What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Storm to scrap captain rotation?

shadow grinder

First Grade
Messages
5,266
SMH.com.au- Roy masters, Nothing to gain from following the AFL's lead


THE atmosphere in the Storm dressing room prior to playing the Sharks was incredibly tense, a look of steely, grim determination on every man's face.
The players sat on the low benches around the small room on Friday night like those flickering black-and-white movie memories of paratroopers belted to the fuselage of old DC3 aircraft.


It was one of those moments coaches would like to bottle and uncork on grand-final day. But Melbourne's Craig Bellamy knew why his players were on a high: winger Matt Geyer's 200th first-grade game for the Storm.
"They fire up for milestone games," an assistant said, as Collingwood also did, celebrating Anthony Rocca's 200th game with a win over second-placed West Coast after three straight defeats.


The Collingwood team has been in Melbourne a century longer, but the Storm club knows how to nurture its brief history. Founding managing director John Ribot, a former international winger, presented Geyer with his jersey and then the players filed solemnly onto the field and proceeded to destroy the Sharks in the ruthless manner good judges have not seen this season.


No one at the Storm knows who is captain until a day or so before the match. The choice always comes from one of five - hooker Cameron Smith, forwards David Kidwell and Michael Crocker, five-eighth Scott Hill and Geyer. They are called the senior player leadership group, but this is in name only. At a time AFL clubs are investing more and more authority in these leadership groups and NRL clubs are embracing the concept, Bellamy is considering abandoning it.


The reason? Everyone looks to him for leadership. He sees things before the gang of five does. The co-captains make mistakes, too. Perhaps the rest of the team feels uncomfortable with this layer between them and the coach. Anyway, it seems certain Bellamy will return to the traditional leadership model of one captain in 2007.





Ironically, Bellamy opted to try the co-captains system after a long talk with Paul Roos, whose Sydney Swans won last year's AFL flag. But the Swans and Brisbane Lions have encountered serious problems with senior players in the past week, compromising leadership.
 

Ice777

Bench
Messages
3,120
It doesn't bother me either way but considering we've only lost 3 games it obviously hasn't had a detrimental affect on us in any way. I can't see the point in dumping it now if it has been working ok, maybe just wait until next year for Cam to take over full time. But as i said it doesn't really bother me either way.
 

Lego_Man

First Grade
Messages
5,071
Chris Walker? He cost the Roosters 2 premierships. In addition to a fat salary, that is too big a price to pay for any team.
 

LESStar58

Referee
Messages
25,496
Collingwood Storm said:
each club should only have 1 captain...just look at the greatest captain to walk the planet....bucks!

You mean that skirt who has a pechant for playfully tapping opposition players in the stomach?

Cat!
 

LESStar58

Referee
Messages
25,496
Collingwood Storm said:
yeah no doubt cam smith will be captain next year...crocker would probably be deputy

sounds about right seein as they are the only 2 members of the leadership group left.... its a good plan!
 

LeagueXIII

First Grade
Messages
5,969
Isn't Bucks' nickname FIGJAM, F*** I'm Good Just Ask Me, yeah great leadership material.
AFL captains role have always been nothing more than a mickey mouse position. When Brian Taylor was asked what a captain does football wise in AFL, all he could come up with was toss the coin. How can a guy who plays in "defence" in AFL get involved with the forwards.
 

Ice777

Bench
Messages
3,120
Buckley has been playing on the ball or in the forward line most of his career and there's not many better captains than him going around. Of course i'm bias as i'm a mad Pie supporter as well, but the fact that he's one of the most hated players in the AFL by opposition supporters is a testament to what an out and out champion he is. In saying that he's stepping down next year as skipper to give someone else a go and if whoever takes over does even half the job as what Bucks has done over the years they'll do a great job.

As for what BT said, as much as i love the bloke, that was a stupid thing to say. The right captain who leads by example can get just that little bit more out of players than maybe what others couldn't and it could mean the difference between a win and a loss in the end.
 

Lancelot Link

Juniors
Messages
142
Even though Melbourne are flying high - I've always seen this as a pretty silly idea.

The honour of captaining your side - is just that - an HONOUR!

Most teams have many 'leaders' in different areas on the field anyway. They just don't have the (c) beside their name. So what difference does it make if you move that little (c) around in Big League every week?

It means something to be the captain of your club. Means something to the fans and should mean something to the players as well. It's an achievement and an honour. And IMO anyway - it should only ever be one bloke.

That's one Footy tradition I don't want to see die...
 

Cloud9

Guest
Messages
1,126
I think the rotating captaincy is appropriate this year but maybe not next year. When Kearns retired, it left a vacuum, coupled with Orfords and bells departure it created a lot of uncertainty about this season. The responsibility of captaincy would have been an unecessary burden for a particular player with on field expectations. The fact that there were several names being thrown around for captaincy with no obvious stand outs excepts pros of cons of each individual, it think it was appropriate that a leadership group was formed. Now that the team structure has stabilised and dynamics established, certain player(s) have matured and would make good captains in a mentoring, leadership, assistant coach role.
 

Ice777

Bench
Messages
3,120
From memory it's been Smith, Geyer, Kidwell, Hill and I think Crocker may have had a go.
 

Latest posts

Top