Ratings

[nqboy]

Bloody stupid ratings to be frank.

Francis Meli gets a 5 when the likes of Toopi and Vagana get a 6? Do you actually watch the game? I presume the answer will be a big fat NO? Meli had a strong game, not many if any mistakes, compared to Toopi who tried to offload throughout the game and turned over the ball 3 times as a result.

So Louis Anderson lacks class aye? He was the top tackler in the match, and has an outstanding work rate. Shame that I thought his try assist had abit of "class" about it.... :roll:

Paul was ineffective? Of course he was, considering he basically had no time to shine in the match. Should start next game. Any NRL starting halfback is better than Leuluai, and I'm serious.

Kidwell a 6? It was one penalty, not "penalties". He had a solid match, no mistakes whatsoever.

I guess you're entitled to your opinion, even if you are wrong. And even that with the benefits of stats and replays. I posted mine immediately after the match without access to either stats or replay to provoke discussion but all you want to do is take potshots, lacking the courage to post your ratings. Kiss my ass.

 

[CouldaBeenAnything]

Kidwell was penalised twice early in the game, the second one led to the first GB points I think (could be wrong here)...other than that he was good. he does put in and his heart and enthusiasm cannot be questioned.

It just didn't look like the Kiwis came out after halftime...which was a shame cause at one stage in the first half, they looked like they could score 40 points in the game

 

[Dr Crane]

Has Benji Marshall definately declared himself available for NZ? He could really make a difference to that side if he continues to develop.

I believe he has.

 

[shiznit]

yeah he's made himself available for the kiwis. so he bloody should though. its not as if hes even close to being an aussie.

 

[Ray]

Bloody stupid ratings to be frank.

Francis Meli gets a 5 when the likes of Toopi and Vagana get a 6? Do you actually watch the game? I presume the answer will be a big fat NO? Meli had a strong game, not many if any mistakes, compared to Toopi who tried to offload throughout the game and turned over the ball 3 times as a result.

So Louis Anderson lacks class aye? He was the top tackler in the match, and has an outstanding work rate. Shame that I thought his try assist had abit of "class" about it.... :roll:

Paul was ineffective? Of course he was, considering he basically had no time to shine in the match. Should start next game. Any NRL starting halfback is better than Leuluai, and I'm serious.

Kidwell a 6? It was one penalty, not "penalties". He had a solid match, no mistakes whatsoever.

I guess you're entitled to your opinion, even if you are wrong. And even that with the benefits of stats and replays. I posted mine immediately after the match without access to either stats or replay to provoke discussion but all you want to do is take potshots, lacking the courage to post your ratings. Kiss my ass.

Ouch. Sorry Mr Courageous. ;-)

 

[Tidus_Raider]

look here is NZ best team
1. Webb
2. Vanikolo
3. N.Vangana
4. C.Toopi
5. M.Utai
6. Marshall
7. Jones

8. J.Cayless
9. Paul
10. Wiki
11. Pulatua
12. Ngulavo(spelling)
13. Williams

if only they could get that side on the pitch

I would have Lolesi in their somewhere.