What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Why is Guerra not facing a suspension?

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,688
He admitted to cheating to gain a penalty. And not just any cheating, this isn't staying down to pretend there was a high shot when there wasn't. This was the kind of cheating that can kill you or permanently cripple you. This is a thousand times worse than throwing a bottle at someone.

The NRL has made so much noise about punishing lifting tackles more, so how can they not punish this which also causes just as much risk. In letting it go they are condoning it and condoning it could lead to it happening again.
 

some11

Referee
Messages
23,350
Just checking for consistency but were you this outraged when Josh Reynolds did the same thing?

[youtube]wQx-6VADk38[/youtube]
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
65,842
Probably because he is just making sht up to get his mate off? Hodges lifted his leg, what happened after that is irrelevant really as the player ended up in a dangerous position. But hey ho, this is the NRL and I've pretty much given up hoping for any level of consistency on any level in the game these days.
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
41,661
He admitted to cheating to gain a penalty. And not just any cheating, this isn't staying down to pretend there was a high shot when there wasn't. This was the kind of cheating that can kill you or permanently cripple you. This is a thousand times worse than throwing a bottle at someone.

The NRL has made so much noise about punishing lifting tackles more, so how can they not punish this which also causes just as much risk. In letting it go they are condoning it and condoning it could lead to it happening again.

It's an absolute joke. It will get worse next season too.

They are piss weak, zero consistency and gutless!
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
41,661
Probably because he is just making sht up to get his mate off? Hodges lifted his leg, what happened after that is irrelevant really as the player ended up in a dangerous position. But hey ho, this is the NRL and I've pretty much given up hoping for any level of consistency on any level in the game these days.

Can't argue with any of that.
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,688
Probably because he is just making sht up to get his mate off? Hodges lifted his leg, what happened after that is irrelevant really as the player ended up in a dangerous position. But hey ho, this is the NRL and I've pretty much given up hoping for any level of consistency on any level in the game these days.

Either he cheated to get the penalty or he lied at the judiciary. Both are low acts and deserve punishment.
 

SLRBRONCOS

Referee
Messages
23,182
If it was a bunnies player this thread would be non existent. Majority of players will play for a penalty when your team is getting belted in a prelim!
 

Cockosh

Juniors
Messages
1,138
The NRL has made so much noise about punishing lifting tackles more, so how can they not punish this which also causes just as much risk. In letting it go they are condoning it and condoning it could lead to it happening again.

So do they draw the line at those that admit it or do they cite serial offenders like Greg Inglanous who perform the act in just about every tackle?

The irony of this thread being started by a souffs fan is incredible. Glenn Stewart and Greg Inglis.
The other ironic thing is that when they do actual get hit and are concussed they don't leave the field.
 

TonyT6

Bench
Messages
4,987
Either he cheated to get the penalty or he lied at the judiciary. Both are low acts and deserve punishment.

Roosters players don't dive and are beyond reproach, who can forget Trent Robinson and Danny Weidlers campaign to get rid of diving when they put the blow torch on young Euan Aitken.f**king hypocrites.
 

Kiwi

First Grade
Messages
9,471
Probably because he is just making sht up to get his mate off? Hodges lifted his leg, what happened after that is irrelevant really as the player ended up in a dangerous position. But hey ho, this is the NRL and I've pretty much given up hoping for any level of consistency on any level in the game these days.

Not true. To the letter of the law they had to find Hodges not guilty. As mentioned in the other topic, as soon as the tackled player contributes to the tackle becoming dangerous the tackling player can't be charged. Guerra admitted guilt so Hodges had to be cleared. What this will do is open the door for players to successfully contest charges when a tackled player falls into a tackle making it high etc.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
65,842
Got a link to which section of rule book this is in? I've looked Through it and can see no reference to this claim re a player contributing to foul play on himself.
 

grouch

First Grade
Messages
8,393
Roosters players don't dive and are beyond reproach, who can forget Trent Robinson and Danny Weidlers campaign to get rid of diving when they put the blow torch on young Euan Aitken.f**king hypocrites.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...yers-laying-down/story-fni3gn3s-1227320919434

Roosters coach Trent Robinson says the NRL must stop players laying down
April 26, 2015 12:35pm
David RiccioThe Daily Telegraph

ROOSTERS coach Trent Robinson has accused the NRL of refusing to have any interest in stamping out the ugly issue of players laying down to attract penalties.

Vocal in recent weeks with his disdain for players intentionally taking dives, Robinson continued his passionate campaign on Saturday night claiming St George-Illawarra?s Euan Aitken purposely lied down after a high shot from Roosters prop Dylan Napa, while adding that teammate Jared Waerea-Hargreaves was within his rights to verbal the rookie centre, as he lay prone on the Allianz Stadium pitch.

It?s not the first time Robinson has queried whether the game is heading down the path of soccer, where players taking dives is of epidemic proportions.

Napa was penalised and placed on report for a 60th minute swinging arm on Aitken, which led to Hargreaves taking umbrage with the Dragons right-centre.

The Roosters firebrand was then singled out by the match officials for yelling at Aitken to ?get up.??

The Dragons extended their lead to 12-6 as a result of the penalty.

Robinson said he watched the incident three times after the match and believes a penalty should never have been blown while claiming Hargreaves was unfairly targeted by the match officials, simply because Aitken lied down.

?The NRL has decided not to do anything about it,?? Robinson said.

?What happened after he (Aitken) got hit around the shoulders?

?Jared got talked too after that for going over and saying ?stand up?. Young kid (Aitken) in our game, playing great footy and he lies down on that play.

?You guys like watching that in our game, are you happy with that? Is that our sport???
When it was suggested by a journalist that Napa had hit Aitken high, Robinson said: ?Well, I think you need to have a look at it again.

?Initially I thought he hit him high, then we saw the replays, across the chest. And so Jared went over, as he should told him to get off the ground.

?And then who gets spoken too, Jared does.

?We?re accepting it in our sport and if that?s the way we?re going then you guys don?t say anything about it, let?s carry on.

?But if that?s the sport you watch and love then its different to the one I?ve been watching for years.

?It?s not an isolated incident. Players have come out and said they do it because it?s being allowed to happen.??

Aitken denied he had intentionally layed down saying: ?He (Napa) got me, I was rattled.??
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
24,558
Did anybody see the Gould hodges interview?

Hodges said he went into the roosters dressing room and asked guerra if he was charged would he support him. Guerra said yes.

This is a bit of an abuse of power and intimidation IMO. You've got a club captain and qld origin legend walking up to a young bloke asking him to do something to save his career. Of course he is going to do it whether he agrees or not. Poor form from hodges.
 

Brutus

Referee
Messages
26,205
He admitted to cheating to gain a penalty. And not just any cheating, this isn't staying down to pretend there was a high shot when there wasn't. This was the kind of cheating that can kill you or permanently cripple you. This is a thousand times worse than throwing a bottle at someone.

The NRL has made so much noise about punishing lifting tackles more, so how can they not punish this which also causes just as much risk. In letting it go they are condoning it and condoning it could lead to it happening again.

who cares.

just enjoy the GF.
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,679
They did it so they could invoke the tears of Souffs fans again
You've been quiet for too long and they wanted to make sure you were truly pissed you'd failed so badly this season

Seems they succeeded
 
Top