What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,367
Clubs don't string off contract players along. The ones who left all would've known they wouldn't be there the following year. They could literally at the difference between the Panthers offer (if there even was one) and the bigger offers from more desperate rivals.
Momorovski and May weren't off contract. May had ZERO idea he wasn't going to be at Penrith. Momorovski may have been monouvering himself though.
 
Last edited:

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,458
Scum could be broken
Jerry Seinfeld Popcorn GIF by Sheets & Giggles
 

crocodile

Bench
Messages
3,551
I’m sure I could dig up posts where you’ve said Mahoney is better then grant and one of the best 9’s in the game. Since Mahoney signed with the dogs, all of a sudden Robson is potentially better then him? Haha glad you can find positives in a shit load of hypotheticals. Would Robson only be better than Mahoney if he joins the eels? Asking for a friend.
You could probably dig up some of mine. I rate Mahoney above Grant. There, said it again.
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,642
Kami Kami Kami Kami Kamikamica
It comes to blows, it comes to blows
Getting off would be easy if your colours were another teams

Who am I kidding Scums get slaps on the wrist
 

Incorrect

Coach
Messages
12,603
I know we tend to overrate our own players and I admittedly haven’t observed Robson that much but I doubt he’s better than Mahoney.
We’d be silly (I say silly but seriously if this option wasn’t be discussed 5 minutes after Mahoney told them, then it’s serious incompetence) to not at least explore Korisau.
Robson at the right price is a ‘safe’ signing.
Liddle is wholehearted but he’s a big BIG jump down in skills/smarts
I'd sign Robson, like I said earlier, but in no way am I asserting he is better than Mahoney. But I would contend that you could sign him for ~250-300 and get a player on the same upward path as Mahoney.

Has shown good footy instincts and footy nous from what I've seen.
 
Messages
19,378
Was reading a Fox Sports article earlier today (probably my first mistake) and whoever wrote it framed it in a way that suggested that our 'premiership window' would be closed unless we signed a first class hooker for next season...

I think even the media is confused by the bizarre contract regime that the NRL have implemented.

Yeh. To be fair to the NRL (and I don't usually wish to do that), in the past people complained like f**k that clubs (and some clubs in particular) were tapping players up prior to whatever the date was when you could speak to players. I don't know what the perfect solution is but the current situation is probably not it.
 

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,605
OMG. I have one arvo on the pi*s with my mates and Ive 12 pages to catch up on ffs.
Summary please.
 
Last edited:
Messages
19,378
Was reading a Fox Sports article earlier today (probably my first mistake) and whoever wrote it framed it in a way that suggested that our 'premiership window' would be closed unless we signed a first class hooker for next season...

I think even the media is confused by the bizarre contract regime that the NRL have implemented.

And of course, them making a judgement on premiership windows without have the slightest clue regarding who the Eels will sign to replace the 2 (3,4) players is the mark of idiots....but it does sell papers in the off-season.
 

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,159
I'd sign Robson, like I said earlier, but in no way am I asserting he is better than Mahoney. But I would contend that you could sign him for ~250-300 and get a player on the same upward path as Mahoney.

Has shown good footy instincts and footy nous from what I've seen.
For $250-300k Robson wouId be an absolute steel, bargin….reckon he might cost a bit more
 

Incorrect

Coach
Messages
12,603
For $250-300k Robson wouId be an absolute steel, bargin….reckon he might cost a bit more
Agree, 300K is basement price. But anything over that you'd have to think is already a lot more than he made the move north for so if you threw a contract at him with 300,000.00 at him, his eyes would light up I reckon....
 

Latest posts

Top