Player Ratings...if you dare!

[Barromundi]

Goodwin 3 - Still sh*t after 3 games, offers nothing.
Fego 8 - Some advice for the youg guy, find a new club, you are better than this sh*t.
Williams 3 - Avergage average player!
Pomeroy -99 - He is the most consistently hopless player I have witnessed in the NRL. Was it 4 dropped balls and 3 missed tackles that lead to tries?
Covell 1 - Must go. offers nothing, too slow and cant react to any attacking raids.
Barret 4 - Average display by someone who is meant to be a ball player.
Green 2 - Should stick to the NSW Cup, gave us nothing and no repeat sets to speak of.
Snowden 5 - If he actually ran hard he would be okay....but he rarely does.
Hughes 0 - OMG.........if I start to write about this f**k I wont stop!
Mannah 2 - Is he actually a prop, did he line up for one hitup?
Vea 8 - Okay in a team of mindas
Topou 7 - Read Fergo
Gallen 8 - As above

Douglas - 5 He usual hard working game but he wil never be a Pricey or Petero
Seu Seu - 7 Tried hard and was the only player who pressured the kicker, why he was pulled I dont know, maybe super coach Ricky can explain.
Millington - 6 meh......
Stapelton 8 I like what i saw, he had some ticker unlike another 13 or so!

 

[Alan Shore]

Goodwin - 0
Ferguson - 6
Pomeroy - 0
Williams - 3
Covell - 3
Barrett - 5
Green - 3
Snowden - 4
Hughes - 0
Mannah - 4
Douglas - 6
Tupou - 7
Gallen - 7

Vea - 7
Seu Seu - 6
Millington - 5
Stapleton - 7

 

[Selachimorpha]

There is no negative number large enough to properly express how bad Pomeroy was. Hughes, only very slightly better than that.

Gallen, Tupou & Douglas tried. Vea looks like a keeper, and Ferguson & Stapleton did OK with the opportunities they had. Everyone else was sh*t.

 

[cjs1822]

pomeroy=−∞

 

[Plastered]

f**k me, best crowd of the year, if the club ever needed a win it is now, and we are served up this shyte....f**k I feel let down...6000 for Warriors?

No kick chase...no pressure on their kicker...boring as f**k in attack...my 4 year old daughter could work out what needs fixing...

Goodwin 5 - only played what 25 minutes or so? average
Fergo 6 - Not bad..shows glimpses and better than the rest...
Williams 3 - sigh...we are well and truly farked for centres...
Pomeroy -999 - I'll add another 9...disgusting...had NFI in defence...I could catch better with 2 frying pans...go away please...now
Covell 4 - Was made to look bad trying to cover up for Pom, was left trying to defend 2 or 3 players...
Barret 6 - The only one who looked likely in attack, but kept on getting tackled on the 5th which isn't a good thing when Green is left to kick!!
Green 1 - f**king joke...Soward gave him a lesson in how to kick....offers nada...
Snowden 4 - Ahh Snowy I though you were looking good last year...this year you are a pile of sh*t
Hughes -998 - f**k OFF!!
Mannah 4 - Young but for farks sake take a few hit ups....
Vea 7 - Happy with him, looks likely
Topou 8 - Total class, pity about the rest
Gallen 7 - I wish Gall's passion would rub off on the rest

Douglas - 6 No problems with Dougie
Seu Seu - 7 please try him for 80...
Millington - 6 went OK
Stapelton 8 1st grade for the rest of the year thankyou very much

If Orcher doesn't get a go next week then I'll do something....drastic...please...looo looo wee waaa neh neh neh...the pelicans are eating my eyeballs....pleeease Ricky I'm going f**king crazy :crazy:

 

[Eion]

There is no negative number large enough to properly express how bad Pomeroy was. Hughes, only very slightly better than that.

Gallen, Tupou & Douglas tried. Vea looks like a keeper, and Ferguson & Stapleton did OK with the opportunities they had. Everyone else was sh*t.

Ditto. Really f**king disappointing. 9/10ths of the people out there were sharks fans and they dish up that sh*te...

 

[Alex Krycek]

Pomeroy -99 - He is the most consistently hopless player I have witnessed in the NRL. Was it 4 dropped balls and 3 missed tackles that lead to tries?

Close, it was 3 dropped balls in the first half, his defensive f**k ups directly lead to 4 tries all up. The only try he wasn't directly responsible for was the one that went two metres forward.

 

[Alex Krycek]

Overall, I'm proud of the effort put forward by everybody barring Pomeroy. The game was really lost in the props. They had Poore and Weyman absolutely destroying us and we had no one.

 

[snoozer]

poms and hughes go now.

goodwin, covell and green not too far away from reggies either.

gallen, toops, baz, vea and dougy put in.

millo, snowy and mannah need to improve.

seu, fergo and williams went ok.

stapo. what a breath of fresh air watching him was.he better be there next week.

 

[Frenzy.]

Some of you don't watch the games very closely do you? Or have no fuggen idea.

Goodwin 6 - made 2 line breaks. 63 metres off only 6 runs. No errors, no missed tackles. Brought the ball back harder and faster than his last 2 games and could be seen sniffing around the middle the whole time he was on. Might of got a try but for a bum forward pass call.
Ferguson 7 - learnt from last week and stayed inside touch. Sign of a good player. 6 tackle breaks! Handled Dell pretty well.
Pomeroy 4 - sad
Williams 6 - He's not a centre but tried his guts out for the team. Made a few good runs, broke tackles, broke the line and fired up nicely at that little homo Soward.
Covell 4 - uninvolved
Barrett 7 - Made errors for sure but he's making them because he's the only creative back in the team. He has too much to try and do. He's an island in a sea of bums so it must be hard to keep his head above water.
Green 4 - Major disappoinment. Put CU2 at half.
Snowden 7 - Despite being thrown around like a rag doll he kept coming. Made FORTY FIVE tackles. This blunted him in attack.
Hughes 6 - Mainly because he didn't really do anything that badly wrong. He plugged the ruck well and made 31 tackles in about 40 minutes of game time. His problem is that he has become too slow. Slow in the legs, slow in the hands and slow in the head. But he tried really hard
Mannah 3 - Not ready. Not hard enough yet. He could be the forwards version of TDD.
Douglas 6 - better game from Douge but if there's one bloke playing fatigued, it's Dougie. Eighty four consecutive games since his rookie debut is starting to take it's toll. He's stale and boring.
Tupou 7 - standard
Gallen 8 Standard
Seu Seu 6 - make him halfback.
Vea 3 - Hits like a jellyfish and has the offensive impact of a wet sponge
Millington 4 - he's a trier. That's all
Stapleton 6 - He caught the ball. He made a couple of nice 1 on 1 tackles. He ran it, albeit with not much force. He did his job well for the sitch he was thrown into. He may as well stay in the team now. The team isn't going anywhere in 2009 so may as well keep all the young ones in now. Blood a few more. Fugg the salary cap and it's fines. We probably won't have to worry about paying a fine anyway. No blood in a stone

 

[Fuddy]

Some of you don't watch the games very closely do you? Or have no fuggen idea.

Goodwin 6 - made 2 line breaks. 63 metres off only 6 runs. No errors, no missed tackles. Brought the ball back harder and faster than his last 2 games and could be seen sniffing around the middle the whole time he was on. Might of got a try but for a bum forward pass call.

I gotta agree on Goodwin Frenz - thought he looked pretty good and far more settled in 1st grade.

Williams played pretty well in the centres considering he's a back rower - he was considerably better than our rep centre who played on the other side.

I'm a huge fan of Covell but he is struggling big time.

Thought Millington looked strong first half - was much quieter after that.

Agree with rest

 

[Surely]

Tupou, gallen, dougie, goodwin, williams, stapleton and ferguson played well the rest should feel ashamed that they get paid for playing.

 

[broncos70]

at no time this year did mannah expect to/or was told he would play first grade this year,let alone start, so no1 should be giving him any stick..
he'll aim up next week against his brother definitely

 

[coolumsharkie]

I think Sticky is doing the right thing in blooding these youngsters, for a few reasons but mainly to get them used to FG. Plenty of pontential in this lot.

This season is a right off, so i think it's a good thing. Like a years worth of trial games.

 

[DJDL]

Unfortunately Coolio that's a out the size of it.
I think it's time to punt Pom/Cov and see what else we have out there.

And I'm not happy with Reece at centre. He tried his guts out sure but there were a heap of occasions he was put outside his man but didn't have the speed or footwork to capitalise, nor the hands to get it out to Ferguson. Tackled into touch twice too. Not good enough IMHO.

I can understand him being there to cover for Fergusons defensive problems, but in attack maybe they should be switched.

 

[millersnose]

Goodwin 5
Fego 6
Williams 6
Pomeroy 4
Covell 4 there is something wrong with their defence
Barret 4 - At least the kids have an excuse
Green 6
Snowden 6
Hughes 4
Mannah 4
Vea 5
Topou 7 -
Gallen 8 -

Douglas - 6
Seu Seu - 6.
Millington - 6
Stapelton 6

 

[DaSuperHero2]

This Corey Hughes has to be one of the most useless players.

 

[Mr Angry]

It hurts to watch.

 

[spider]

I thought wombat did ok

Got himself in the right poisiton and line to receive the ball many times

Lacks pace though to do any damage

 

[DJDL]

That's my problem with him Spide. The opportunities are there, he is just not the guy to capitalise.