TheFrog's Panthers Player Of The Year 2018

[TheFrog]

From my weekly ratings.

The winner happens to be the only player to play all 26 games. He achieved the highest average per match as well. There were 27 players who played first grade for us this year.

Obviously the players who played the most games were always going to get the highest score.

Total Score (Games Played)

1. Isaah Yeo 182 (26)
2. Viliame Kikau 174 (25)
3. James Fisher-Harris 171 (25)
4. James Tamou 160 (25)
5. Tyrone Peachey 151 (24)
6. Trent Merrin 150 (25)
7. Corey Harawira-Naera 149 (24)
8. James Maloney 142 (22)
9. Reagan Campbell-Gillard 139 (21)
10. Dean Whare 138 (22)
11. Dallin Watene-Zelezniak 132 (20)
12. Moses Leota 122 (20)
13. Nathan Cleary 116 (17)
14. Cristian Crichton 116 (20)
14. Sione Katoa 116 (20)
16. Waqa Blake 111 (16)
17. Josh Mansour 98 (15)
18. Jack Hetherington 73 (13)
19. Peter Wallace 59 (9)
20. Tyrone May 54 (10)
21. Wade Egan 54 (11)
22. Dylan Edwards 52 (8)
23. Tyrone Phillips 51 (9)
24. Kade Ellis 28 (6)
25. Jerome Luai 25 (4)
26. Sam McKendry 12 (2)
27. Caleb Aekins 7 (1)

 

[TheFrog]

Average Score Per Game (Minimum 4 games)

When comparing score-per-game, players who played short minutes off the bench regularly would be expected to be at or near the bottom.

1. Yeo 7.00 (26)
2. Kikau 6.96 (25)
3. Blake 6.94 (16)
4. Fisher-Harris 6.84 (25)
5. Cleary 6.82 (17)
6. Campbell-Gillard 6.62 (16)
7. Watene-Zelezniak 6.60 (20)
8. Wallace 6.56 (9)
9. Mansour 6.53 (15)
10. Edwards 6.50 (8)
11. Maloney 6.45 (22)
12. Tamou 6.40 (25)
13. Peachey 6.29 (24)
14. Whare 6.27 (22)
15. Luai 6.25 (4)
16. Harawira-Naera 6.21 (24)
17. Leota 6.10 (20)
18. Merrin 6.00 (25)
19. Crichton 5.80 (20)
20. Katoa 5.80 (20)
21. Phillips 5.67 (9)
22. Hetherington 5.62 (13)
23. May 5.40 (10)
24. Egan 4.91 (11)
25. Ellis 4.67 (6)

Under 4 Games

McKendry 6.00 (2)
Aekins 7.00 (1)

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Interesting to look back.
I would have thought Blake and Cleary would have scored better. and that Merrin should have been further down the list..Katoa is our best hooker.

 

[age.s]

Thanks for doing these Froggy. Enjoyed reading them even when I disagreed with the specifics. Hard to disagree much with the list, particularly on the per-game table.

What are people's thoughts on doing a forum wide 3, 2, 1 for each game next year?

 

[umina panther]

Thanks for doing these Froggy. Enjoyed reading them even when I disagreed with the specifics. Hard to disagree much with the list, particularly on the per-game table.

What are people's thoughts on doing a forum wide 3, 2, 1 for each game next year?

I tried a few years ago but life got in the way

 

[Fangs]

Haha I had no idea you were doing this for real. Thought your scores were just a meme.

I'm impressed, keep it up for next year!

 

[Fangs]

What are people's thoughts on doing a forum wide 3, 2, 1 for each game next year?

I'm in, maybe Frog should keep it organised because he has got this down.

@TheFrog

 

[MrBlack]

A lot of work in that.

The results are not surprising though. Yeo was our most consistent and reliable player.

 

[OldPanther]

If Merrin is above Maloney there is a serious flaw in the system.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Love it Froggy!

Yours is the only scoring system I even look at!

 

[age.s]

I'm in, maybe Frog should keep it organised because he has got this down.

@TheFrog

I wouldn't mind starting the threads and tallying scores.

Let's see what my motivation/time levels are like next year though

 

[TheFrog]

I'm in, maybe Frog should keep it organised because he has got this down.

@TheFrog

I've got the time to do something like this being out of the workforce permanently. A 3-2-1 was started a couple of years back but died when we had a few losses.

If I do this again I'll keep a spreadsheet updated every week. Saves hours of work at the end.

 

[TheFrog]

If Merrin is above Maloney there is a serious flaw in the system.

He played more games, that's all. This is why I did average per game as well. Trent was well down in that and Maloney about the middle. I was thinking to limit each player to the best 20 performances, to make it less biased towards players who played more games. As it stands, it's a measure of durability as much as anything

 

[martielang]

Good stuff Frog.

 

[OldPanther]

He played more games, that's all. This is why I did average per game as well. Trent was well down in that and Maloney about the middle. I was thinking to limit each player to the best 20 performances, to make it less biased towards players who played more games. As it stands, it's a measure of durability as much as anything

That makes sense. Definitely need something to counter games played. Especially since we have rep players who'll easily miss a few.

 

[Fangs]

I've got the time to do something like this being out of the workforce permanently. A 3-2-1 was started a couple of years back but died when we had a few losses.

If I do this again I'll keep a spreadsheet updated every week. Saves hours of work at the end.

Yeah well if there is enough interest why not. Appreciate the effort.

 

[Panther Pete]

Well done Frog, no doubt you have put a lot of time into this.

 

[franklin2323]

If Merrin is above Maloney there is a serious flaw in the system.

Played more games. That helps

 

[TheFrog]

Well done Frog, no doubt you have put a lot of time into this.

Three or four hours to go over all the game threads and put it into a spreadsheet, not too bad. Something I hadn't previously mentioned is that forum comments after games were taken into account in the scoring, so it wasn't just me.

Interesting to see how the Mervs go tonight, Yeo would have to go close but depends if they want to have a different winner this year. From posts on Twitter I'm thinking Billy Kikau might be the man.

 

[GongPanther]

Thanks for doing these Froggy. Enjoyed reading them even when I disagreed with the specifics. Hard to disagree much with the list, particularly on the per-game table.

What are people's thoughts on doing a forum wide 3, 2, 1 for each game next year?

What about a 1-10 rating?