Rumoured and Confirmed signings - Part 4

[franklin2323]

They're going shit have but he's still been if not their best forward one of them. The problem is they've only got about 4 or 5 decent if not great players. And Merrin and Hurrell are two of them.

Yeah he has gone ok. The backline is terrible

 

[GongPanther]

Merrin has been scapegoated if true,being that Merrin doesn't know anything about this talk.

 

[herbert henry1908]

Think we should’ve kept Sivo

Oh well, not much that could’ve been done. We can’t keep getting younger.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Think we should’ve kept Sivo

Oh well, not much that could’ve been done. We can’t keep getting younger.

Who would you drop? DWZ or Sauce?

 

[mxlegend99]

Think we should’ve kept Sivo

Oh well, not much that could’ve been done. We can’t keep getting younger.

Hes having a great game. Although hes only up against a rookie. Sivo hadnt really impressed before tonight. But he certainly has potential and would probably be an improvement over Mansour barring him finding some great form.

 

[herbert henry1908]

Who would you drop? DWZ or Sauce?

Mansour isn’t going very well, but I was never a fan of the 5 year deal for Whare. I’d like to see what DWZ can do in the centres.

 

[franklin2323]

Sivo to me would of been better than Phillips or Aekins but in reality he would of signed on as a backup

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Sivo to me would of been better than Phillips or Aekins but in reality he would of signed on as a backup

and there lies the reason that Siv left opportunity. How old is he 25 or 26 ?

 

[franklin2323]

and there lies the reason that Siv left opportunity. How old is he 25 or 26 ?

I think we need to start planning to phase out Whare but it won't be in the short term

 

[Panfa]

If Brandon mcgrady the big young centre from qld cup and nephew of ewan mcgrady lives up to his full potential than i think whare will be well snd truly gone.

 

[herbert henry1908]

If Brandon mcgrady the big young centre from qld cup and nephew of ewan mcgrady lives up to his full potential than i think whare will be well snd truly gone.

Brayden

 

[Kilkenny]

I

Sivo to me would of been better than Phillips or Aekins but in reality he would of signed on as a backup

I think the powers that be believe the likes of Brian Too, Stephen Chrichton and one or two others were the future rather than retain Sivo who is still raw. Not taking anything away from Sivo good luck to him but he still has major handling, defence and positional issues to overcome if he is to be an NRL player of substance.

 

[franklin2323]

I


I think the powers that be believe the likes of Brian Too, Stephen Chrichton and one or two others were the future rather than retain Sivo who is still raw. Not taking anything away from Sivo good luck to him but he still has major handling, defence and positional issues to overcome if he is to be an NRL player of substance.

That is how I saw Sivo too. Some great highlights and can find a try but the 1% he lacks. Crichton looks a backrower to me long term but Too is the one. Looks a star

 

[martielang]

The one who I thought would give it a serious shake, Sam Smith, isn’t even making NSW Cup. I must have a real eye for talent.

 

[franklin2323]

The one who I thought would give it a serious shake, Sam Smith, isn’t even making NSW Cup. I must have a real eye for talent.

Haha. That is the nature of talent spotting

 

[Panfa]

Just on another note i did say that kalyn ponga is not a 5/8s arsehole a week ago after we beat the knights well as of yesterday nathan brown has told ponga his 5/8 days are over lol.

 

[Panfa]

If its wet in bathurst it will suit us and slow the likes of ado carr and vunivalu down gonna be a grind hopefully mr klein remembers whos home game it is and is a bit kinder than rd 1 against the eels.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

I


I think the powers that be believe the likes of Brian Too, Stephen Chrichton and one or two others were the future rather than retain Sivo who is still raw. Not taking anything away from Sivo good luck to him but he still has major handling, defence and positional issues to overcome if he is to be an NRL player of substance.

I rate Too much higher than Sivo

 

[Luke Bowden]

Tyrone Phillips has quit the club after being caught drunk driving over the weekend.

 

[franklin2323]

Well drink driving should be treated this serious