What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,590
So if hayne had simply decided to leave would our season be ruined?
I reckon the squad sucks even with him in it, how this squad with him in it or not is near the cap is one for Ripleys. Especially when we had the money free in case Semi came back this year and sacked Edwards and signed no one. What did we do with it??? Or was it more Bernie hot air???
 
Last edited:

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,051
I reckon the squad sucks even with him in it, how this squad with him in it or not is near the cap is one for Ripleys. Especially when we had the money free in case Semi came back this year and sacked Edwards and signed no one. What did we do with it??? Or was it more Bernie hot air???
How do you know we had the money for semi? ... that was all speculation ... just like having the money to sign hayne

edwards money didnt just disappear - he was still paid half of it - who was there to sign mid season for half his worth?
 

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,875
So if hayne had simply decided to leave would our season be ruined?
If we didn’t replace him with someone of similar ability, then pretty much. This replacement would need to be in addition to our current recruits to be a competitive squad IMO.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,590
How do you know we had the money for semi? ... that was all speculation ... just like having the money to sign hayne

edwards money didnt just disappear - he was still paid half of it - who was there to sign mid season for half his worth?
So BA and Bernie were lying??? In a few interviews they both stated we have had money left aside for him and with Edwards left over coin we could of front loaded and extended a junior like Mahoney for example. Oh that’s right he’s still not even in the top 28 yet. You honestly think this squad should be anywhere near the cap???
 
Last edited:

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
78,051
If we didn’t replace him with someone of similar ability, then pretty much. This replacement would need to be in addition to our current recruits to be a competitive squad IMO.

Fergo and Siva* are the Hayne / Semi replacements IMO. I reckon that BA and his think tank see Hayne as being an unreliable footy enigma. They don’t want to hang their hat on him because it is entirely plausible that he may no deliver when the chips are down.

If not Siva then Parry, if not Parry then etc
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,051
So BA and Bernie were lying??? In a few interviews they both stated we have had money left aside for him and with Edwards left over coin we could of front loaded and extended a junior like Mahoney for example. Oh that’s right he’s still not even in the top 25 yet. You honestly think this squad should be anywhere near the cap???
I said it before, i can understand why our players are getting what they are - and if they played to their potential we wouldnt be whinging .... only one that disappoints me is what MJ is reported to be on (and maybe junior is a touch over, but we needed what he offers, so meh)
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,590
I said it before, i can understand why our players are getting what they are - and if they played to their potential we wouldnt be whinging .... only one that disappoints me is what MJ is reported to be on (and maybe junior is a touch over, but we needed what he offers, so meh)
So that’s a yes you think this squad should be near the cap???
 

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,875
Fergo and Siva* are the Hayne / Semi replacements IMO. I reckon that BA and his think tank see Hayne as being an unreliable footy enigma. They don’t want to hang their hat on him because it is entirely plausible that he may no deliver when the chips are down.

If not Siva then Parry, if not Parry then etc
That’s a pretty significant downgrade as far as I’m concerned and we’re coming off a wooden spoon and should be in a position to improve the roster.
 

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,721
Out.
Beau Scott
Kenny Edwards
Vae
Matagi
Davis
Williams
King
Hayne
Auva

In
Ferguson
Paulo
Lane
Davey
Sivo

I guess if you compare estimated salarys, and assume we were on our limit last season, the numbers probably closely balance and suggest we have again maxed (no pun intended) out.
Then we also need to consider Norman, Moses and Mennings have back ended contracts as well as the need to upgrade some of our promoted juniors.
Its scarey what some very average footy players can earn at our club.
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,192
I chuckle how everyone is saying how shit our roster is going into 2019

Our roster going into 2018 was probably worse, yet every f**ker here (me included) said we would be top 4
Most of us forget what happened beyond last week. We are rating the squad based on form rather than on talent.

It’s why we overrated them going into 2018 and why we are now probably underrating them now.

The good news is that I’ll be pleasantly surprised when we finish 11th next year.
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,192
So that’s a yes you think this squad should be near the cap???
Do you know any rich merkins that can jag us a few (perfectly above board) TPAs? Because Bernie doesn’t seem to...

That’s where we are getting killed and why it isn’t an even playing field at the moment.
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,192
Fergo and Siva* are the Hayne / Semi replacements IMO. I reckon that BA and his think tank see Hayne as being an unreliable footy enigma. They don’t want to hang their hat on him because it is entirely plausible that he may no deliver when the chips are down.

If not Siva then Parry, if not Parry then etc
ETC looks an exciting prospect.
 

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,875
Do you know any rich merkins that can jag us a few (perfectly above board) TPAs? Because Bernie doesn’t seem to...

That’s where we are getting killed and why it isn’t an even playing field at the moment.
That’s a good point and a pretty strong argument why corporate networks should be one of the key section criteria for the CEO.
 

Latest posts

Top