What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

This side would work

1eyedeel

Juniors
Messages
552
I've basically spent all night, writing and anlaysing the Eels recent games and I reckon I've come up with a team that will go far better than what we've been producing in recent weeks (not that that is difficult).

1. Wade McKinnon
2. Brett Anderson
3. Ben Smith
4. Ashley Graham
5. Eric Grothe
6. John Morris
7. Chris Thorman/Adam Dykes/Michael Witt
8. Justin Tsoulos
9. Lee Hopkins
10. Fuifui Moimoi
11. Nathan Hindmarsh
12. Chris Muckert
13. Daniel Wagon

14. James Webster
15. Michael Vella
16. Craig Stapleton
17. Dean Widders

Most importantly, this team has balance, which as I've written in my blog is what I think we are missing. Importantly, I don't care who plays half-back, they're all good players but they all play the same game and successful sides only have ONE of these players in their team. When you consider Tim Smith is coming up as well, we have four classic-style small half backs. We don't need Orford or Head (unless you cut at least two of these four), we just desperately need a five-eighth. In the meantime, Morris needs to go back there.

This team has a full-back who backs up, wingers who have noses for tries, three-quarters who can run into holes, a five-eighth who is a solid defender and has the ability to set up outside backs, a half back who can control play and make zippy runs through the rucks, two big strong, intimidating starting props, one with a good offload, the other with menacing strength, an 80 minute second row with allround skills complemented by another big second rower with the ability to create chances, a lock who is strong defensively and a hooker who will give reliable service and work hard in defence. Off the bench, I've got a nippy hooker to exploit a tiring defence, a fast interchange prop who has seniority to come on and take over workload, a reliable forward who will come on and not make mistakes and work hard and a backrower with a great step who can break a game open. Sure, its a little inexperienced, but the inexperience comes in positions that are instinctive, not thinking positions, on the wing and in the three quarters.
 

The Engineers Room

First Grade
Messages
8,945
It isn't that the right players aren't playing it is that they aren't playing the way they should. The team is just pathetic in defence and offers little in attack. When did we last see second phase play and angled runners? And why do they not get up in defence?
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,093
I think you're onto something there......if we play all 3 of Chris Thorman/Adam Dykes/Michael Witt at halfback, hence 15 players on the field, I think it'll give us that advantage we have been needing.

;-)
 

The Engineers Room

First Grade
Messages
8,945
Gruzka wasn't that impressive the games I saw, Rnds 3, 5, 6, 7. Could have changed. Still the problem is not who is on our wings. Just what they are doing.
 

Freak

Juniors
Messages
1,394
That team stinks. Still way too many guys filling 1st grade shirts with No Hearts!!
To start with you have 2 front rowers you cannot get 10 minutes of football out of.
Tsoulos off in the opening 10 minutes against the Dragons??? And Fui on in the 21st minute and off again before halftime???

Our worst by a long way was again Dykes. Please please please just get rid of him. IMO he is the worst player in the comp and I would even prefer KUSTO!!! :shock:
 

PARRA_FAN

Coach
Messages
17,830
The problem is the prop forwards we've got, the halves combo. and the centres. Plus Morris hasnt been the same at hooker, should move back to five-eighth where he was in great form last year.

Fui Fui Moi Moi is mainly an impact player coming off the bench, I dont think he'll ever start in first grade because of the amount of time he plays. We need good mobile prop forwards, unfortunatley Cayless and Peek are both out at the moment. :(

Centres need to work on the defence, the current centres were hopless on the weekend and didnt aim up. They need to also work in attack, but we've got to solve the halves problem before the centres. Its the only way they'll be dangerous in attack.

And another thing is bring back Luke Burt.
 

Eels Dude

Coach
Messages
19,065
Wouldn't mind seeing Morris at 5'8th, we started winning when he came in there late last year. Muckert and Wagon both in the back row doesn't work for me, they're both not the biggest forwards around. FuiFui isn't worthy of a starting spot, and we should do better than Webster off the bench.
 

William Hung

Juniors
Messages
290
No way I would start with Fui.

He's a guy who will look good when the team is starting to lift/go forward. If we were falling behind/under pressure Fui would look like a fool- like he has the last couple of weeks (i.e not keeping up with the play, dropping of tackles, standing flat footed on hit ups).

He really does have to be injected at the right moment.

He's definately worth a spot on the bench though. I'd go with:

1. Mckinnon
2. Andersen
3. Smith
4. Graham
5. Grothe
6. Dykes
7. Thorman
8. Tsoulos
9. Morris
10. Stapleton
11. Hindmarsh
12. Hopkins
13. Wagon

14. Webster
15. Vella
16. Armit
17. Fui

Only problem would be the entirely new centre/wing combo on the right side of the field. If they got destroyed it might wreck their confidene. As far as a teams perspective goes though- they can't be any worse than the Petersen/Langi combi which IMO offers nothing in attack or defence.

I don't think Smith would relegate Vella either- as he is supposedly our forward leader and quite possibly our highest paid forward. Quite simply though...he has not played to starting first grade prop standard for two seasons. Let him work his way into form off the bench.
 
Top