Who Is 2004's Most Under Performing Sharks Player??

[Sideline Eye]

I'll start this with a tie between Paul Franze and Andrew Lomu.

 

[Jimbo]

Beattie rated a strong mention before last week's effort

 

[chili pepper]

Lomu has had a couple of great games - watch the Broncos game again.

Franze is coming back from a hideous injury that would have ended the careers of some.

I'd nominate Galloway. I really thought he'd have a huge year this year but his game hasn't really progressed much. Of course he's still young so maybe I'm also being a bit harsh but I'm really expecting huge things from this kid.

Other contenders are Merrit and Newton.

 

[King of the Hill]

Nigel Vagana

 

[Sideline Eye]

For what Lomu cost us and expectations he came with, he has been dissappointing

 

[Macca]

Nathan Merrit for mine. I really think he has something but he has failed to show us what it is. It's a shame really.

 

[Nuffs]

vagana, merrit, galloway, franze, where do i start?

 

[Genius Freak]

Vagana if not for the Parra game. Expected more from Newton too.

 

[chili pepper]

That must have hurt you McSharkie to type that.

 

[Macca]

Yeah, I picked him as a bloke with potential. He may yet prove me correct. I thought he was going to be the solution to our goal kicking first and foremost but I pleased that Hilder got the nod now.

 

[Special K]

Franze big time!
Galloway
Merrit

Lomu has been good, he just needs more game time and to be more pissed off like he was against Manly!

 

[carcharias]

For what Lomu cost us and expectations he came with, he has been dissappointing

you should check out his Grand Final effort for last year. Compared to that he's on fire.
I thought Nigel Vagana would have worked out better.....Franze as well.
Galloway is too slow for mine he looks like one of those big tree's from Lord of the rings.
Merrit has been a little dissapointing as well, from the hype I thought he was gonna be the next billy slater. However he is getting better slowly.
Reick still can't run without tripping over his own feet.

Probably Nigel for my vote unfortuantly....I still hold hope for a great run home for him.This weekend is the big one for him I'd imagine.

 

[millersnose]

1. merrit
2. vagana

 

[incredible_holc]

1.Vagana
2. Merrit
3. Franze

 

[givmeabeer]

No one

 

[blacktip-reefy]

1. vagana
2. Lomu
3. merrit

= $500,000.00

 

[Booyah]

Merritt for mine. He shone with the Bunnies last year, and I had massive raps on him when he came over. He hasn't done much to prove me right.

Vagana has been disappointing, but I think we will really see him shine next year. I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt this year. Injuries, different style of attack etc.

 

[Mr Angry]

Franze.

 

[Melstar]

Vagana and Merritt

 

[imasharkie]

oh well I guess i have to put my two bobs worth in:
Vagana- I thought he was going to be our savour in the backs

Merritt- Kills me to say it although he had his best game for us last week,might be a change in the wind.

Galloway- Whats doin with this bloke, he's gone downhill