What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,156
I’ll post this question because certain people only post here. What would peoples views on BA be if somehow we wound up with Paulo, Holmes and Klemmer for the loss/non-resigning of Edwards, Scott, T-Rex and say, Norman & French?
Good question. Thrown in one more semi-decent acquisition that could play 6 and it seems like a good effort.

Maybe someone of Blake Austin’s ilk (doesn’t need to be him).

Still think we need a better option at 9 though...
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,281
I’ll post this question because certain people only post here. What would peoples views on BA be if somehow we wound up with Paulo, Holmes and Klemmer for the loss/non-resigning of Edwards, Scott, T-Rex and say, Norman & French?

That's a net gain, imo, and would certainly help to make up for a terrible 2018.

I think our 2018 form is mostly due to the fact we just do not have the right sort of players to compete in the new NRL, but those signings would definitely help.
 

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
That's a net gain, imo, and would certainly help to make up for a terrible 2018.

I think our 2018 form is mostly due to the fact we just do not have the right sort of players to compete in the new NRL, but those signings would definitely help.


We’ve had plenty of ball and opportunities to win games this year. Not totally sure our shortfall is quality of players only.
 

Djay

Juniors
Messages
1,827
I’ll post this question because certain people only post here. What would peoples views on BA be if somehow we wound up with Paulo, Holmes and Klemmer for the loss/non-resigning of Edwards, Scott, T-Rex and say, Norman & French?
I would be impressed but I think it’s quite apparent that we can sign all these forwards etc but without a good dummy half then is it really gonna get us to the promised land? We may come close but I think we will still fall short.

Read somewhere about Jake Granville? If we could nab him that would be the best signing of the lot for me, his an absolute gun from dummy half in my eyes and his a super intelligent footballer.
 

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
I would be impressed but I think it’s quite apparent that we can sign all these forwards etc but without a good dummy half then is it really gonna get us to the promised land? We may come close but I think we will still fall short.

Read somewhere about Jake Granville? If we could nab him that would be the best signing of the lot for me, his an absolute gun from dummy half in my eyes and his a super intelligent footballer.



Yeah like many have stated we’ve been a hooker and big bopper short. I’d like to see Kaysa come off the bench and inject himself for 30 minutes. Jake would be an astute purchase
 

Djay

Juniors
Messages
1,827
Yeah like many have stated we’ve been a hooker and big bopper short. I’d like to see Kaysa come off the bench and inject himself for 30 minutes. Jake would be an astute purchase
His exactly what we need and what is needed in today’s game, we’ve been lacking a hooker like that for as long as i can remember.
 

Noise

Coach
Messages
18,226
I’ll post this question because certain people only post here. What would peoples views on BA be if somehow we wound up with Paulo, Holmes and Klemmer for the loss/non-resigning of Edwards, Scott, T-Rex and say, Norman & French?

Leaves us short 2 decent edge forwards and still doesn’t fix our hooker and wing issues (Holmes won’t come here to play wing)
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,924
I would be impressed but I think it’s quite apparent that we can sign all these forwards etc but without a good dummy half then is it really gonna get us to the promised land? We may come close but I think we will still fall short.

Read somewhere about Jake Granville? If we could nab him that would be the best signing of the lot for me, his an absolute gun from dummy half in my eyes and his a super intelligent footballer.
Good question. Thrown in one more semi-decent acquisition that could play 6 and it seems like a good effort.

Maybe someone of Blake Austin’s ilk (doesn’t need to be him).

Still think we need a better option at 9 though...
The main question is around whether and how much extra time people would give BA should these signings happen. Even further to it, lets say we make these changes plus Salmon makes a passable 1st grade 5/8th and Kaysa becomes consistent and uninjured enough to at least warm the seat for juniors for couple of seasons, we rebound somewhat next season, have some outstanding games and some round 2 v Manly games, and limp into 8th, but can't make any further notable signings for 2020, do people re-sign BA or look elsewhere?
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,865
Remaining Games:

ROUND 12 Broncos
ROUND 13 Knights
ROUND 14 Cowboys
ROUND 15 Rabbitohs
ROUND 16 Dragons
ROUND 18 Knights
ROUND 19 Bulldogs
ROUND 20 Rabbitohs
ROUND 21 Titans
ROUND 22 Dragons
ROUND 23 Storm
ROUND 24 Cowboys
ROUND 25 Roosters

I can see us maybe beating Knights twice, Titans once and Dogs, but that's about it to be honest.
Have a really bad feeling that next game could get real ugly, another Manly disaster coming up. Trouble is once a team is 14 points ahead we've lost as that is about all we can score so it appears.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,865
With those players I mentioned back every game I expect us to be competetive and a chance.

Pou blamed heat, then possesion, then injuries. All those have played a part but soon its back to an even playing field and cool weather.
Pou has a squillion excuses on why we lost other than actually blaming the coach or the players. Lets see how we go when these players come back. Lets hope we let go of the wooden spoon handle so firmly in our grasp atm and pass it over to the rightful owner, the Dogs.
 

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,192
Have a really bad feeling that next game could get real ugly, another Manly disaster coming up. Trouble is once a team is 14 points ahead we've lost as that is about all we can score so it appears.

Yes we are having trouble scoring points!!

Interestingly if we take out, our flogging against manly, our defence has probably been the best of the bottom 8 teams.

Also there is a fairly big difference in points against between the top 8 and bottom 8.
 
Last edited:

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,869
Yep that would be a net gain and BA gets another chance to see what he can do early next year. By this time next year though, if we’re not showing serious promise it would be time to part ways. I think we could offer T-Rex another minimum contract though.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,865
Mannah is on chump change though given his long term cap discount. We’d be lucky if we pay him $250k on the cap. We wouldn’t be able to replace him for less than that.

Other than Jenko or Norman, only other players it could be imo would be French or Tepai
Tepai, another overpaid merkin, who has failed to live up to his pay cheque. Just on Jenko's 4 year contract surely his pay decreases over the time, but knowing this club, bet it doesn't, if anything probably increases.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,865
Yep that would be a net gain and BA gets another chance to see what he can do early next year. By this time next year though, if we’re not showing serious promise it would be time to part ways. I think we could offer T-Rex another minimum contract though.
What really worries me is that other clubs are announcing signings but as yet nothing from our club. Rumours we have Junior but just that, a rumour, at present. We really need to go hard and pay overs if necessary to rebuild the squad. Go really hard for Pangi Jnr, looks like one of those forwards that'll be a real beast in the future plus another good middle forward, maybe Lodge. However our precarious ladder position doesn't help us in negotiations but the Knights have proved they can still sign players when in the cellar. We need to do the same. Lets hope the dopey BA doesn't come to the fore, praising how our forwards will perform once they are all back so no need to buy any more for next year (or is that Pou talking?).
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,201
The rot of this team started in around the 60th min of the very first game of the year, you bullshit artist. Way before any major injury toll started to be a factor.

You have been sweating on the injury toll to climb, you pathetic gibberer, so you can trot it out to justify all your crappy excuses and analysis. Like I've said before, many of us here knew, suspected and thought that we were weak up front. The coach is paid handsomely to get it right. He got it ridiculously and insultingly wrong.

Now we, the tragically long suffering Eels supporters, have to sit here and hope, pray that this fool can get it right for next year. And when he fails again next year, we will hope, pray that our legendary management get it right when they fire his arse and hire someone that can f**ken do his f**ken job well!

What a f**ken disgrace! I mean I have to sit and bare another crappy f**ken season on top of the 3 plus decades of mostly crap that has come before.

My patience is shot. I f**ken hate this clubs endemic failure to succeed and its inability to hire the best people to get it right and cultivate a truly lasting winning ethos. We are from top to bottom rotten to the core. No wonder we have the most wooden spoons of any club. Is it any surprise to anyone really? Just a f**ken loser of a club. Constantly chirping like a heavy weight champion who laughingly gets knocked out in the very first round like chump.

F**ken BA has f**ked us well. What a legend.
I agree our form was poor before the injuries but every team experiences poor form. Gutherson was unavailable to start the year. In round two we lost Takairangi, in round three we lost Evans and Hayne. In round five we lost Brown. These are all important players in our attack.
 

Latest posts

Top