Wests 1999 V Newcastle 2005....Who is worse?

[Stranger]

Two wrongs DONT make a right

But sometimes they just make some people feel better

 

[BWNB]

cronulla_sharks_fan123

nice photocopy of the trophy you have in ur sig :lol:

it is nice isnt it
we are one of the favs to bring it to wooloware , we just cant get in front of ourselves

 

[wittyfan]

Incorrect. The joint venture have been given the rights to take the statistical information of both clubs into account when they are considered. Which means that they are St George and Illawarra not a new seperate club.

Then why does the Official Yearbook of the NRL not count anything before 1999????

 

[Stranger]

it is nice isnt it
we are one of the favs to bring it to wooloware , we just cant get in front of ourselves

I do note the only time you will see that trophie in ur dust cabinet will be with a photocopy... strange it will look similar to the one in your sig

 

[Gene Krupa]

Two wrongs DONT make a right

Two wrongs make a right, Lisa.

 

[Gene Krupa]

I do note the only time you will see that trophie in ur dust cabinet will be with a photocopy... strange it will look similar to the one in your sig

Funny 'cause it's true! :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[BWNB]

dont we have something in our cabinet?
world club challange ?
or something?

 

[Squishy_Da_Byatch]

So do punching bags. Have you not thought that some people take their footy VERY seriously and it might hurt a lil?!?!

 

[Stranger]

dont we have something in our cabinet?
world club challange ?
or something?

Cause that competes With the Nrl premiership trophy dosent it? :lol:

 

[*Paul*]

dont we have something in our cabinet?
world club challange ?
or something?

1979 midweek comp. Funny stuff that comp, QLD Country beat Newtown, Norths and Parramatta. I sure hope it was becasue the Sydney clubs weren't taking it seriously.

 

[Pistol]

Dont forget about the Gold Coast. Pretty much throughout the 90's they personified mediocrity. There was a season there where they only won the single game. They only made the finals during the Super League year.

 

[wittyfan]

Ummmmm. We've won two Einstein!

1.5 to be more chillingly accurate.

I also forgot to add earlier that Wests in 1999 didn't waste a significant part of their salary cap on an injury prone player past 30.

 

[wittyfan]

Dont forget about the Gold Coast. Pretty much throughout the 90's they personified mediocrity. There was a season there where they only won the single game. They only made the finals during the Super League year.

Perhaps the Gold Coast of 1993 are a much fairer yardstick to compare Newcastle 2005 to?

 

[Gene Krupa]

dont we have something in our cabinet?
world club challange ?
or something?

Choke team award is more like it.

 

[wittyfan]

1979 midweek comp. Funny stuff that comp, QLD Country beat Newtown, Norths and Parramatta. I sure hope it was becasue the Sydney clubs weren't taking it seriously.

It was Combined Brisbane.

 

[Gene Krupa]

1.5 to be more chillingly accurate.

I also forgot to add earlier that Wests in 1999 didn't waste a significant part of their salary cap on an injury prone player past 30.

You couldn't even win the other 0.5 premiership that year! :lol:

Choked then too! :lol:

 

[Gene Krupa]

Perhaps the Gold Coast of 1993 are a much fairer yardstick to compare Newcastle 2005 to?

Your team compares to Annandale and University! :lol:

 

[wittyfan]

You couldn't even win the other 0.5 premiership that year! :lol:

Choked then too! :lol:

Your mob would have been smashed by Brisbane too. How did Manly lose that game?????

 

[wittyfan]

Your team compares to Annandale and University! :lol:

I think University are much more closer to Newcastle. They went through long periods without looking like winning games.

 

[RABK]

Cronulla's start to 2002????

Someone?