What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Tiger5150

Bench
Messages
3,756
View attachment 86412
Nothing will beat this manly jersey.
Knights usually save this one for Tigers games...
team-j18-0-nkn-ormi22-adlt-p1_1.jpg
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,124
We were playing fine til we lost our half-back. We just don't have good enough cover there or in the backs.

It's just such a shame that there aren't people at the club with the responsibility to build a 30-man roster to provide some form of depth...

I realise that losing our first-string halfback is a burden we don't need, and puts a lot of pressure on the team.

However, it doesn't excuse Arthur's selections, his puzzling tactics, or his bizarre use of our bench.
 
Messages
19,378
It's just such a shame that there aren't people at the club with the responsibility to build a 30-man roster to provide some form of depth...

I realise that losing our first-string halfback is a burden we don't need, and puts a lot of pressure on the team.

However, it doesn't excuse Arthur's selections, his puzzling tactics, or his bizarre use of our bench.

Who would you have picked in the first match post-Moses injury?
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,746
This is nothing story as his market value is what a buyer is willing to pay from a willing seller isn't it? Schuster, reportedly on $800k, is on the outer at Manly. What is his market value? Probably not more than $250-300k, certainly not what Manly are paying him. Roosters and Broncos have been underpaying for years so MV apparently doesn't apply to them as nobody questions them - only us it appears.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,019
Its probabaly better to provide a source rather than throw darts


Meninga, whose father is of South Sea Island heritage and mother is Australian, was born in Bundaberg, Queensland. His father, Norman Meninga, also played rugby league. He has a brother, Geoffrey Meninga. Meninga attended Maroochydore State High School, graduating with a Junior Certificate in 1975.

 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,124
Who would you have picked in the first match post-Moses injury?

1. Gutherson
6. Talagi
7. Brown


Or

1. Talagi
6. Gutherson
7. Brown

Or

1. Gutherson
6. Matterson
7. Brown


Or

1. Gutherson
6. Asi
7. Brown


If there are no viable back-ups at the club, that would constitute a failure in recruitment, and roster-building, in my eyes.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,221
6. Brown
7. Hands
I felt like Blaize was worth a punt for a couple of weeks in the role.

Gives him valuable experience and something to go back and learn what it takes to play grade with that small taste. Short-term pain for long term gain.

BA pulling him out now is the right call 3 games in before his confidence could completely be shot if he stayed the whole 8 weeks.

Its easier going back to Asi now then starting with Asi and realising oh shit now we have to go to a 18 year old kid.

If we won the Tigers game the whole situation where in wouldn't be as bad.

And probably where we expected to be once Moses was ruled out. 3-2 after 5 would be acceptable.
 

eels_fan

First Grade
Messages
7,574
Happy for Blaize to get experience in firsts at centre.

BA came out and said he’s either a centre or fullback so why on earth would we throw him into a position our head coach knows is not his future spot, in a high pressure role? Makes zero sense.

it’s not like a centre slotting in on the wing.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,260
I felt like Blaize was worth a punt for a couple of weeks in the role.

Gives him valuable experience and something to go back and learn what it takes to play grade with that small taste. Short-term pain for long term gain.

BA pulling him out now is the right call 3 games in before his confidence could completely be shot if he stayed the whole 8 weeks.

Its easier going back to Asi now then starting with Asi and realising oh shit now we have to go to a 18 year old kid.

If we won the Tigers game the whole situation where in wouldn't be as bad.

And probably where we expected to be once Moses was ruled out. 3-2 after 5 would be acceptable.


BA should have gone with Asi at 7 as soon as they started pre season training if he was never going to give Sanders a shot.

Now we don't have a backup 7 that has trained in that position or even played there at the start of the season.

It should have been from the Tigers game.
7.Asi
6.Brown
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,221
BA should have gone with Asi at 7 as soon as they started pre season training if he was never going to give Sanders a shot.

Now we don't have a backup 7 that has trained in that position or even played there at the start of the season.

It should have been from the Tigers game.
7.Asi
6.Brown
Fair enough hypothetically if Blaize didnt play the Manly game does he play the following week against the tigers game at 5/8.

BA and the club might have been caught in the excitement of keeping him in the team.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,108
Happy for Blaize to get experience in firsts at centre.

BA came out and said he’s either a centre or fullback so why on earth would we throw him into a position our head coach knows is not his future spot, in a high pressure role? Makes zero sense.

it’s not like a centre slotting in on the wing.
He played like a fullback in attack. Third in precedence of our playmakers. In defence he was one in from centre. He at least has experience defending there.
 

Latest posts

Top