Video Ref at it again....

[Alderley Rooster]

I am a bit perplexed with the video ref for the Lachlan Coote try today. They showed one replay of the best camera angle they had that showed clearly he grounded the ball on the dead ball line. They then proceeded to look at angles from cameras where the angle was poor at least three or four times and came up with a try.

WTF??

 

[The.X.Factor9]

I am a bit perplexed with the video ref for the Lachlan Coote try today. They showed one replay of the best camera angle they had that showed clearly he grounded the ball on the dead ball line. They then proceeded to look at angles from cameras where the angle was poor at least three or four times and came up with a try.

WTF??

Ohhhh SHUT THE F**K UP !

The Video Ref let your team get away with the Anasta strip.

 

[Alderley Rooster]

Ohhhh SHUT THE F**K UP !

The Video Ref let your team get away with the Anasta strip.

Mate I was just discussing a decision. typical bulldog fan response

 

[The.X.Factor9]

Mate I was just discussing a decision. typical bulldog fan response

No its not; you were just having a go at the panthers supporters for saying the refs cost them the game and you made this thread. The decision was benefit of the doubt, a fair call.

Another point; your team won, why the hell are you whinging ?

 

[Gaba]

The roosters always get the wrong side of decisions just ask the roosters fans

 

[Alderley Rooster]

No its not; you were just having a go at the panthers supporters for saying the refs cost them the game and you made this thread. The decision was benefit of the doubt, a fair call.

Another point; your team won, why the hell are you whinging ?

Mate I am not whingeing I am discussing a valid point. Can you tell me why the video ref didnt look at the front on shot which was from the best angle more than once?

Oh and I made this thread first thanks very much keyboard hero

 

[The.X.Factor9]

Mate I am not whingeing I am discussing a valid point. Can you tell me why the video ref didnt look at the front on shot which was from the best angle more than once?

Oh and I made this thread first thanks very much keyboard hero

there were 3 angles front side and behind... the front angle had doubt... the side angle said try.... and the behind angle said try... So if common sense prevails its a BOD try.

wow im a key board hero because i called you out for talking crap in two different threads ?

Why are you so special that you can call the Penrith fans whingers for a decision and people cant call you a whinger ?

 

[innsaneink]

I am a bit perplexed with the video ref for the Lachlan Coote try today. They showed one replay of the best camera angle they had that showed clearly he grounded the ball on the dead ball line. They then proceeded to look at angles from cameras where the angle was poor at least three or four times and came up with a try.

WTF??

On my TV, which is 103cm....the front on shot from the camera in the corner was inconclusive, the camera didnt get the dead ball line in the shot.
None of them showed anything clearly

 

[The.X.Factor9]

On my TV, which is 103cm....the front on shot from the camera in the corner was inconclusive, the camera didnt get the dead ball line in the shot.
None of them showed anything clearly

Hence BOD is a fair call right ?

 

[skeepe]

On my TV, which is 103cm....the front on shot from the camera in the corner was inconclusive, the camera didnt get the dead ball line in the shot.
None of them showed anything clearly

Correct.

Now if the OP would like to explain why a blatant strip by Anasta gets let go while Todd Carney gets a penalty for dropping it cold, I'd like to hear it.

 

[Dr Crane]

oh look, a roosters fan aggrieved by a refereeing call. how novel!

 

[cornerposter]

Mate I was just discussing a decision. typical bulldog fan response

Oh great! Another drive by shooting :crazy:

 

[The.X.Factor9]

Oh great! Another drive by shooting :crazy:

LOL haha I knew something like this was coming. :sarcasm:

 

[ceagle]

That LOL@50uff$ try today was a shocker

 

[besthalfbackPEARCE]

The video ref came up with some very contentious calls, but idc Roosters won :lol:

 

[snoozer]

That LOL@50uff$ try today was a shocker

terrible call.

felt a bit sorry for the eagles with that one.

they had the last laugh though.

lol@50uff$

 

[God-King Dean]

Morris was in.

 

[Downie]

I don't even know where to start with the Merritt tap-back today. How they couldn't see his foot clearly touching the ground whilst his hand was still in contact with the ball is beyond me. Expect a sorry and a week-long demotion for the video ref (Mander was it?) and a that's all folks. I don't mind them getting the odd 50-50 wrong but this one was ridiculous.

 

[cornerposter]

I'd be spewin if it was awarded against my team, but I can see why they did. The frame was blurred and dark so they couldn't see for sure if the hand was still on the ball. I think we all thought it was but You couldn't tell thus BOD.

 

[MSIH]

I'd be spewin if it was awarded against my team, but I can see why they did. The frame was blurred and dark so they couldn't see for sure if the hand was still on the ball. I think we all thought it was but You couldn't tell thus BOD.

Couldn't tell?

Your reception up in Queensland must be pretty shit.