What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Player Rating

Utey

Coach
Messages
19,328
1-Mckinnon=Very good and usually broke of 1st tackle. Becoming more and more impressed. 8
2-Peterson=Had a few chances to clinch the game for us but was unable to capitalise. Tried his heart out like usual but made soem positional errors. Did well to score. 7
3-Langi=Strong, Big, Agressive and overpowered his opposing number. 6
4-Burt=Pretty quiet but held his own. 5
5-Graham=Made a definate try saving catch and is gettin match fitness back. intresting to see if he goes when grothe gets back in. 7
6-Wagon=tried hard but couldnt click with Witt. Ran and tackled like he does. Not as effective as last night. 6
7-Witt=Again last tackle options were a big big problem. Confidence is down but in time i think witt is gonna shine and lead the way. When he attacked his did not give a lot of pressure to Wesser who is veyr supsect to the high ball. Did put some nice kicks into the goal area. A shame he couldnt convert and put soem real pressure to lock the game up. 6.5
8-Pearson=Not as effective as last week. Tried like usual with some barnstorming runs. 7
9-Morris=Expolited the rucks when the big penrith forwards were tired. Anotehr solid preformance and a call to make the #9 his own. 8
10-Vella=Regaining the form which made him famous in 2001. Scored a try. 7
11-Hindmarsh=Was absolutely devasting in attack and again our shining light. So strong and agile and penrith were nereous when he got the ball. 9.5
12-Stapleton=A good game and relaiable like usual. A little to quiet in some areas of defense. 6
13-Muckert=I personally didnt see much of this guy. ???
14-Widders= Explosive off the bench and a must to our side. Didnt break the line like past weeks but was good in all aspects. 8
15-Hopkins= I persoanlly would relegate this bloke. He has done nothing impressive from what i have seen since his return fromn injury. He is probably there becuase he is safe without being exciting. 4
16-Afamasaga=Didnt see much of him. ???
17-Tsoulos=looks like he may have rei jured his shoulder but kept up with the fast pace iof the game and in soem areas poverpowered the Penrith forwards.

There you have it my views. I didnt see much for the hill but thats just my instinct on how they played. Looks promising. :?
 

Utey

Coach
Messages
19,328
Everybody played well we were just outclassed. Its not as if we didnt stick it to them but the panthers have the ability to do wat we did but for the full 80 minutes. I styill think hopkins has to go
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,095
Hurriflatch said:
yet again, Phillips' credibility falls

Can it get any lower??

Well he could be doing Gary Freeman type ratings....actually - Phillips, are you Gary Freeman? :lol:
 

Misty Bee

First Grade
Messages
7,082
After a brief absence my much loved and ever reliablepoints system has returned!!!

McKINNON - 7 Some positional play erors allowed tries, but generally was safe and sound, with some excition defence

PETERSON - his usual ball of energy. Great skill in placing the ball for his try. Bleeding happily for the Eels, even in defeat! 6

LANGI - his ball skills are coming along nicely. His best game yet. 6

BURT - He isn't a bloody centre!!! 4

GRAHAM - Great catch. Good effort getting bak into the field opf play. Otherwise solid without being impressive. 6

WAGON. Actually passed the ball a bit in the first half. Died in the arse in the second. 6

WITT - not effective as a playmaker. 5

VELLA - A blinder of a first half. That hit on Lang - then that try - awesome. Tired later in he game, but gave it his best. 7

MORRIS - Tried everything. Kicking from dummy half isn't easy. IMHO our best. 8

PEARSON - Inneffective. 4

HINDMARSH - His usual busy game. Dropped ball at the end of a run cost us, as did the dropped ball on the 20. Otherwise the usual Hindy game. 7

STAPLETON - Solid withouit being spectacular - 6

MUCKERT - Participated. 4

WIDDERS. Tried hard - kept their defence honest. 6

AFASAMAGA - Did some special things at times. Developong into a great asett. 7

HOPKINS - Participated. 4

TSOULOS - was Greg Drake like. Fell constantly to low tacklers before the advantage line. 4
 

Utey

Coach
Messages
19,328
I dont understand how we lost. we had so much possession and opportunity. we just cant capiatlise this. Beer and Pizza NIGHTTTT
 

Parra_Boy

Juniors
Messages
238
I don't know how we are rating our players soo high? If they were that high wouldn't they be winning most of their games? Most of them are nothing like they were in 2001 so what would they have been rated then?
 

Utey

Coach
Messages
19,328
I admit i look at those ratings and i was a little to leniant. But sometimes yyou cant help being outclassed.
 

the killer eel

Juniors
Messages
12
The boys played pretty good last night. We were justed beaten by the class of one player , Amos Roberts , the same thing happen last week against the broncos. I think the side needs another play maker to take some pressure of our half and hooker.
 

MitchEel

Juniors
Messages
338
Jack Afa: 7.5. made an impressive break with a great step. solid in defence. A star of the future for parra. :D :D :D :D :D
 

Utey

Coach
Messages
19,328
He had absolutely now game time at all. Bit disappointed. Jack should start with Stapleton and Pearson on the bench.
 
Messages
735
hindy only had one dropped ball, the other one never actually touched the ground.

i think the call came from the touchie - an absolute shocker, considering the break and the flow of play we had at the time.
 

1eyedeel

Juniors
Messages
552
Misty, I think your being harsh on Pearson. His numbers show he was actually very effective - he actually made more metres than any other Eel and was second only to Frank Pritchard (how good would it be if we signed him)..
 
Messages
11,677
UtE, I must digress and say that you an't give players 7s and 8s when we didn't really play that well in the second half.

Mist, probably your best ratings yet, with some errors, because for once you didn't do what UtE did and give too high scores across the board. Must say the "Participated" comments made me laugh.

Although McKinnon played well, I must say that his play on Roberts' bombs was not good (although hard to shut down such excellent kicks) and gave Penruff good field position that played against us.
 

Latest posts

Top