What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Ricky Stuart Should Be Dropped!

4wardPass

Juniors
Messages
66
Ok it's not fully his fault but neither was the tri nations loss 3 years ago wayne's fault but Ricky and others called for wayne's sacking.

Instead wayne stepped down under the pressure of the press and so called experts those that wanted the job.

Well rickys turn now if you ask me, he coached them to the final not loosing a game, but that all means jack the final is what counts!!!

Ricky Stuart should step down or be sacked as Australian coach!
 

thommo4pm

Coach
Messages
14,814
The coach is to blame for the selections, and he had some horrible selections in that team last night.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,306
Questions have to be asked though.

Since 2003 he has lost 2 NRL Grand Finals, Left the Roosters when they were at the bottom of the ladder.

Built the Sharks up nicely now, but they fell out of last years finals in embarrassing fashion.

And now lost the World Cup.

I'm not saying sack the guy. He had us playing good footy and this is only his second loss out of about 14 games in charge of the Kangaroos.

But perhaps questions should be asked..
 

4wardPass

Juniors
Messages
66
It's that what ricky demanded when the roos lost the tri nations under Wayne Bennett ?

I remember him being one of the loudest voices in the media bashing wayne.
 

4wardPass

Juniors
Messages
66
Questions have to be asked though.

Since 2003 he has lost 2 NRL Grand Finals, Left the Roosters when they were at the bottom of the ladder.

Built the Sharks up nicely now, but they fell out of last years finals in embarrassing fashion.

And now lost the World Cup.

But perhaps questions should be asked..


Yep how many finals has he won ? 0 from my memory!
 
Messages
17,821
Take a look at the players that did not stand up:

I would be questioning the likes of Fitzgibbon, Watmough, Smith and Inglis...all MIA.
 

thommo4pm

Coach
Messages
14,814
Take a look at the players that did not stand up:

I would be questioning the likes of Fitzgibbon, Watmough, Smith and Inglis...all MIA.

You can add Thurston, Gallen, & Topou to that list.
I thought Inglis tried but he was heavily marked and kept out of the match.
 

4wardPass

Juniors
Messages
66
Take a look at the players that did not stand up:

I would be questioning the likes of Fitzgibbon, Watmough, Smith and Inglis...all MIA.

Fitzgibbon was only inthere cause hes ricky's mate, come on hes like a 150 years old and drops the ball more than any other forward!

If ricky and fitzy didn't play together and stuff would he have been in the australian team ? Not likely!
 
Messages
17,821
Fitzgibbon was only inthere cause hes ricky's mate, come on hes like a 150 years old and drops the ball more than any other forward!

If ricky and fitzy didn't play together and stuff would he have been in the australian team ? Not likely!

Agree...bad choice.
 

4wardPass

Juniors
Messages
66
And questions need to be asked about Slatter too

He effectively gave them 6 pts from that stuppid pass on the sideline, maybe he thought the fullback would be back there oh crap hes the fullback lol

He also did something like that for queensland a fee years ago. Hes a great player but hes not the best fullback hunt was better.
 

orochimaru

Juniors
Messages
443
A way better team could have been picked

It's like some of our players weren't even interested in the game, just irritating really
 

Knightmare

Coach
Messages
10,715
It wasn't Sticky's fault Slater had that brain-fart last night, and neither is it his fault that while Australia cruised into the final with a 50 point walloping of Fiji, NZ had a tough game against England to prepare them for the big one...
 

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
Hard call on Stuart to be dropped, but Australia played all year with cute selections. From the start, the likes of Ryles, Hindmarsh and O'Meley were never going to get a look in - and in hindsight Dallas Johnson, Danny Buderus and Justin Hodges would have been handy inclusions, too.

Too much was made of Inglis' brilliance, which only shows when the forwards are winning the ruck and his halves give great service.

Slater cost us a try, but engineered at least two. Watmough also had a big part to play in Heather's second try. Thurston could have engineered the big comeback play late in the game had Jeremy Smith not ankle tapped him.

Cameron Smith, like Inglis, went MIA. Slater had a dig, IMHO his biggest blunder was being absent when Jeremy Smith strolled through.

Where Sticky and the selectors went wrong was not having the foresight to have a forward leader to take the reigns when the going got tough - read Hindmarsh, Ryles and Mason (who is still possibly injured). Even the likes of Carl Webb and Nate Myles could have produced that when the Kiwis surged home.

And cutie as the utility? What does he add? Clearly Kidley was missed, but since Craig Wing, Australia has not developed anyone for that role, when Prince, Farah, Cronk, Lyon, Mullen, Rogers, Anasta or Bowen provide a pool of players capable of filling that role with development and experience.

To call for Stuart's sacking is a bit harsh, though. Bennet lost a home test to NZ and made some bizare selections (Waterhouse in the centres) in the run up to the 05 loss. At least Stuart had the Kangaroos in the game until the end. He also fronted the media, and didn't use the secret tunnel from Suncorp to platform 3 at Roma St station to avoid the media.
 

Moffo

Referee
Messages
23,986
good post mate, hard to argue with that

i dont see mason and webb as leaders though. they are both the kings of MIA
 

Latest posts

Top