What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Top 20 NRL Players

DeeGan

Bench
Messages
2,800
An article written by LU's administrator Legend.

The Top 20 NRL Players
Written by: Michael Edgar
June 17th, 2007 10:41 AM


1. Jonathan Thurston, Cowboys: Has emerged as the real superstar of our game and has surpassed Lockyer as the main man for Australia and Queensland.

2. Cameron Smith, Storm: The best hooker in the game bar none. He can play eighty minutes, kick goals, tackles like a demon and can alternate between hooker and half if need be.

3. Darren Lockyer, Broncos: He is getting on in years but his list of achievements knows no bounds and has added another Origin series win to his list of outstanding achievements.

4. Willie Mason, Bulldogs: The one man the Blues and the Dogs cannot do without. Both teams look lost without him so his value to the game is immense. He looks worn out at the moment though.

5. Robbie Farah, Tigers: If Farah is injured, the Tigers season is over. He has eclipsed Marshall as the main man at the Tigers and will probably unseat Buderus as the hooker for NSW from next year and beyond.

6. Mark Gasnier, Dragons: His value can be measured by how much the Dragons and NSW have missed his game breaking ability on the field. He may be back by the finals, but the Dragons won’t be participating this year.

7. Paul Gallen, Sharks: The unluckiest player in the game when it comes to rep footy. He is hard and aggressive and is thriving under Stuart. NSW missed his aggression this year and is certain to be selected for game three.

8. Danny Buderus, Knights: Still one of the best players in the game but is approaching the twilight of his career. Wasn’t used to his potential for NSW but is leading the Knights superbly.

9. Jarryd Hayne, Eels: The best outside back in the NRL today. He has speed, size and confidence and is improving by the week. One of the only NSW players to hold his head high this year.

10. Greg Inglis, Storm: Not as dynamic last year at club level but at Origin level he is still scoring plenty of tries and has pace to burn.

11. Luke O’Donnell, Cowboys: Another player whose worth can be measured by his absence for NSW and the Cowboys. He brings his ‘A’ game every week and his toughness is only matched by his enthusiasm and aggression.

12. Steve Price, Warriors: The elder statesman of this group but has been superb for Qld and the Warriors and like a fine wine, is getting better with age. Both sides rely heavily on his leadership and go forward.

13. Todd Carney, Raiders: One of the most prodigious talents in the game if he can get his life in order. He will be a mainstay for NSW for years to come if he can stay on the field. A great running five eighth with a strong kicking game.

14. Justin Hodges, Broncos: His form in 2006 and 2007 has been breathtaking and his long range try against the Dogs last night was a thing of beauty. He moves very quick for such a big man and is a joy to watch.

15. Andrew Ryan, Bulldogs: Is just below Mason in terms of value for the Dogs. He is an inspirational captain who has a great year in a team that has been underachieving. He has been one of the few bright spots for NSW as well. Ryan has overtaken Hindmarsh as the games best workhorse forward.

16. Steve Simpson, Knights: With the retirement of Andrew Johns, Simpson has taken on even more responsibility and has relished being in the thick of it and leading the young Knights pack into battle every week.

17. Brett Stewart, Manly: Currently, the best finisher in the NRL along with Inglis. Made his debut for the Blues on Wednesday night and was one of only a handful of players who stood up to be counted for NSW. Will eclipse 100 tries with ease and may push Steve Menzies for the all time Manly record if he stays fit.

18. Greg Bird, Sharks: One of the hardest players in the NRL. He loves the rough stuff and is an equally good defender as he is with the ball in hand. Got a taste of Origin this year but needs more game time to be effective. One of the Sharks key players as they look for their maiden premiership.

19. Matt Bowen, Cowboys: Bowen is the fastest man in footy today and when he ran down Brett Stewart from Manly, he showed his raw pace against another speedster. Has exceptional ability in attack and is rapidly improving in defence.

20. Scott Prince, Titans: Has been the best player for the NRL’s newest club and due to Thurston being in front of him, is unlikely to play rep football again barring injury. Still, he is leading the Titans to an unlikely top eight berth and has brought self belief to the Titans in their maiden season.

Players who can consider themselves unlucky to miss out include: Benji Marshall, Sonny Bill Williams, Karmichael Hunt, Petero Civoniceva, Cooper Cronk, Matt Cooper, Nathan Hindmarsh, Roy Asotasi, Ryan Hoffman.
 

ShadesOfTheSun

Juniors
Messages
646
Please do explain how Marshall is 'unlucky to miss out' based on recent form. Also please explain why there are so many players who aren't playing in the 'Top 20 Players'.
 

legend

Coach
Messages
15,150
And...

If Carney were to be released by the Raiders he would be the number one target by almost every club.

When he has played this year, on most occasions he has destroyed other teams with his running and kicking and would have been in the origin side ahead of Mullen.
 

legend

Coach
Messages
15,150
ShadesOfTheSun said:
Please do explain how Marshall is 'unlucky to miss out' based on recent form. Also please explain why there are so many players who aren't playing in the 'Top 20 Players'.

Marshall is an excellent player and his dip in form prior to his injury had him miss out but overall, he is still an excellent player.

However, it is arguable his worth to the side based on their results this year is lesss than what is previously was with Robbie Farah stepping in as the go to guy for the Tigers.

NSW needed both Gasnier and O'Donnell if they were to win this year and there is no questions Gasnier is the Dragons best player and O'Donnell is second only to Thurston in North Qld.

Just because they are injured doesn't make them any less valuable to their team. In fact, their absence highlights their value IMO.
 

Raiding Dazz

Juniors
Messages
779
too many missing, what about Menzies, Hindmarsh, Toungue and Petro, they should be in there instead of some of those
 

legend

Coach
Messages
15,150
It's an opinion peice. Both Hindmarsh and Petero were given honourable mentions.

Menzies is good but nowhere near the player he was four years ago.

Tongue is inspirational for the Raiders but I don't see him in that list unfortunately and I'm a Raiders fan.
 

Tap Twist Snap

Juniors
Messages
1,030
Mason in there and no Civoniceva something is pretty wrong with the list. I think Cronk should be there infront of Prince. Prince is an alot more entertaining footy player to watch but Cronk does all the little things to perfection every week.
 

Panthers888

Juniors
Messages
125
My list:

1. Craig Gower (PEN)
2. Paul Gallen (CRO)
3. Shaun Kenny-Dowall (SYD)
4. David Faalogo (SOU)
5. Michael Jennings (PEN)
6. Greg Bird (CRO)
7. Brett Stewart (MAN)
8. Robbie Farah (WT)
9. Johnathan Thurston (NQ)
10. Joel Clinton (PEN)
11. Mitchell Pearce (SYD)
12. Feleti Mateo (PAR)
13. Steve Simpson (NEW)
14. Wade McKinnon (NZL)
15. Darren Lockyer (BRIS)
16. Josh Morris (StGI)
17. Luke Lewis (PEN)
18. Todd Carney (CAN)
19. Michael Gordon (PEN)
20. Brett Kearney (CRO)
 

ShadesOfTheSun

Juniors
Messages
646
legend said:
Marshall is an excellent player and his dip in form prior to his injury had him miss out but overall, he is still an excellent player.

However, it is arguable his worth to the side based on their results this year is lesss than what is previously was with Robbie Farah stepping in as the go to guy for the Tigers.

NSW needed both Gasnier and O'Donnell if they were to win this year and there is no questions Gasnier is the Dragons best player and O'Donnell is second only to Thurston in North Qld.

Just because they are injured doesn't make them any less valuable to their team. In fact, their absence highlights their value IMO.
Then you aren't judging the NRL's 'Top 20 players' - you're judging the 20 who are most invaluable to their clubs. There is a significant difference.
 

miccle

Bench
Messages
4,334
It's all opinion, of course, but I can't see how Steve Simpson and Andrew Ryan are included over Civoniceva.
 

Tommy Smith

Referee
Messages
21,344
miccle said:
It's all opinion, of course, but I can't see how Steve Simpson and Andrew Ryan are included over Civoniceva.
Simpson over Civo - that's hilarious. Even worse than seeing Jarryd Hayne above Hodgo on the list.

But i want criticise too much but every such list would bring alot of conjecture with it. It's entirely subjective.
 

wittyfan

Referee
Messages
29,984
Carney should be in the Top 10.

I'd imagine Witty would surely be bubbling just under the 20.
 

morri (cWo)

First Grade
Messages
6,030
Panthers888 said:
My list:

1. Craig Gower (PEN)
2. Paul Gallen (CRO)
3. Shaun Kenny-Dowall (SYD)
4. David Faalogo (SOU)
5. Michael Jennings (PEN)
6. Greg Bird (CRO)
7. Brett Stewart (MAN)
8. Robbie Farah (WT)
9. Johnathan Thurston (NQ)
10. Joel Clinton (PEN)
11. Mitchell Pearce (SYD)
12. Feleti Mateo (PAR)
13. Steve Simpson (NEW)
14. Wade McKinnon (NZL)
15. Darren Lockyer (BRIS)
16. Josh Morris (StGI)
17. Luke Lewis (PEN)
18. Todd Carney (CAN)
19. Michael Gordon (PEN)
20. Brett Kearney (CRO)

is this a joke?
 
Messages
3,717
1. Johnathon Thurston (Cowboys)
2. Cameron Smith (Storm)
3. Darren Lockyer (Broncos)
4. Sonny Bill Williams (Bulldogs)
5. Robbie Farah (Tigers)
6. Willie Mason (Bulldogs)
7. Cooper Cronk (Storm)
8. Steve Price (Warriors)
9. Mark Gasnier (Dragons)
10. Greg Inglis (Storm)
11. Matt Bowen (Cowboys)
12. Justin Hodges (Broncos)
13. Paul Gallen (Sharks)
14. Roy Asotasi (Souths)
15. Luke O'Donnel (Cowboys)
16. Greg Bird (Sharks)
17. Petero Civoniceva (Broncos)
18. Anthony Minichiello (Roosters)
19. Nathan Hindmarsh (Parramatta)
20. Brett Stewart (Manly)
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
Good list.. Its only someones opinion, not everyone is going to agree with it....

I would like to see the ARL come out with a Australian 25 contracted players list.. now that would be a talking point...
 
Messages
3,717
Panthers888 said:
My list:

1. Craig Gower (PEN)
2. Paul Gallen (CRO)
3. Shaun Kenny-Dowall (SYD)
4. David Faalogo (SOU)
5. Michael Jennings (PEN)
6. Greg Bird (CRO)
7. Brett Stewart (MAN)
8. Robbie Farah (WT)
9. Johnathan Thurston (NQ)
10. Joel Clinton (PEN)
11. Mitchell Pearce (SYD)
12. Feleti Mateo (PAR)
13. Steve Simpson (NEW)
14. Wade McKinnon (NZL)
15. Darren Lockyer (BRIS)
16. Josh Morris (StGI)
17. Luke Lewis (PEN)
18. Todd Carney (CAN)
19. Michael Gordon (PEN)
20. Brett Kearney (CRO)

:lol:
 

mxlegend99

Referee
Messages
23,324
My top 20:
1. Johnathon Thurston
2. Cameron Smith
3. Robbie Farah
4. Greg Inglis
5. Steve Price
6. Brett Stewart
7. Jarryd Hayne
8. Willie Mason
9. Darren Lockyer
10. Mark Gasnier
11. Cooper Cronk
12. Benji Marshall
13. Greg Bird
14. Matt Bowen
15. Sonny Bill Williams
16. Anthony Watmough
17. Anthony Minichello
18. Billy Slater
19. Petero Civinoceva
20. Roy Asotasi

They'd be my top 20, as for the exact order, it's just a rough list. Too hard to seperate some of them.
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
Minichiello has to be the most unlucky, him & Civo.
 

Latest posts

Top