Round 3 vs. Bulldogs

[panthersam]

It's team list Tuesday and this week we are coming up against the Bulldogs.

Should be interesting to see who gets picked for us this week, seeing as Grant was apparently good to go last week and was still left out. This is what I'd like to see:

1. Matt Moylan
2. Josh Mansour
3. Dean Whare
4. Jamal Idris
5. Kevin Naiqama
6. Jamie Soward
7. Peter Wallace
8. Brent Kite
9. Kevin Kingston
10. Nigel Plum
11. Lewis Brown (I hope he gets dropped for Manu whenever he is fit)
12. Elijah Taylor
13. Adam Docker

14. James Segyaro
15. Tim Grant/Jeremy Latimore
16. Tyrone Peachey
17. Sam McKendry

I think with our team and how we have played so far this year we should be easily able to account for an under performing Bulldogs side, they still looked extremely average last night against a woeful Sharks team.

 

[Copperhead]

Kite may be in doubt. He was going for scans on a calf injury.

 

[benntash]

Kite may be in doubt. He was going for scans on a calf injury.

In which case Kite out - Grant in. Our depth is amazing

 

[panthersam]

In which case Kite out - Grant in. Our depth is amazing

^ This is what I am so excited about, gone are the days where our replacements are of the likes of Cameron Ciraldo, Danny Galea, Nathan Smith and etc

 

[umina panther]

Unfair to put Nathan Smith with those two imo

 

[mxlegend99]

Agreed. Smith was a solid first grader. Those other guys are poor reserve graders.

 

[mxlegend99]

Also same team as last wee. Just being Soward in for John, Grant in for Latimore unless Kite is ruled out.

Would be tempted to bring Matt Robinson in for Brown. But i haven't seen him play lately to know how his form is. Might even be worth bringing Yeo back in for Brown. He needs a run in reserves to learn the basics again.

 

[franklin2323]

Also same team as last wee. Just being Soward in for John, Grant in for Latimore unless Kite is ruled out.

Would be tempted to bring Matt Robinson in for Brown. But i haven't seen him play lately to know how his form is. Might even be worth bringing Yeo back in for Brown. He needs a run in reserves to learn the basics again.

No one from the lower grades will push anyone out on form.. Just playing terrible atm.

Only changes will be if Soward, Simmons and Grant are fit

 

[panthersam]

What does everybody think should happen with the right wing spot? What are peoples feeling on Naiqama retaining his spot outside Idris?

 

[soc123_au]

Depends on how fit Simmons is. I wouldnt be rushing him back, wouldnt mind seeing Kev get a few weeks to settle in & maybe make a fist of it. If Simmons is 100% he deserves to get his spot back though.

 

[Big Mick]

Depends on how fit Simmons is. I wouldnt be rushing him back, wouldnt mind seeing Kev get a few weeks to settle in & maybe make a fist of it. If Simmons is 100% he deserves to get his spot back though.

Agreed

 

[chrisD]

I don't think NSW cup need to be winning for a player to be dropped and another brought up, individual form may be fine. Brown's form is certainly not fine, it's f**king dire.

 

[franklin2323]

I don't think NSW cup need to be winning for a player to be dropped and another brought up, individual form may be fine. Brown's form is certainly not fine, it's f**king dire.

NSW Cup lost to Wyong for god sake. I am no fan of a few players Brown included but we have been playing well and as such only injuries will change things up

 

[franklin2323]

Depends on how fit Simmons is. I wouldnt be rushing him back, wouldnt mind seeing Kev get a few weeks to settle in & maybe make a fist of it. If Simmons is 100% he deserves to get his spot back though.

No one should play not 100% the wingers especially we have better waiting for a start.

 

[chrisD]

NSW Cup lost to Wyong for god sake. I am no fan of a few players Brown included but we have been playing well and as such only injuries will change things up

Yeah I don't agree with that at all, we have been playing well despite Brown being awful, if we would improve if we dropped him is a very worthy question.

 

[franklin2323]

Yeah I don't agree with that at all, we have been playing well despite Brown being awful, if we would improve if we dropped him is a very worthy question.

I agree.... Ivan though won't do things like that. Hell we were dreadful with Wes at centre and Whare at FB took 6 weeks to fix that

 

[mxlegend99]

1 Moylan
2 Naiqama
3 Whare
4 Idris
5 Mansour
6 Soward
7 Wallace
8 Plum
9 Kingston
10 McKendry
11 Brown
12 Taylor
13 Docker

14 Segeyaro
15 Latimore
16 Peachey
17 Grant

If that runs out, it's the strongest 17 we have fielded this season IMO.

 

[betcats]

1 Moylan
2 Naiqama
3 Whare
4 Idris
5 Mansour
6 Soward
7 Wallace
8 Plum
9 Kingston
10 McKendry
11 Brown
12 Brown
13 Taylor

14 Segeyaro
15 Latimore
16 Peachey
17 Grant

If that runs out, it's the strongest 17 we have fielded this season IMO.

You got 2 browns in there instead of Docker but other then that its what we will see I think.

 

[Copperhead]

Have they really swapped the wingers?

Is Taylor named at lock, or that just a glitch with Brown named twice and Docker not at all?

 

[mxlegend99]

Shit stuffed up the second row. Taylor is second row, Docker lock. Considering Brown is the weakest second rower in the side, it would be horrible to have him twice.