Who's Better?

[Anonymous]

Please settle an argument between me and a very misguided individual.

 

[ball boy]

on his day booger if he runs the right lines otherwise robbo hands down

 

[Raider_69]

Robbo over boogs by a fair margin
but robbo is still nothing more than a solid back up for mine

he wont get a start with mogg, frawley, graham, gafa etc infront of him

 

[edabomb]

Bulgarelli on his day by a mile.

 

[Steven Gerrard]

i wonder who raiderette robbo will vote for?

 

[edabomb]

http://www.nrl.com/season2004/stats/playerstats.cfm?team1=3&player1=724

Stats are pretty even. I can hardly see how Timbo can call me misguided when making this statement. I guess it's the in thing to blame Bulgarelli for everything.

 

[Steven Gerrard]

I personally think Robbo was going great guns when he started to run at full speed at the defence.

I'd like to see next year

1. Schif
2. Robbo
3. Frawley
4. Mogg
5. Graham

that would be one of the quickest backlines in the league? :shock:

 

[edabomb]

I'd prefer Lolesi in the 2.

Or Gafa, Howell, N.Smith......

 

[Kris_man]

Gafa HAS to be there, he's awesome, especially his defence. Every game, i'm more and more impressed with him. He has the complete game, unlike Robbo or Phil. Phil, however, makes up for his weaknesses with breathtaking attacking flair, unlike Robbo.
back to the poll question, it's pretty easy for me: Robertson. Boogers has been OK the last couple of games, but in general i think he's got problems - anything but the complete game. he has almost single handedly lost us games at times. and did anyone see that first try by the roosters on the weekend? hodges is not really a very fast centre, but he easily outpaced boogers (not that i blame boogers completely for that try, but it just showed how he lacks the speed to be a good centre. also see that bulldogs game at gosford this year. boogers took an intercept, and only made about 20 metres).

 

[edabomb]

Gafa HAS to be there, he's awesome, especially his defence. Every game, i'm more and more impressed with him. He has the complete game, unlike Robbo or Phil. Phil, however, makes up for his weaknesses with breathtaking attacking flair, unlike Robbo.
back to the poll question, it's pretty easy for me: Robertson. Boogers has been OK the last couple of games, but in general i think he's got problems - anything but the complete game. he has almost single handedly lost us games at times. and did anyone see that first try by the roosters on the weekend? hodges is not really a very fast centre, but he easily outpaced boogers (not that i blame boogers completely for that try, but it just showed how he lacks the speed to be a good centre. also see that bulldogs game at gosford this year. boogers took an intercept, and only made about 20 metres).

He was hardly helped by Robbo dropping back for the kick leaving a blatant 2 or 3 on 1 scenario.

 

[thickos]

If Boogas could CATCH the goddamn ball #-o I think he would have a greater ability to penetrate a defensive line than Robbo so I am, incredibly, leaning towards Boogas. He can tackle, which is a plus.

 

[ball boy]

that is my thaught exactly thickos

 

[Kris_man]

He was hardly helped by Robbo dropping back for the kick leaving a blatant 2 or 3 on 1 scenario.

:roll: i didn't say it was his fault they scored, because it was of course a 3 on 1 situation. you totally missed my point. all i was saying is that boogers got outpaced by hodges, showing how slow he is for a centre.

 

[Kris_man]

He can tackle, which is a plus.

yes, he can tackle the big guys, which is a plus, but he struggles immensley with one-on-one tackles on the quick guys. gee, i don't think he's a good defender at all, quite the opposite.

 

[edabomb]

He was hardly helped by Robbo dropping back for the kick leaving a blatant 2 or 3 on 1 scenario.

:roll: i didn't say it was his fault they scored, because it was of course a 3 on 1 situation. you totally missed my point. all i was saying is that boogers got outpaced by hodges, showing how slow he is for a centre.

Centers don't need to be quick if they work well as a team in defense. Look at Shaun Timmins, he was never quick and consistently plays rep footy at center. Boogas and Robinsons combo on D is a shocker.

 

[raiderette_robbo]

i wonder who raiderette robbo will vote for?

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm.............. :-k ...........ummmmmm..............yeah.
GO ROBBO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Woohoo

 

[I Bleed Green]

On current form, even though Robbo scored a length of the field try last week, Bulgarelli for mine.

 

[MILLWALL]

I hate boogas but i mean he has played a couple of solid games

 

[lotm]

i don't think boogs is as bad as some people make him out to be. with a couple of adjustments to his game regarding handling and discipline, he'd be a solid (and enthusiastic) first grader. it's fortunate that his problems aren't technique-related, because he'd never get near the firsts if they were.

nevertheless, atm, robbo's the more consistently better of the two.

 

[Anonymous]

Ahhhhhh!!!!!!

I was just flicking through some old posts, and to my abject horror, I discovered I picked Buggers in most of my sides earlier this season!