Rookie of the Year

[betcats]

Lol maybe you can.

But I was responding to your point that "neither even won the award"

If you reckon Tom T would not have won if a few games the previous year hadn't disqualified him, then good luck to you.

Ok well I'll just keep dealing with the facts while you live in fantasy land.

 

[Tommy Smith]

NSW should throw caution to the wind next year and unleash the rookie backs on QLD:

1. Tedesco
2. Cotric
3. Mitchell
4. Trbojevic
5. Addo Carr
7. Cleary

Might not win (won't anyway) but at least it'll be super entertaining for once.

Better than watching the likes of Fergo, Dugan, Maloney and yes, Pearce, plod it up gangnam style.

 

[TheFrog]

Dylan Edwards.

 

[Clifferd]

NSW should throw caution to the wind next year and unleash the rookie backs on QLD:

1. Tedesco
2. Cotric
3. Mitchell
4. Trbojevic
5. Addo Carr
7. Cleary

Might not win (won't anyway) but at least it'll be super entertaining for once.

Better than watching the likes of Fergo, Dugan, Maloney and yes, Pearce, plod it up gangnam style.

Might happen but that won't be the backline.

If NSW were smart they wouldn't pick Dugan/Fergo either, and Morris has retired

This is what id like to see next year -

1. Tedesco
2. Trobjevic
3. Bird/Hayne
4. Walker
5. Mansour
6. Moylan
7. Maloney/Cleary

Basically a whole new backline.

Haynes ego is too big for his own good, would rather him not be there but we all know he will

Can only see rookies like Cotric, Addo-Carr, Roberts, Mitchell getting a run if their were injuries

 

[Nice Beaver]

Ok well I'll just keep dealing with the facts while you live in fantasy land.

Jesus. Righto legend.

CWN for rookie of the year in 2017 and I am living in fantasy land....

 

[dogz08]

matt frawley..

 

[betcats]

Jesus. Righto legend.

CWN for rookie of the year in 2017 and I am living in fantasy land....

Hahaha yeah because I really said that, get more butt hurt you idiot. Tommy turbo didn't win rookie of the year pretending otherwise is a fantasy far out how sensitive can you be.

 

[OldPanther]

Jesus. Righto legend.

CWN for rookie of the year in 2017 and I am living in fantasy land....

Did you mean Corey Harawira-Naera(CHN) or is there someone I'm forgetting? Personally I think it should be Cotric. That Sharks bloke was alright but the injury stuffs him. CHN should at least be considered in the conversation, been a very good back rower.

 

[nick87]

Cotric for sure.

The kid is awesome and wouldn't look out of place in a Blues jersey next year if the selectors had some balls.

His kick returns and runs out of his own half are awesome.

And from all reports he's a good kid too with an excellent work ethic so he'll be a superstar for years to come.

Maybe even better than Matt Gaffa!

Haha we can only hope so!
Seriously though Raiders fans love to love their young kids, so it's nice to see others are impressed with him as we are

 

[betcats]

Did you mean Corey Harawira-Naera(CHN) or is there someone I'm forgetting? Personally I think it should be Cotric. That Sharks bloke was alright but the injury stuffs him. CHN should at least be considered in the conversation, been a very good back rower.

I think he means Tom Turbo should win rookie of the year every year.

 

[Cockadoodledoo]

Might happen but that won't be the backline.

If NSW were smart they wouldn't pick Dugan/Fergo either, and Morris has retired

This is what id like to see next year -

1. Tedesco
2. Trobjevic
3. Bird/Hayne
4. Walker
5. Mansour
6. Moylan
7. Maloney/Cleary

Basically a whole new backline.

Haynes ego is too big for his own good, would rather him not be there but we all know he will

Can only see rookies like Cotric, Addo-Carr, Roberts, Mitchell getting a run if their were injuries

Hayne shouldn't be considered. James Roberts would have to be very close to a spot.

 

[Lemon Squash]

Can we vote on WAG of the year? Cameron Munsters new misses has to be 1.01 favourite holy smokes.

 

[M2D2]

and you dont provide pics WHY?

 

[POPEYE]

Hayne shouldn't be considered. James Roberts would have to be very close to a spot.

Fair go, Qld need Hayne to be picked, distractions on the night are more disruptive than drinks with lunch a few days before

 

[Clifferd]

Hayne shouldn't be considered. James Roberts would have to be very close to a spot.

I'd have the jet closely considered after Walker/Bird. His defense concerns me at origin level but

 

[mxlegend99]

Slim pickings this year.

Nick Cotric wins for mine. But the best rookies dont always win. Guys like Tommy Turbo, Cleary etc. All debuted midseason when they had no chance at winning that years award and were ineligible for the following year. Cotric has an advantage in playing all season.

I also think Vunivalu had the better rookie season. Hopefully a good club picks up Cotric so he can go on and be the star we know he is capable of. It would truly suck if his potential was wasted and he just became another Jarrod Croker.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

I'd have the jet closely considered after Walker/Bird. His defense concerns me at origin level but

Agree. Jimmy the Jerk looks to be one of those who is fine at club level but would be found at the next level.
Plus do we really want another known dickhead in the NSW team?

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Cotric's coming up with match winning plays for our sh*t team in his rookie year. Vunivalu was in a good team, and mostly just caught and fell over the line last year.

 

[betcats]

Cotric's coming up with match winning plays for our sh*t team in his rookie year. Vunivalu was in a good team, and mostly just caught and fell over the line last year.

In just saying you could argue it, leading try scorer etc I'm not saying it definite.

Ash Taylor came up with winning plays and got a mediocre side to the 8. I think he has a more impressive rookie year than anyone else the last five years.

 

[mxlegend99]

Cotric's coming up with match winning plays for our sh*t team in his rookie year. Vunivalu was in a good team, and mostly just caught and fell over the line last year.

How many of the Raiders 7 wins were because of him?