which storm player will be in tiger colours next year??

[Borat.]

Which storm player will be in tiger colours next year??

More who you would sign, rather than who you think super-coach would sign....

 

[aids]

former origin player.
tony quin

 

[Magpies Forever]

Probably none. But, maybe Lima seeing as we almost had him hooked last time.

 

[Borat.]

Probably none. But, maybe Lima seeing as we almost had him hooked last time.

You wouldn't sign anyone??

 

[Tigers_are_Pro]

Isa seems reasonable, he's what we need, a back to back up Fitz.

 

[Magpies Forever]

You wouldn't sign anyone??

a/ I dont think they'd want to come.

b/ WT only really want a prop / half for depth- they dont need hooker, backrow, wing / centre. I reckon Lima may be the only one but I dont think he will come.

c/ If WT can play their existing team roster in a full strength team ie Moltzen, Tuiaki & Galloway playing, at best you'd only want some back up reserve depth. We are weak in the half position but only in depth- Cronk wouldnt come to be a reserve and a dont think its fair on Moltzen. Same with fullback Ryan is doing a damn good job there- he has done nothing to warrant dropping him for a new signing.

d/ Melbourne's problem is they have to loose a start player or two, not the depth players and I dont think the star players are in the positions we really want to swap for our existing players.

Smith for Farah? Nah
Slater for Ryan? Nah
Cronk for Moltzen? Nah
Inglis for Lawrence? Nah

And if we are talking about replacing Fitzy any of those would want may over our limit for replacing Fitzy with another utility- besides we have Flanagan learning the ropes.

 

[Borat.]

a/ I dont think they'd want to come.

b/ WT only really want a prop / half for depth- they dont need hooker, backrow, wing / centre. I reckon Lima may be the only one but I dont think he will come.

c/ If WT can play their existing team roster in a full strength team ie Moltzen, Tuiaki & Galloway playing, at best you'd only want some back up reserve depth. We are weak in the half position but only in depth- Cronk wouldnt come to be a reserve and a dont think its fair on Moltzen. Same with fullback Ryan is doing a damn good job there- he has done nothing to warrant dropping him for a new signing.

d/ Melbourne's problem is they have to loose a start player or two, not the depth players and I dont think the star players are in the positions we really want to swap for our existing players.

Smith for Farah? Nah
Slater for Ryan? Nah
Cronk for Moltzen? Nah
Inglis for Lawrence? Nah

And if we are talking about replacing Fitzy any of those would want may over our limit for replacing Fitzy with another utility- besides we have Flanagan learning the ropes.

I was only after who you would like to see at the club...not who would come,

In saying that the Panthers are chasing Inglis.....

cut Tnt, cayless, fitzy, brown, ryan, and payto and you can fit 2 out of Inglis, Cronk, Lima , White....who will be no doubt going for unders as not that many clubs have cap space left.....some will go to England, some to R/U etc etc...but if they go to other NRL clubs they would likely go for unders...

Don't know why we need Fulton and Flanagan in the same side- so more potential $$ savings- surely O'dwyer can play a similar role to Flanagan....or Hino for that matter...

 

[851]

I would like Slater and Tolman,although Inglis would be good too.

 

[Benji Magic]

If I could only have 1 then it would be Tolman. Cronk would be nice too.

Sheensy will probably try to resign Ryan Tandy, or Anthony Quinn to sit on the bench & play 3 mins every week.

 

[Magpies Forever]

I was only after who you would like to see at the club...not who would come,

In saying that the Panthers are chasing Inglis.....

cut Tnt, cayless, fitzy, brown, ryan, and payto and you can fit 2 out of Inglis, Cronk, Lima , White....who will be no doubt going for unders as not that many clubs have cap space left.....some will go to England, some to R/U etc etc...but if they go to other NRL clubs they would likely go for unders...

Don't know why we need Fulton and Flanagan in the same side- so more potential $$ savings- surely O'dwyer can play a similar role to Flanagan....or Hino for that matter...

Fair enough- Inglis, Lima & Cronk in no particular order

 

[Tigers_are_Pro]

I seriously don't want White. He's very, very average.

 

[macnaz]

Quinn, he is a massive merkin...dam hate the wanker.
Id go cronk or finch, i think Finch would be the cheapest option but still would provide more than enuf to our side.

 

[tigers_are_premiers]

Will we even have room under the cap?? Who's off contract at the end of the year?

 

[macnaz]

Thats right, we wont be buying any of them. Even if we had the money i doubt we would chase anyone useful and in there prime.

 

[phenisha]

^ what like ellis ?

 

[37916319]

I'm more than happy to Sign Inglis on a '1 training session contract' and hope he runs into Fitzy and puts him out of his misery.

 

[super_coach]

We will struggle to keep what we have, but Cronk without doubt would be the player to turn our mob around. Even Sheens could not stuff him up