Round 23 v Warriors

[rem286]

The f**k are you on about? The times he came in he wasn't just overlapped 2 to 1 it was 3 to 1 and his offload has always been a weapon that has never lead to mistakes since he's been in first grade.

I can only assume you forgot to put the laughing smiley face at the end of your comment

 

[mxlegend99]

have you watched any of the last games moylan has missed every 1 on 1 tackle he has attemped .He has been nowhere to be seen on line breaks.I do rate moylan as a talent but his form has been down since the Darwin game.He will get his spot back and competiton for places is what will win us more games

I have seen every game.. And at no point has Moylan been as poorly positioned as Coote today. He saves those first 2 tries, and doesnt spill that bomb IMO. But even if he did... He was only equally as bad as Coote. Not worse... As Coote couldnt have possibly been worse in that opening 20 mins or so.

Moylan has flaws for sure. But saying he is that bad is beyond ridiculous. Id back him to save a try over Coote.

 

[chrisD]

I can only assume you forgot to put the laughing smiley face at the end of your comment

I can only assume by the shit you spew that you started watching Penrith and rugby league with year.

 

[TeamSatan]

Ok calm down boys...the panthers cost me plenty of $$ today but thats ok.

Today was a football miracle.

Our form has been terrible
The game was in NZ
The warriors would want revenge for being belted last time.
The big one ....jason was the ref today and even though he tried his best he still couldnt stop us.
Both wingers scored freakish tries...not once but twice..each.

Anyway I agree with MM our forwards were excellent today.
The difference Mckendry makes to Timmys game is huge.
Smith is a far better option than Ciraldo.

Coote....still not match fit and probably a little more gunshy than usual. Will go well at the cowboys.

Really entertaining game today...lets hope we can play like this for the rest of the season.

 

[franklin2323]

Hope none of the Mansour haters jump on his bandwagon now.

There is no Mansour haters.

I would have him in my team on skill no doubt his form has been NSW Cup standard. Though will he back it up this week.

Where was this the last month? Is my question not just him but John & Grant also

 

[franklin2323]

Not saying you are wrong...but it is pretty funny.

I was saying the same thing at the game today. Re- Walsh. The good stuff he does is cancelled out by people just hating him.

Say he had a mask on it would change. Stat's wise his not far off Reynolds only Walsh doesn't have the running game around him.

Same with Coote. Opposite with Mansour & Grant (although lately it's been changing)

If you have the faces blocked out of a few players and people would have different opinions.

On Coote no one stops the tries they let in today.
Try 1.Coote was where Johnson was as 9/10 times he gets it on the last.
Latimore/Manu left the gap for Taylor- no gap no try.
Matagi- he tried but too small no gap he doesn't get through.
Hurrell- Mansour rushes in. Outside backs no where to be seen.

 

[Panther Pete]

The boys showed plenty of ticker to come back from 12 nil down early in the game. Mansour and Simmons scored some amazing tries between them, I think that would makes Simmons leading try scorer for the comp which is pretty impressive considering the teams position on the ladder.

 

[umina panther]

No...just no. The play he got tacked on the 5th with a few mins to go showed just how far from a premiership winning 7 he is. Hopeless

 

[umina panther]

I was saying the same thing at the game today. Re- Walsh. The good stuff he does is cancelled out by people just hating him.

Say he had a mask on it would change. Stat's wise his not far off Reynolds only Walsh doesn't have the running game around him.

Same with Coote. Opposite with Mansour & Grant (although lately it's been changing)

If you have the faces blocked out of a few players and people would have different opinions.

On Coote no one stops the tries they let in today.
Try 1.Coote was where Johnson was as 9/10 times he gets it on the last.
Latimore/Manu left the gap for Taylor- no gap no try.
Matagi- he tried but too small no gap he doesn't get through.
Hurrell- Mansour rushes in. Outside backs no where to be seen.

First one off the kick Coote was nowhere

 

[franklin2323]

Moylan wasn't dropped. He's exemption was withdrawn. So seems like he will end the year at Windsor.

 

[umina panther]

Moylan wasn't dropped. He's exemption was withdrawn. So seems like he will end the year at Windsor.

Can understand that call from a rules standpoint but from 2014 Coote will never play fullback again imo

 

[betcats]

have you watched any of the last games moylan has missed every 1 on 1 tackle he has attemped .He has been nowhere to be seen on line breaks.I do rate moylan as a talent but his form has been down since the Darwin game.He will get his spot back and competiton for places is what will win us more games

Moylan made a great one on one tackle to save try last week on that big cowboys winger.

 

[franklin2323]

First one off the kick Coote was nowhere

The dummy half scooted then kicked. Where were the markers? apart from a dropped kick or not attempting a tackle. I don't blame FB for tries scored.

 

[franklin2323]

No...just no. The play he got tacked on the 5th with a few mins to go showed just how far from a premiership winning 7 he is. Hopeless

Johnson did the same thing. Reynolds has done the same the last month with no Inglis. Don't get me wrong glad he's gone. Soward will be the same people will hate him no matter what he does.

 

[murraymob]

Moylan wasn't dropped. He's exemption was withdrawn. So seems like he will end the year at Windsor.

no he was rested.Just asked mr gould on twitter and he replied he needed a rest

 

[franklin2323]

no he was rested.Just asked mr gould on twitter and he replied he needed a rest

So why not leave him home? Playing for Windsor would of helped more then not playing at all

 

[Big Mick]

I guess needing a rest meant just training.

I'd heard he has had a fair few niggles that have been hampering him. So probably just giving him a week off as maybe one of those had the potential to escalate to something worse should he play.

Given our luck and he played it probably would have.

Can't really blame them for being safe with him considering just re-signing him and him being a likely important fixture for the future.

 

[chrisD]

Masoe had an impact, Manu some, the rest of the forwards dropped where they were hit.

 

[murraymob]

Masoe had an impact, Manu some, the rest of the forwards dropped where they were hit.

grant got 199 meters he was our best

 

[franklin2323]

Can't really blame them for being safe with him considering just re-signing him and him being a likely important fixture for the future.

No issues from me season's gone look to next year. Better off getting guys qualified for lower grades & getting them confidence & form in the finals. A run in Windsor this week is on I would say

Seeing us throw it around made the trip over worth it. Though where was this the last month? That month & the Tigers home game is what's stuffed our season.