Ref and Bunker Decisions

[kurt faulk]

.

I love how the idiot Queenslanders think they got dudded. The ref could have gone to town on them with the way they kept holding the ball carrier down on the ground. Idiots.

.

 

[Saxon]

.

I love how the idiot Queenslanders think they got dudded. The ref could have gone to town on them with the way they kept holding the ball carrier down on the ground. Idiots.

.

Ahh. New South Wails. Even when they win you whine.

And here was me thinking you'd be happy having brought your series win rate for the last 20 years up to 30%.

 

[kurt faulk]

Ahh. New South Wails. Even when they win you whine.

And here was me thinking you'd be happy having brought your series win rate for the last 20 years up to 30%.

I don't care about origin.

.

 

[Saxon]

I don't care about origin.

.

Oh, obviously.

 

[Diesel]

Bunker chooses not to look at the broncos knocking the ball over the dead ball like. Replay confirm it. Ref says no challenge time is up after Frizelle sees it on the big screen. What do the bunker look at

 

[Vee]

Kenny on Katoa is not a penalty imo.

If that is the rule, the non-offending side should have the choice for the location of the penalty. Easier kick where the offence occurred than where the ball landed. The rule was about yardage gain but in the modern game, crossfield kicks are so common, it should be changed.

 

[MKCS]

Not a trip. Play on

 

[MKCS]

DCE prevents the Titans from scoring by grabbing a leg to prevent a quick play the ball, no professional foul, no sin bin and 60 seconds later Manly race down the other side and score.

 

[snickers007]

Kenny on Katoa is not a penalty imo.

If that is the rule, the non-offending side should have the choice for the location of the penalty. Easier kick where the offence occurred than where the ball landed. The rule was about yardage gain but in the modern game, crossfield kicks are so common, it should be changed.

Speaking of "choose your advantage", in the first half, Panthers winger jumps from the in goal, and catches the ball on the full despite being tackled in the air.

Ref penalises. Panthers get a free kick 1m from the sideline, 10m out from goal line. Due to the angle of the kick, Panthers only make ~10m with the kick.

So instead of 20m tap from the centre and 7 tackles, Panthers get a 20m tap, 10m in and only 6 tackles.

Surely the greater advantage is the 7 tackles set?

 

[mave]

DCE prevents the Titans from scoring by grabbing a leg to prevent a quick play the ball, no professional foul, no sin bin and 60 seconds later Manly race down the other side and score.

Thanks for your input, Desmond