Were not using win rate to determine who is better, just that McCullough must've been good to win so many games. The theory is that an average player wouldn't have been picked in so many strong teams. Average players play in strong teams but they don't become mainstays.lol just lol, Farah was Cam Smith Lite . McCulloch reminded me of Matt Keating. Now it's back to win % to rate a player. I bet his win rate was higher than Farah's would you say he was a better footballer????