Rumoured & Confirmed Signings - Part 5

[martielang]

2 of whom cost more than Kikau
The other one is zero chance of coming back...Hell Gus/Hook partnership here is more likely

CHN that disliked?

 

[Iamback]

CHN that disliked?

He is blamed for the videos going around.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

He is blamed for the videos going around.

Whether that was true or not.....who knows.....that's the same story I heard.

 

[Smug Panther]

Probably better to blame the sexual predator Tyrone May

 

[maple_69]

If May shared it to a close circle without consent and CHN shared it wider without consent then they both hold plenty of blame.

 

[Iamback]

Probably better to blame the sexual predator Tyrone May

We know of 3 videos.

Yet only May was charged.

While it shows poor culture. It was more widespread then just that one player sadly

 

[Iamback]

If May shared it to a close circle without consent and CHN shared it wider without consent then they both hold plenty of blame.

Tyrone Phillips and I think it was Liam Coleman also in videos.

So the whole squad was too blame

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Tyrone Phillips and I think it was Liam Coleman also in videos.

So the whole squad was too blame

I heard out of the whole squad only a couple of players weren't involved. May took the wrap for basically the whole squad.

 

[BossleyPanther]

2 of whom cost more than Kikau
The other one is zero chance of coming back...Hell Gus/Hook partnership here is more likely

Yea I know but just looking at the players in the game

 

[Iamback]

I heard out of the whole squad only a couple of players weren't involved. May took the wrap for basically the whole squad.

Wasn't all criminal stuff.

Some players traded photos with girls
Sexting etc

But yes only a handful of the squad wasn't involved

 

[Iamback]

Yea I know but just looking at the players in the game

Teams are going smaller now. Who knows it might be a blessing over time

 

[forby]

Why are we raising this again?
This is a signings page not a rehash scandals page!

 

[Original Name]

Tyrone Phillips and I think it was Liam Coleman also in videos.

So the whole squad was too blame

The NRL players don't train with the boys on Cup contracts in the season unless they have injuries. It's the boys in the top 30 squad they interact with at training which Coleman wasn't in.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

n

 

[The Realist]

But the elite players like gi, manu, etc dont need expansive footy.

Those types of elite centres are the guys you could throw the ball and theyd just make something happen out of nothing.. staggs i think might get to that level.

Critta just isnt going to be that good in attack. He is good if theres a half oppurtunity or finishing off a well worked play but creating something out of nothing not as much.

I strongly believe tago will overtake him within 12 months. To me he already looks a way stronger attacking player.

Yes on Tago. If I had to pick between the 2 I would pick Tago without even thinking about it. Critta is an excellent defender and highly competent finisher but that’s not worth 700K. To be worth 700-800K you have to be an attacking line break/assist weapon and he just doesn’t have it in him. He doesn’t seem to have a step + elusiveness of an ‘evasive’ back (think Michael Jennings) or the mixture of strength and balance of a power centre (think GI or Meninga)

To be honest in terms of attack I think Taylan May is a better player already then Crichton. He breaks tackles for fun and he isn’t even close to his physical peak.

 

[chrisD]

Because Crichton is playing out of position, he is really a winger.

 

[BxTom]

Because Crichton is playing out of position, he is really a winger.

Agree. Would like to see To'o inside him breaking tackles and getting the ball to his winger...

 

[Iamback]

Because Crichton is playing out of position, he is really a winger.

And a left side player at that

 

[Iamback]

Yes on Tago. If I had to pick between the 2 I would pick Tago without even thinking about it. Critta is an excellent defender and highly competent finisher but that’s not worth 700K. To be worth 700-800K you have to be an attacking line break/assist weapon and he just doesn’t have it in him. He doesn’t seem to have a step + elusiveness of an ‘evasive’ back (think Michael Jennings) or the mixture of strength and balance of a power centre (think GI or Meninga)

To be honest in terms of attack I think Taylan May is a better player already then Crichton. He breaks tackles for fun and he isn’t even close to his physical peak.

Critter covers more positions
Goal kicks
Saved the side in 3 finals last year

Tago has a long way to go

 

[mxlegend99]

Critter is definitely ahead of Tago at the moment.

Tago has a potentially higher ceiling. But Critter has come up with clutch plays in big games while Tago has bombed some very easy tries with poor footy awareness and no pressure.

Still dirty on him for being selfish and trying a dummy half scoot in the corner against the only defenders onside when we could have scored under the posts by throwing a few quick passes. But even in our last game he bombed an easy try by going out when he had a lot of space to work with and no pressure on him to ground it.

They're all learning experiences for him that are yet to lose us a game. But for now I rate Critter ahead of him even if he can't pass right to save his life. Just unbelievable that last year at fullback he was actually able to set up a few tries on the right edge and a year later he's actually worse passing to his right than he used to be.