I am a little out of touch but in respect of the proceedings initiated against Tyrone May in the civil jurisdiction it is probably a no brainer he will be found liable for damages and therefore it is largely in his best interests to settle out of court and avoid very substantial legal costs.
The plaintiff in seeking monetary damages will have to demonstrate a number of things in order maximise any judgement or negotiated settlement.
Physical injury, psychological injury, loss of earnings etc etc all as a direct or indirect consequence of the actions or acts of the defendant. This is a rather simplistic explanation of proceedings which are much more complicated.
Sadly, and anyone who has been involved directly in civil proceedings as the plaintiff can attest there is largely only ever one winner and that is the lawyers involved.
I can probably provide numerous examples wherein there is only one winner in legal proceedings, civil or otherwise, but as an example a very dear friend of mine initiated civil proceedings over a family estate/will dispute. He was always going to win and he did have a win in court, awarded a substantial settlement, his family member went into bankruptcy and he is still paying off hundred’s of thousands of dollars in legal costs while the person whom he initiated proceedings against (sister) still resides in the home the proceedings were all about in the first place.
There really is no justice sometimes.