talk some shit 😂
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,119
Hey all,

Apparently the Raiders have signed Ethan 'Colonel' Sanders for 2 years from 2025, just checking in if he's any good?
Thoughts?

:D
19 years old and never played reserve grade. He will probably become a first grader, so he's better than most players his age. It would've been nice to be able to keep him.
 

Latest posts

Top