Rothfield's Top Fifty

[Non Terminator]

Link

50. Blake FERGUSON (Sharks)
49. Alan TONGUE (Raiders)
48. Ben HORNBY (Dragons)
47. John SUTTON (Rabbitohs)
46. David STAGG (Bulldogs)
45. Roy ASOTASI (Rabbitohs)
44. Jamie LYON (Sea Eagles)
43. Josh DUGAN (Raiders)
42. Chris LAWRENCE (Tigers)
41. Luke LEWIS (Panthers)
40. Manu VATUVEI (Warriors)
39. Daniel MORTIMER (Eels)
38. Jarrod MULLEN (Knights)
37. Luke O'DONNELL (Cowboys)
36. Adam BLAIR (Storm)
35. David TAYLOR (Rabbitohs)
34. Terry CAMPESE (Raiders)
33. Todd CARNEY (Roosters)
32. Jamie SOWARD (Dragons)
31. Steve PRICE (Warriors)
30. Greg BIRD (Titans)
29. Justin HODGES (Broncos)
28. Petero CIVINOCEVA (Panthers)
27. Michael ENNIS (Bulldogs)
26. Israel FOLAU (Broncos)

Who would be in your top fifty?

 

[skeepe]

Some pretty good selections there. I would rate Dugan higher, and Mortimer shouldn't be there at all. Apart from that, I can't see anything to complain about yet. Tomorrow might be another story.

 

[Non Terminator]

So far, Pearce and Tuiaki have missed out, apparently.

 

[Fein]

Some pretty good selections there. I would rate Dugan higher, and Mortimer shouldn't be there at all. Apart from that, I can't see anything to complain about yet. Tomorrow might be another story.

:?

He's probably in the top 25.

 

[Gaba]

So far, Pearce and Tuiaki have missed out, apparently.

:lol: , pearce should never be in the top 50

anasta should be in the top 50 more then pearce should be

But we are talking about rothfield:lol:

rates mortimer in the top 40

 

[Dutchy]

Dear God, Gaba and Skeepe found this thread already.

Note to self: Stay the f**k away from this one.

 

[Gaba]

:lol:

 

[mxlegend99]

How the f*ck is Daniel Mortimer ahead of Luke Lewis? Last year he was leading the Dally M awards before injury, and was recalled to NSW and Australian teams where he was among the better players.

 

[typicalfan]

Dave Taylor ahead of Adam Blair? And Petero should be in the top 10-15 imo at worst. Luke Lewis should be higher than Mortimer and Carney at the very least, best lock in the game bar Bird and maybe Watmough if you count him imo.

 

[Non Terminator]

Lewis should be top twenty-five.
So, who will be top twenty-five...

1 Hayne 2 Hindmarsh 3 Lockyer 4 Inglis 5 Slater 6 Smith 7 Cronk 8 Marshall 9 Farah 10 Cooper 11 Gidley 12 Stewart 13 Prince 14 Thurston 15 Hannant.

Guessing they'll all be there.

 

[Dutchy]

Watmough will be up there after 2009.

 

[Non Terminator]

True, good point.

 

[jc155776]

People get so riled up over such a little thing like "where they should be ranked". By all means discuss it, but some of you act like Rothfield rape your mothers because he put your favourite player behind someone else.

 

[hybrid_tiger]

No Tuiaki?

Anyway, who gives a f**k what Rothfield thinks.

 

[typicalfan]

there has to be more than one prop in the top 25 imo, Sam Burgess may get a mention as well

Kimmorley, Brett Morris, Michael Jennings etc should all be there.

 

[Non Terminator]

People get so riled up over such a little thing like "where they should be ranked". By all means discuss it, but some of you act like Rothfield rape your mothers because he put your favourite player behind someone else.

So far, you're the most riled up one.

 

[Red Bear]

Petro has to be higher than 28th. He'd be one of the first couple of players i would pick in a side.

 

[typicalfan]

Petero is in the top 2 props in the game. Hannant had a superb year last year and will be in the top 25, I feel they will have Moimoi there as well :? not that I agree he is as good as Petero but you get the vibe.

 

[Firey_Dragon]

LOL @ anyone who actually cares what Rothfield thinks, he is far more knowledgeable about downing a glass of cheap scotch than the game of league.

 

[gronkathon]

The only thing Rothfield can accuratley list in a top 50 would be a bang for your buck list of cheap booze