Who would you cut? who would you keep?

[girvie]

I was wondering which of the unsigned Premier League players would you want to keep, and who would you cut?

This is from my Premier League gains and losses thread:
http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/showthread.php?t=146977

Gains for 2007:
Jack Afamasaga (Second Row) - from Parramatta
Glenn Hall (Prop) - from Sydney Roosters

Losses for 2007:
Kane Cleal (Prop) – to South Sydney (mid-season)
Mark Lennon (Fullback) - to Cronulla Sutherland
Paul Stephenson (Centre) - to Cronulla Sutherland
Michael Witt (Halfback/Five-Eighth) - to New Zealand Warriors

Retained Players for 2007:
Adam Cuthbertson (Second Row), Sean Meaney (Wing/Fullback), Michael Robertson (Wing), George Rose (Prop), Glenn Stewart (Second Row/Lock), Mailangi Styles (Prop), Nathan Tutt (Second Row/Lock), Jason Wells (Lock/Second Row).

Unsigned - who would you keep? who would you cut?
Kyle Arnold (Prop),
Matt Ballin (Hooker),
Todd Barrow (Lock),
Willie Bishop (Wing/Fullback),
JP Cherry (Five-Eighth/Lock),
Mitch Creary (Wing),
Jim Curtis (Prop/Second Row),
Sean Dalton (Centre),
Andrew Everingham (Wing),
Sione Finefeuiaki (Prop),
Jon Grieve,
Clint Halden (Halfback),
James Mortimer (Wing),
Phil Morwood (Prop),
Mark Offerdahl (Second Row),
Jeff Robson,
Wes Tillot (Centre/Wing),
Rob Toshack (Centre).

 

[Ryan]

My Premier League team would be this:-

01. Sean Meaney
02. Willie Bishop
03. Sean Dalton
04. Wes Tillot
05. Mitch Creary
06. Clint Halden
07. Aaron Groom
08. Glenn Hall
09. Matt Ballin
10. Mailangi Styles
11. Mark Offerdahl
12. Adam Cuthbertson
13. Jason Wells

14. J P Cherry
15. Sione Finefeuiaki
16. Phil Moorwood
17. Jack Afamasanga

I personally think the problem with Manly's Premier League team, is there's too many Premier League quality players if you get my meaning.

I mean The Storm for example had Jake Webster, Scott Hill, Ian Donnelly, Billy Slater, Ben Cross, Chris Walker etc playing premier league at some time this year for The Bears...

Shows you the difference in depth.

And they couldn't even find an appropriate replacement for BK, yet Mayer comes out and suggests we are close to the salary cap???

Bob Fulton suggested we didn't have the personel to match it with the big guns, and now we have a team in 1st grade that will consist of players like Williamson, Rose, Bryant and co. that aren't exactly the biggest name players. I personally think we may be heavily front loading. If not, we are paying overs (like monaghan on $240k per annum !!!)

 

[RainMan]

If Matt Ballin hasn't been re-signed for next year, that will do me.

 

[Sea Eagle Scuba]

I was wondering which of the unsigned Premier League players would you want to keep, and who would you cut?

This is from my Premier League gains and losses thread:
http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/showthread.php?t=146977

Gains for 2007:
Jack Afamasaga (Second Row) - from Parramatta
Glenn Hall (Prop) - from Sydney Roosters

Losses for 2007:
Kane Cleal (Prop) – to South Sydney (mid-season)
Mark Lennon (Fullback) - to Cronulla Sutherland
Paul Stephenson (Centre) - to Cronulla Sutherland
Michael Witt (Halfback/Five-Eighth) - to New Zealand Warriors

Retained Players for 2007:
Adam Cuthbertson (Second Row), Sean Meaney (Wing/Fullback), Michael Robertson (Wing), George Rose (Prop), Glenn Stewart (Second Row/Lock), Mailangi Styles (Prop), Nathan Tutt (Second Row/Lock), Jason Wells (Lock/Second Row).

Unsigned - who would you keep? who would you cut?
Kyle Arnold (Prop),
Matt Ballin (Hooker),
Todd Barrow (Lock),
Willie Bishop (Wing/Fullback),
JP Cherry (Five-Eighth/Lock),
Mitch Creary (Wing),
Jim Curtis (Prop/Second Row),
Sean Dalton (Centre),
Andrew Everingham (Wing),
Sione Finefeuiaki (Prop),
Jon Grieve,
Clint Halden (Halfback),
James Mortimer (Wing),
Phil Morwood (Prop),
Mark Offerdahl (Second Row),
Jeff Robson,
Wes Tillot (Centre/Wing),
Rob Toshack (Centre).

Kyle Arnold (Prop) - KEEP
Matt Ballin (Hooker) - DEFINATELY KEEP!!!!!
Todd Barrow (Lock) - CUT, but really KEEP for depth if needed.
Willie Bishop (Wing/Fullback) - KEEP
JP Cherry (Five-Eighth/Lock), - Tough one, if we could sign a quality young five eighth then CUT, but until we do KEEP
Mitch Creary (Wing) - KEEP but only on a part time basis
Jim Curtis (Prop/Second Row) - KEEP, for depth purposes
Sean Dalton (Centre) - KEEP
Andrew Everingham (Wing) - KEEP, youngster from JF in 2006.
Sione Finefeuiaki (Prop) - KEEP, plenty of improvement left in the big fella.
Jon Grieve - KEEP
Clint Halden (Halfback) - Same situation as Cherry tbh, If we could sign a quality 5/8, it wouldn't bother me if we let him go.
James Mortimer (Wing) - KEEP , depth
Phil Morwood (Prop) - KEEP
Mark Offerdahl (Second Row) - MUST KEEP
Jeff Robson - KEEP
Wes Tillot (Centre/Wing) KEEP
Rob Toshack (Centre) KEEP

 

[Berkeley_Eagle]

Cut Dunley

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Robson, Toshack, Cherry, we don't need them...

 

[chileman]

Gotta keep Ballin!

 

[Ryan]

He re-signed I think a month ago guys to a two year deal. As you get nada from the club, who knows what could be true though?