What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

will thurston be an eel?

Raudonikis

Juniors
Messages
1,544
I would just concentrate on KK and Mortimer.Didnt DA say a couple months ago they were the longterm halves? I really cant see parra letting Mortimer go to the dogs either.
 

ElectricEel

Juniors
Messages
352
If we can get Thurston that will be awesome. I think we should offload Cayless. He will do good in retirement in UK or France probably. But Osborne is looking to buy Thurston that will be awesome. Thurston being a marque player, we can have a deal like Gasnier. I think we will be the team to watch in 2010.

I HATE SALARY CAP...

I'll give you the hot tip. Thurston will never go back to the Dogs.
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,366
I'll give you the hot tip. Thurston will never go back to the Dogs.

That is what I heard but that was under previous management and coach, Folkes. Maybe things have changed now.

The more I think about it the more I ponder because Thurston may change the dynamics of our side. Hayne and Mateo may have less influence which worries me. Remember 2001? We played as a team and didn't really rely on any one player.
 
Last edited:

ElectricEel

Juniors
Messages
352
That is what I heard but that was under previous management and coach, Folkes. Maybe things have changed now.

The more I think about it the more I pondery because Thurston may change the dynamics of our side. Hayne and Mateo may have less influence which worries me. Remember 2001? We played as a team and didn't really rely on any one player.

Good point about dynamic. He can be a ball hog, and want to be the centre of the game.

Yeah, 2001. It was ours for the taking. Why did we only turn up in the second half?
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,968
we dont need him

how do we know Mortimer isn't going to be better than Thurston ?

and Morts is not a Queenslander
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,484
Thurston is the best player in the game bar none IMO, but i hate the bloke with a passion. But that all will change if he comes to Parra :lol: Except for 3 games a year........
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,285
Thurston isnt needed

I kind of agree. But let's break it down:

The last times we were successful were 2005 and 2007. We made it one game from the Grand Final.

Now, granted - other events transpired those days. But a big problem, in my eyes, was our halves' inability to capitalise and take the match by the scruff of the neck.

Thurston could do that...
 

Someone

Bench
Messages
4,964
haha. you guys actually want the eels to be like the cowboys? thurston has killed the cowboys because he is asking for way too much money. noone is worth what ive heard he is on (600-700k roughly). you could divide that into 3 players that will give the cowboys a chance for a premership. how can they win 1 if they have a 700k HB while every other player is either washed up or not even half decent. one good player doesnt win premerships. thurston will never win 1 aslong as he asks for that much money.
 

Raudonikis

Juniors
Messages
1,544
haha. you guys actually want the eels to be like the cowboys? thurston has killed the cowboys because he is asking for way too much money. noone is worth what ive heard he is on (600-700k roughly). you could divide that into 3 players that will give the cowboys a chance for a premership. how can they win 1 if they have a 700k HB while every other player is either washed up or not even half decent. one good player doesnt win premerships. thurston will never win 1 aslong as he asks for that much money.

I agree,dont need/dont want.
 

tresurehunt

Juniors
Messages
1,323
Thurston is the best player in the game bar none IMO, but i hate the bloke with a passion. But that all will change if he comes to Parra :lol: Except for 3 games a year........

i think thurston is a great player,but he is not the best player in the world atm
 

Talanexor

Juniors
Messages
1,798
haha. you guys actually want the eels to be like the cowboys? thurston has killed the cowboys because he is asking for way too much money. noone is worth what ive heard he is on (600-700k roughly). you could divide that into 3 players that will give the cowboys a chance for a premership. how can they win 1 if they have a 700k HB while every other player is either washed up or not even half decent. one good player doesnt win premerships. thurston will never win 1 aslong as he asks for that much money.

Darren Lockyer earns more than Thurston. And yet they have always had a side full of representative-quality players.

A huge chunk of that $700,000 is in third-party deals and is outside the salary cap anyway, so we can still afford some other quality players.

And the Cowboys will come a helluva lot closer to a premiership than the Eels will. Four Cowboys played Origin this year (Thurston, Tonga, Scott for QLD; O'Donnell for NSW) compared to one Eel.

Every club in the competition will be after Thurston's signature when his current contract expires because he's a quality halfback and a genuine gamebreaker, both extremely rare attributes.

The Dogs think they'll get him, but they won't. The club, coach and players are totally different to 2004. The Warriors think they'll get him because he's half Kiwi and he gave his premiership ring to Steve Price. But he won't go anywhere unless he's going to be captain, least of all New Zealand, where players go to kill their careers.

700K is a LOT to pay for a player, but the reality is most clubs would (and would have to) pay more than that to lure him away from Townsville where he's captain of the team and a god to the people.

So hands off. Besides, that Mortimer kid goes alright anyway.
 
Top