What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Soto

Bench
Messages
4,223
The world of Ayoub/Gutho negotiation tactics is there again for all to see. Relief it’s at another club, they may not fall for it an BA/MON appeared to.
It's the end of year/school term circus.
Comes to a venue nearby every couple of years. Creates a lot of noise for a few weeks/months then there is a happy union formed and everyone sets off into sunset.
I think this is the 4th instalment. Thought it was going to be a trilogy but the producers have gone again...
Pop corn ready
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,428
Read the courier fail today and there was a huge contrast with Eels training and Donkeys. They had almost full squad with a very tough opening session whereas we had almost nobody and light session. Hope things ramp up when full squad assembled, definitely need better fitness.


Do we have anyone else available to train 😂

Moses/Lomax/Iongi won't train till Xmas
Barlow/Brown/Penisini/Simmonson a few others pro bably injured too..

Kelma married I think Joe as well.

Next week more are back apparently
 

Stormy36

Juniors
Messages
139
I hope longi works out... With the rumours of Kennedy leaving the sharks, he would be a very good option for a club. I'd rather him at fullback over latrell... The bloke competes in every facet, can ball play and can read a game.
 

Legal Eel

Juniors
Messages
1,039
He was injured after we signed him ffs. He was starting hooker in round one of 2022. His 2021 form was good, which is why we signed him.
You always conveniently ignore the fact that his signing was lauded by almost no-one and that most fans and pundits had him as a bust from the day he was announced, which was before the injury you are referencing
 

Legal Eel

Juniors
Messages
1,039
He was injured after we signed him ffs. He was starting hooker in round one of 2022. His 2021 form was good, which is why we signed him.

In this article, he confirms this injury was his "third knee"...everyone knew he was washed up except our recruitment team (and coach) and the great Poudini!
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,404
You always conveniently ignore the fact that his signing was lauded by almost no-one and that most fans and pundits had him as a bust from the day he was announced, which was before the injury you are referencing
This is why he was the cheap option, just like Lussick, who replaced him. We didn’t replace Mahoney with Hodgson because we thought he was better. There was too much demand for Mahoney, making him unaffordable. Do you really think the key to managing the cap is signing the best available player at every position?
 

Legal Eel

Juniors
Messages
1,039
This is why he was the cheap option, just like Lussick, who replaced him. We didn’t replace Mahoney with Hodgson because we thought he was better. There was too much demand for Mahoney, making him unaffordable. Do you really think the key to managing the cap is signing the best available player at every position?
No, but its also not signing a proven crock and woefully staffing the hooker position in an attempt to leave a pathway there for players of "potential"...I have been told by many people, including agents, that for at least two years they had been told not to bother with offering hookers to Parramatta.

You have to ask yourself why that is? Because we were so wonderfully stocked in that area?

Either our coach deliberately wanted to leave a pathway for his son, or he and the club had no clue or ability to ensure that position was properly staffed in the past two years....either way, it was a big failure.

It is this culture that we hopefully have left behind, to the chagrin of only you.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,404

In this article, he confirms this injury was his "third knee"...everyone knew he was washed up except our recruitment team (and coach) and the great Poudini!
Everyone knew he was a risk. Are you suggesting we were in a position to avoid risk, with the salary cap squeezing players out of the squad?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,404
In fairness, Pou is still deep throating Steve Kearney for f**k's sake....
It was a clear indication of where we were at as a club, with the only coaches willing to come here being ones no other club wanted. No surprises Bennett preferred Souths, who finished below us on the ladder. Is Ryles the first one where there has been some external demand? Admittedly, it was from the Dragons, who haven’t been a preferred destination for anybody for over a decade.
 

Legal Eel

Juniors
Messages
1,039
Everyone knew he was a risk. Are you suggesting we were in a position to avoid risk, with the salary cap squeezing players out of the squad?
see above - we chose a disposable short term option (and crock) because we wanted the hooker position available for Arthur junior...all of the rugby league world knows that.

And you will deride that information and spout crap about the cap, but history has proven that our coach either didn't value the hooker position and didn't realise how important it was, or wanted it for his plodder son.....

Of course there were other options, only the mentally weak and yourself regularly peddle the "there is no one or nothing else" fallacy....
 

Legal Eel

Juniors
Messages
1,039
It was a clear indication of where we were at as a club, with the only coaches willing to come here being ones no other club wanted. No surprises Bennett preferred Souths, who finished below us on the ladder. Is Ryles the first one where there has been some external demand? Admittedly, it was from the Dragons, who haven’t been a preferred destination for anybody for over a decade.
still litigating Kearney...you are the best!
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,404
No, but its also not signing a proven crock and woefully staffing the hooker position in an attempt to leave a pathway there for players of "potential"...I have been told by many people, including agents, that for at least two years they had been told not to bother with offering hookers to Parramatta.

You have to ask yourself why that is? Because we were so wonderfully stocked in that area?

Either our coach deliberately wanted to leave a pathway for his son, or he and the club had no clue or ability to ensure that position was properly staffed in the past two years....either way, it was a big failure.

It is this culture that we hopefully have left behind, to the chagrin of only you.
Matt Arthur does have massive potential. Look how good he was in reserve grade this year, despite still being eligible for SG Ball.

If you think he just wanted to create pathways for his children, why did he extend both Moses and Drown? Why didn’t he give Matt Arthur his NRL debut?
 
Top