Team List Toosday: Round 4 Eels v Panthers

[emjaycee]

1. Gutho
2. Sivo
3. Blake
4. Penisini
5. Russel or Dunster
6. Brown
7. Moses
8. Paulo
9. Hodgson
10. RCG
11. Cartwright
12. Matterson
13. Hopgood

14. Arthur
15. Doorey
16. Makatoa
17. Greig

 

[strider]

1. Gutho
2. Sivo
3. Blake
4. Penisini
5. Russel or Dunster
6. Brown
7. Moses
8. Paulo
9. Hodgson
10. RCG
11. Cartwright
12. Matterson
13. Hopgood

14. Arthur
15. Doorey
16. Makatoa
17. Greig

Matto and Doorey have both played right edge hey? ... i would probably prefer Doorey start over Carty but maybe its a question of what side

Do you reckon Matto moves to middle during the game?

 

[yy_cheng]

It eill be cut and paste bar thr injured and matto

 

[Gronk]

So is Doorey OK then ?

It eill be cut and paste bar thr injured and matto

Bailey ? No, can't be.

 

[Tooooks]

If Doorey is fit maybe Matto off the bench due to match fitness. Hopefully Russell fit. From what I understand, Haze played his first 80 minute game last week? If true, he won’t be ready for first grade.

 

[hindy111]

Are we signing anyone? We have 27/30 spots filled.
If not upgrade Matalele and start blooding the kid. Even if he gets 10 mins a game he can drop back to NSW cup on the weekend.

 

[Gronk]

Are we signing anyone? We have 27/30 spots filled.
If not upgrade Matalele and start blooding the kid. Even if he gets 10 mins a game he can drop back to NSW cup on the weekend.

He can be selected from June 30 anyway. So why waste a Top 30 spot ?

 

[hindy111]

Matto and Doorey have both played right edge hey? ... i would probably prefer Doorey start over Carty but maybe its a question of what side

Do you reckon Matto moves to middle during the game?

Unsure what Doorey has done over Bryce but.
Average meters Bryce - 146 vs 88
Offloads Bryce - 8 vs 0
Defense tackles Bryce - 84 vs 64
Missed tackles Doorey - 2 more
Tackle breaks Bryce - 7 vs 5

How many errors has Bryce made or forced? Not many if any. Doorey has spilled the ball a few times. Bryce adds another dimension to our attack. When Lanes back I'd have him still starting with Matto at lock and Hopgood on bench.

 

[hindy111]

He can be selected from June 30 anyway. So why waste a Top 30 spot ?

But you need 30 players. And we could just add someone else to the development spot.
Plus if we could get him some NRL game time so by end of season he would be further developed.
If Moimesea and Murchie had show more I wouldn't. But they look garbage

 

[Pazza]

I'd play matto in the middle, rcg and Paulo need the support.

 

[Pazza]

The boys on bloke in a bar were saying

Rcg
Hodgson
Paulo
Lane
Matto
Hopgood

Would be the best pack in the comp, what do you guys reckon??

 

[King-Gutho94]

Penrith humiliated us on the field in the GF and then after the game as well by mocking us.

Surely that's motivation enough to come out with a bit of fire and brimstone this week.

Last week we looked like we just got out of the sauna in the first 25 mins and Manly bashed us.

If we get beat by a better side so be it.

But lets attack with our defence and make a stand & point we hate Penrith too.

I think we are too placid at times by trying to play the nice guy.

 

[emjaycee]

Matto and Doorey have both played right edge hey? ... i would probably prefer Doorey start over Carty but maybe its a question of what side

Do you reckon Matto moves to middle during the game?

From memory in Round 1 Doorey started on the left and Carty on the right, but I may be mistaken.
Either way, I see Doorey as Ice's replacement on the right and Cartwright just keeping Lane's spot warm while he is out.

Yep, Matto starts on the edge and moves to the middle after 30, giving Hopgood a rest. Doorey into the right edge.
Hopgood returns with 30 to go and Matto moves back to the edge.

If it was me, I would start Paulo and Greig and bring RCG on for Greig after 20 and Maka on for Paulo after 30.

So:

Player	Ist Half	2nd Half	Total
Paulo	First 30 mins	Last 30 mins	60 mins
RCG	First 20 mins	Last 40 mins	60 mins
Greig	Last 10 mins for Paulo	First 10 mins for Paulo	20 mins
Makatoa	Last 20 mins for RCG	Injury cover only	20 mins
Cartwright	40 mins	40 mins	80 mins
Matto	Edge for 20 then middle	Middle for 10 then edge	80 mins
Hopgood	First 20	Last 30	50 mins
Doorey	Last 20 for Matto on edge	First 10 for Matto on edge	30 mins

Doorey needs to get fitter before we can rely on him for longer mins I reckon.

 

[Pazza]

I don't know about Greig, seeing him get belted on the weekend gave me Justin tsoulous vibes.

 

[hineyrulz]

I don’t think Greig is going to make it, maybe he just needs some more first grade. 10mins a game isn’t doing much for him.

 

[emjaycee]

I don’t think Greig is going to make it, maybe he just needs some more first grade. 10mins a game isn’t doing much for him.

That's why I reckon 20 mins with half time in the middle.
Let the f**ker rip in for 10 each side of halftime and see how he goes.

 

[Gronk]

Doorey needs to get fitter before we can rely on him for longer mins I reckon.

Yes, I said this a few weeks back and others have confirmed. He is definitely not Parra fit yet.

 

[JokerEel]

Unsure what Doorey has done over Bryce but.
Average meters Bryce - 146 vs 88
Offloads Bryce - 8 vs 0
Defense tackles Bryce - 84 vs 64
Missed tackles Doorey - 2 more
Tackle breaks Bryce - 7 vs 5

How many errors has Bryce made or forced? Not many if any. Doorey has spilled the ball a few times. Bryce adds another dimension to our attack. When Lanes back I'd have him still starting with Matto at lock and Hopgood on bench.

Bryce is a ball player... He is not a hole running second rower he is a middle..

 

[Gronk]

I don’t think Greig is going to make it, maybe he just needs some more first grade. 10mins a game isn’t doing much for him.

Maybe he can when we are playing a shit team and are 3 tries up ? Just not vs Pennys when we are 1 try down and Reg / Jnr are saying they are OK to go back on.

 

[Chipmunk]

From memory in Round 1 Doorey started on the left and Carty on the right, but I may be mistaken.
Either way, I see Doorey as Ice's replacement on the right and Cartwright just keeping Lane's spot warm while he is out.

Yep, Matto starts on the edge and moves to the middle after 30, giving Hopgood a rest. Doorey into the right edge.
Hopgood returns with 30 to go and Matto moves back to the edge.

If it was me, I would start Paulo and Greig and bring RCG on for Greig after 20 and Maka on for Paulo after 30.

So:

Player	Ist Half	2nd Half	Total
Paulo	First 30 mins	Last 30 mins	60 mins
RCG	First 20 mins	Last 40 mins	60 mins
Greig	Last 10 mins for Paulo	First 10 mins for Paulo	20 mins
Makatoa	Last 20 mins for RCG	Injury cover only	20 mins
Cartwright	40 mins	40 mins	80 mins
Matto	Edge for 20 then middle	Middle for 10 then edge	80 mins
Hopgood	First 20	Last 30	50 mins
Doorey	Last 20 for Matto on edge	First 10 for Matto on edge	30 mins

Doorey needs to get fitter before we can rely on him for longer mins I reckon.

I think you'd have to make more than 8 interchanges under your scenario of minutes. You've basically got 6 interchanges just from Paula, RCG and Hopgood