What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Team for the Panthers match. Organisation!

t-ba

Post Whore
Messages
55,999
A little early I know, what, with a match being played and all :lol: .

I am fully aware that 8 of the players out there tonight are probably classed as PL players, but this does not change the fact that our playmaking is attrocious. Monaghan fully deserved to be re-signed, as he was captain, but it has always been clear we haven't had an organising influence at the club since (gulp) Kimmorley in 2001.

We've (Touchwood) wrapped up a finals spot this year, and exceeded most peoples expectations. But we simply can't get away with this simple type of football anymore. We aren't going to win any trophies (this year). We've got 8 matches to experiment with if we're willing to throw away the (slim) hope of a home final. It's time to trial a playmaker in the halves, and put Monaghan, whose clever, if limited passing game and solid defence is suited to the number 9.

Here's what I'm thinking for next week ('interesting' ones bolded and explained)

1-Brett Stewart
2-Scott Donald
3-Ashley Alberts
4-Chris Hicks
5-Jared Taylor
6-Michael Witt
7-Travis Burns
8-Mark Bryant
9-Michael Monaghan (c)
10-Brent Kite
11-Sam Harris
12-Steve Menzies
13-Ben Kennedy

14-Glenn Stewart
15-Shayne Dunley
16-Jason King/Anyone but Kane
17-Kylie Leuleui

Taylor- Give the Bloke a run! Hicks played some solid football at centre last year, and I think Matai needs to cool his heels in PL a little bit!
Burns- An actual organiser in the halves!!! We need to try and mix up our approach now that the patented 'super secret Manly football code' has been cracked by opposition teams.
Bryant- First Grade written all over him. Wrap the bloke up because he is developing into a fine prop.
Monaghan-Hooker is his real home.
Harris- Is his contract about to be torn up or something?
 

canteen worker

Juniors
Messages
86
Great call T-Ba though the form of Hicks has worried me in whatever position he has played. His defensive decision making on the wing has been poor. Your side is worth a go as we have looked like a cork in a cyclone in the past few weeks, especially with the ball in the opposition quarter!
 

CliffyIsGod

First Grade
Messages
6,454
Good side t-a.


It was interesting to see Monas play a bit of hooker towards the end of the Tiger's game. If we miss out on Orford, Hasler may just put Burns there next year anyway.
 

KulaShaker

Juniors
Messages
222
Definitely put Burns up. Although defensive tactics will have to be changed.. his problem is that he's too light and players run over the top of him. We need bigger players to back him..
 

RainMan

Juniors
Messages
2,034
stiff-meister eel said:
Guys don't worry about the recent loss. At least now you won't have high expectations for this year.

A lot of the Manly supporters with a bit of knowledge about their team never really had Manly finishing higher than 8 spot. So far, this season to date has been a bonus.
 

Fluffy

Juniors
Messages
339
id take mullane at 5/8 and monas half over burns. Mullane has been good in PL and gets the ball out to his backs, something witt hasnt done much of at all
 

cainen

Juniors
Messages
1,907
FYI, Penriths likely team:

1. Wesser
2. Howland
3. Galea
4. Franze/Pomeroy*
5. Rooney
6. Cambell
7. Gower
8. Clinton
9. Priddis
10. Ross
11. Rodney
12. Pritchard
13. Waterhouse

14. Crossman
15. F Puletua
16. Swain
17. Rogers

*If he comes back from injury.

Good team on paper, sh*t on field. They didn't look too bad on field against Canberra yesterday, just some bad decisions (from both our players and the ref) cost us dearly.
 

CC_Eagle

First Grade
Messages
7,295
Minus Witt and Cleal

1.Stewart
2.Donald
3.Hill
4.Alberts
5.Hicks
6.Monaghan
7.Burns
8.Bryant
9.Randall
10.Kite
11.Menzies
12.Harris
13.Kennedy

14.Leuluai
15.Dunley
16.King
17.G.Stewart

Would love to see Travis in 1st grade but imo Des will go for Mullane or Cherry at 5/8th. IF ONLY WILLOW WASN'T INJURED!!
 

Latest posts

Top