One positive is getting BennyV to see the light at the end of the tunnel and admit his lord and savior, Gareth Widdop, doesn't deserve to be rated highly. No such luck for Old Timer. I suspect he will be rocking back and forth and mumbling about how Marshall is to blame for Widdop's useless for some years yet.
One positive is getting BennyV to see the light at the end of the tunnel and admit his lord and savior, Gareth Widdop, doesn't deserve to be rated highly. No such luck for Old Timer. I suspect he will be rocking back and forth and mumbling about how Marshall is to blame for Widdop's useless for some years yet.
As I posted several times you read very little and comprehend less and less.
I have posted many times about my abject disappointment in Widdop's performances this year so your efforts to gode are futile.
On the subject of how we rate players you have asked several times about this one or that one v Widdop.
Your question is quite absurd and highly flawed as you are comparing halves against a 5/8.
So in effect IMO what should ask is one of the following questions.
a) If any of the halves previously mentioned played half at St George this year instead of Benji would Widdop have gone better?
or
b) If Benji had of played 5/8 instead of Widdop would we have gone better?
In relation to answers to the correct questions
a) The answer is obviously yes as I rate all of them better halves than Benji.
b) Not sure as it would probably depend on the half chosen to play with him and also the fact Benji hasn't played 5/8 for 2-3 years and he was playing so poorly in that position at the Tigers they were happy to see him go to Rugby where he did anything else but excel.
Now I believe that should clear it up for you quite nicely.
