What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rugby calls held

Messages
2,177
Here is an article from fox sport that quotes the outgoing Wallaby coach, Rod Macqueen, as saying Rugby is a rule change away from a 'perfect' game, and saying they need to think 'laterally' about how to handle the 'breakdown' situation.
Does anyone else think it sounds like he is calling for Rugby League style play the balls?

<span>Macqueen: Fix breakdown</span>
1p.gif

<span>From our wire services</span>
1p.gif

<span>15 July 01</span>
1p.gif

<span>News Interactive</span>
1p.gif

<span>FIX the breakdown and rugby would be the greatest game in the world, outgoing Wallabies coach Rod Macqueen said today. </span> <span>Macqueen ended his four-year tenure with the Wallabies after Saturday's 29-23 win over the British and Irish Lions to clinch their first series over the pride of British Isles rugby. Each side in the deciding Test conceded 13 penalties – most of which came at the breakdown, what used to be known as a ruck or maul which has become a point of contention for players and fans alike. Macqueen said finding a definitive way of policing the tackle situation was rugby's ultimate test. "I think rugby at the moment is a terrific game and it's getting better and better but there's one area of the game – the breakdown – that we have to address," Macqueen said. "Maybe we have to think a bit laterally about that. "In the days the laws were made you had rucks and mauls and you had eight forwards from each side running to that area... to expect the referee to make a decision on a ruck and maul in a split second with everything that's going on is impossible. "It's hard for the referees, it's hard for the players and it's hard for the spectators. "When we get that sorted out it'll be a perfect game... the greatest game in the world." The laws governing what can happen at the breakdown have been fluid since rugby went professional in 1995, with the Super 12 and Tri-Nations competitions leading in subtle changes made on an annual basis. The Lions and the Wallabies played two different styles at the breakdown during their engrossing series. Often the Lions resorted to the illegal tactic of using their hands in the ruck because it was the only way they could adapt to the supreme foraging of Australia's outstanding open-side flanker George Smith. It didn't cost the Lions the game, but it didn't win them any admirers among the fans. Lions captain Martin Johnson said it was the single biggest difference between northern and southern hemisphere teams – mainly because the southern hemisphere nations always seem to be at the cutting edge of law changes with their northern counterparts adjusting to the changes. "A few years ago the northern hemisphere players were being slated for competing the ball on the floor at ruck and maul time," Johnson said. "Now it's come full circle – the way we play at home you can't go near a ruck or maul and play the ball on the floor but then you come here and you run into George Smith, who is an excellent player at turning over the ball there – we're just not used to it. "It always seems that the southern hemisphere is one step ahead and it's always us trying to adapt."</span>
&lt;!-- Start Email a friend links //-->
 
Messages
2,177
After watching some of the super 12, and especially the brumbies, I was convinced that Union was moving more towards League with every game, but the Lions sure killed off that idea. Running the ball seems to be a crime in the eyes of those blokes, and they not only wouldn't do it themselves, but seemed determined, through fair means or foul, to stop the Wallaby's doing it as well.
Limiting the numbers of players in the breakdown should at least make it more probable for the attacking team to keep a movement going.
 
Messages
419
yeah roopy, it may clean it up a bit but I wonder how they will be able to score if they don't get all those penalties that come from breakdowns :eek:)

I watched the tests but found it difficult to maintain any sort of enthuisiasm with the lions constantly forcing mauls and just rolling forward a yard at a time waiting for a penalty to come. You could go out and make a coffee while being assured all the action would be in the same place when you got back.
 
Messages
2,177
I will if I can. I have uni on Monday nights and work either afternoons or nights for the rest of the week except Tuesday, so that is the night I usually have some sort of social obligations, visiting relos and such. But anyway, I haven't heard of any plans for tonight so I may be there.
 

Latest posts

Top