Rd 18 v Storm

[Iamback]

Martin and NAS full pelt at each other would be a throwback to Spud vs Chief, it would go close to splitting an atom.

The refs would bin both for having evil eyes

 

[WestyLife]

The refs would bin both for having evil eyes

They'll be binned for unnecessary forceful contact putting space and time at risk.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Didnt watch Melbourne this week but NAS has been spending time on an edge, need to look at how we will cover that especially if he lines up against cogger, Put Martin on him he loves a big fella like that, he can charge him and not have to worry about late footwork beating him.

NAS on edge against our system will be far less effective than against most other teams.

You need fit mobile edge forwards against us.

 

[Alintheeast]

If you can handle JWH you can handle NAS, 2 good props and a fearless 2nd rower. Would prefer Martin target Munster watched Origin 1 Munster’s ribs seemed to be looking out for Marto.

 

[betcats]

I'd be sending Soni back to cup for a bit more game time and keeping Smith in the rotation. If Kenny gets a bit loose Salmon to 6 & Luai to 9 for 10 or 15 minutes.

Dont like the idea of moving Luai during the game, If Soni wasnt to play I think Salmon would be a decent option for Soni's minutes at hooker. He wouldnt be a huge threat running he doesnt have the speed but he would certainly be less shy about running than Kenny is and his passing and defence are good enough imo. We can get by with a ten to fifteen minute stint from the back up hooker I wouldnt mind seeing what Salmon can do there. Since Soni isnt providing the impact we hoped for we just need someone to hold down the fort and take the obvious chances to run and provide decent service the rest of the time.

 

[soc123_au]

Dont like the idea of moving Luai during the game, If Soni wasnt to play I think Salmon would be a decent option for Soni's minutes at hooker. He wouldnt be a huge threat running he doesnt have the speed but he would certainly be less shy about running than Kenny is and his passing and defence are good enough imo. We can get by with a ten to fifteen minute stint from the back up hooker I wouldnt mind seeing what Salmon can do there. Since Soni isnt providing the impact we hoped for we just need someone to hold down the fort and take the obvious chances to run and provide decent service the rest of the time.

I'd be happy enough with that, as you say it wouldn't be a bad thing to see how he goes there. More options is better.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Dont like the idea of moving Luai during the game, If Soni wasnt to play I think Salmon would be a decent option for Soni's minutes at hooker. He wouldnt be a huge threat running he doesnt have the speed but he would certainly be less shy about running than Kenny is and his passing and defence are good enough imo. We can get by with a ten to fifteen minute stint from the back up hooker I wouldnt mind seeing what Salmon can do there. Since Soni isnt providing the impact we hoped for we just need someone to hold down the fort and take the obvious chances to run and provide decent service the rest of the time.

I agree, Salmon would get the job done.

 

[martielang]

Salmondo diving over from 1m was prime Priddis.

 

[maple_69]

Martin running at NAS I'd say is even money. NAS running at Martin and NAS's ribs are the only thing losing.

Agree Luke needs a stint in Cup. Kenny has improved to the point of being vaguely ok but both service & defence gets worse when Luke comes on and we're not seeing much the other way in terms of creativity/zip out of the ruck that you'd want to justify it.

I wonder if we'd look at Cogger as 14 when Cleary is back as we did against the Dragons before the option was removed. Seems ok in defence (20 min stint) and might offer better vision, kicking etc during the soft minutes.

 

[betcats]

Martin running at NAS I'd say is even money. NAS running at Martin and NAS's ribs are the only thing losing.

Agree Luke needs a stint in Cup. Kenny has improved to the point of being vaguely ok but both service & defence gets worse when Luke comes on and we're not seeing much the other way in terms of creativity/zip out of the ruck that you'd want to justify it.

I wonder if we'd look at Cogger as 14 when Cleary is back as we did against the Dragons before the option was removed. Seems ok in defence (20 min stint) and might offer better vision, kicking etc during the soft minutes.

Cogger so far appears to good to be in cup. That being said when ive watched him in cup he hasnt exactly been a stand out. Wouldnt be against him being used as a back up hooker, he'd be perfect for it if his defence was a bit more solid. Genuine kicking option, good enough passing game and he likes the dummy and go when he sees a tired forward.

 

[Hamstring awareness]

Katoa should be back for Melbourne so unlikely NAS plays on an edge IMO

 

[Iamback]

Cogger so far appears to good to be in cup. That being said when ive watched him in cup he hasnt exactly been a stand out. Wouldnt be against him being used as a back up hooker, he'd be perfect for it if his defence was a bit more solid. Genuine kicking option, good enough passing game and he likes the dummy and go when he sees a tired forward.

He has been shown up a few times in defence but generally seems ok, If he is staying next year. Having him play some 14 makes sense. Even give Critter an early mark one game try him at centre for a bit

 

[BossleyPanther]

Can't spend 55% plus and only be 6 Infront in this game.

 

[snickers007]

Can't spend 55% plus and only be 6 Infront in this game.

The extra class that the Origin boys bring should ensure we capitilise on more of our opportunities.

 

[Bob]

He has been shown up a few times in defence but generally seems ok, If he is staying next year. Having him play some 14 makes sense. Even give Critter an early mark one game try him at centre for a bit

Try him at centre, did you go to the Brad Fittler school of coaching

 

[Kilkenny]

Wife and I are in Melbourne for this game.

She can’t currently go to our home ground due to mobility issues, but we can see us away in a mobility friendly stadium. Go figure.

I’ve been to Marvel Stadium for AFL and A League but first time to see us there against the Storm.

I suspect a really tough game in front of us. They haven’t been perfect, but are close to full strength and will be up for it.

Looking forward it.

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Wife and I are in Melbourne for this game.

She can’t currently go to our home ground due to mobility issues, but we can see us away in a mobility friendly stadium. Go figure.

I’ve been to Marvel Stadium for AFL and A League but first time to see us there against the Storm.

I suspect a really tough game in front of us. They haven’t been perfect, but are close to full strength and will be up for it.

Looking forward it.

Enjoy Kilkenny. Melbourne is a cool city; hope you can make your way around it easy enough.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Wife and I are in Melbourne for this game.

She can’t currently go to our home ground due to mobility issues, but we can see us away in a mobility friendly stadium. Go figure.

I’ve been to Marvel Stadium for AFL and A League but first time to see us there against the Storm.

I suspect a really tough game in front of us. They haven’t been perfect, but are close to full strength and will be up for it.

Looking forward it.

I understand what you're saying about mobility issues, and our current home ground. I'm in a similar position.

So good that you and yours can get down to Melbourne. Yell loud, drown out those ringing cowbells please. Enjoy yourselves.

 

[Black Panther]

Try him at centre, did you go to the Brad Fittler school of coaching

That’s what I thought. People here are saying no to Cogger at Hooker, then play him at Centre appears. Pretty funny.
Trying Cogger as a backup 9 has merit, most halves are comfortable playing 9 these days with most of the same skill sets.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Pretty weak bench but nothing we haven't discussed before