Player ratings against rabbits.

[Booyah]

get nutters the f**k outta my team

disgrace

how many penaltys did he concede? all of em

isemonger can f**k off and close the door behind him

ive had him

 

[Coastal Shark]

Between the whole team they earned 9 from me and that's only cause Souths let us score 12. Absolutely disgraceful.

 

[Booyah]

i got a player rating for youse

adam mcdoogall: 10/10
luke mcdoogall: 10/10

both f**king shark juniors!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[ali]

Galloway - Doesn't have enough skil for first grade. Reminds me of Don Tweddle when he takes a run. Slow, unaggressive and...lame.

at the rest. But I can't agree with your criticism of Galloway. He's doing the job an 18-year old frontrower should be doing - hitting it up, getting it over the advantage line, no mistakes and no penalties, and an offload here and there. You can't expect miracles this early, it's the other forwards who are letting us down.

Max you are way off the money with Galloway. I thought he was our best forward going forward and the stats back me up. All our forwards averaged less than 8 metres a hit up, with Stevo the 2nd best. Galloway got 83m from 9 hitups, which is an average of over 9, making him by far our most effective metre getter. No errors at all and one offload (of which he has much potential to improve here.) The only weakness I can see in the kid is a problem locking up the ball when defending, as was seen in the Dogs winning try 2 weeks back. He shouldn't be hanging his head in shame after his performance tonight.

 

[eternaltreblinka]

The only worry I have with Galloway is the similarity to Lance Thompson. :shock:

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Spot on Ali.
thats why I gave Galls a 7.
I thought he was our best forward.
I am worried for Beats. He is trying hard but I question his fitness.
One of his tackles led to a try tonight so that was a 6 point defensive play.

 

[King of the Hill]

Peachey 5
Symmonds 2.5
Mcgoldie 4
Franze 2
Saleh 6
Bird -10000000000000000000000000000000000000
Kimmorley 6
Stevo 5
Bosnich 5
Nutley 0
Bailey 2
Isemonger 1
Hilder 5
Galloway 7
Sullivan 5
beattie 2
Bickers 6

 

[beekershark]

i agree, galloway was one of the few who cab be assured of a first grade spot next week.

 

[millersnose]

Peachey 3
Symmonds 3
Mcgoldie 4
Franze 3
Saleh 6
Bird -1

Kimmorley 6
Stevo 6
Bosnich 2
Nutley 5
Bailey 5
Isemonger 3
Hilder 5
Galloway 6
Sullivan 4
beattie 6
Bickers 6

 

[blacktip-reefy]

You must give a lot of points for effor Millers.
Because that is all BK had last night.
His running game was non existent.
He kicked on the 3rd & 4th & always ran on the 5th.
He missed 7 or 8 tackles.
He did not support.

I expect far more from our 400k man. Much much more.

at least he kicked 100%

BTW you gave peach 3, that shows your throwing a line or didn't watch the game.
The Peach was the first player there & made every tackle on the downtowns. He tried to create some stuff & did. Both line breaks being the work of Peach & Saleh.

 

[lolesi]

How can some of u keep bagging Saleh? everytime he has played for sharks this year he has not let anyone down, and he has actually played well, safe as a bank, he was one of our best easily last night

 

[SirShire]

Too right Lolesi.

Idiots.

 

[millersnose]

well we could argue all day reefy

kimmorley made some great kicks and was instrumental in setting up tries

i still only rated him 6

peachey did f**k all in attack and missed tackles that ultimately led to bunny tries

isnt he supposed to be origin level?

its how i saw it

 

[blacktip-reefy]

No that was Noddy misses that led to tries.
But mostly the centres & in particluar franze.
Peachey was down for 5 misses of which 3 were on kick chases.


BTW You weren't too happy with peacheys grubber a few weeks ago. Do you like those types of grubbers now? The ones where the other team scores.

 

[millersnose]

No that was Noddy misses that led to tries.
But mostly the centres & in particluar franze.
Peachey was down for 5 misses of which 3 were on kick chases.


BTW You weren't too happy with peacheys grubber a few weeks ago. Do you like those types of grubbers now? The ones where the other team scores.

kimmorleys kick was a disaster

but as he does most of the kicking he is going to be expected to make more errors

kimmorley didnt play well reefy no doubt

peachey didnt have any joy either

 

[blacktip-reefy]

I thought Peachey was our most dangerous player by far.
below his best, but very good in team out of puff.

He had twice the game Kimmorley had in half the touches.