What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Your team v titans

Spot On

Coach
Messages
13,902
Keary outplayed Pearce in 2017. Not sure how anyone could have Pearce staying at the Roosters and playing in front of Keary. I doubt that was ever the preferred plan either.
 

Johns Magic

Referee
Messages
21,654
https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/luke-kearys-rise-alongside-cooper-cronk-a-sliding-doors-moment-for-mitchell-pearce/news-story/86f82983fd2508b3b313bb1ee249bca2?fbclid=IwAR1z9_XmKVxkDMV5hHQ2q5FcKWtKthSBILnaCT6RBXnqn7b_QYuFo5q4R7w

Luke Keary’s rise alongside Cooper Cronk a sliding doors moment for Mitchell Pearce



Watching Luke Keary’s astonishing rise alongside Cooper Cronk is like a sliding doors moment for what could have been for Mitchell Pearce.

That’s because Keary’s biggest progression as a footballer is straight out of the Cronk handbook.

It is not about doing more, it is about doing less, doing it well, and consistently.

By doing that, it makes the players around him look better.


3ca60145488b1b98a93d5c211bd54807

If you look at the way Keary has learned from Cronk, Keary seems to have a simple approach to the game.

He just looks, and plays, so carefree.

Then you watch Pearce playing for Newcastle and it is like the struggling skipper is still carrying the weight of the world on his shoulders.

What you can never do is question Pearce’s commitment.

But the one thing he did at the Roosters, and is still doing at the Knights, is overplaying his hand.

He just tries too hard.

4274c21fe84841a5a37ede38373235f9

Luke Keary’s astonishing rise alongside Cooper Cronk is like a ‘sliding doors’ moment for what could have been for Mitchell Pearce.
Taking that into account, the most obvious thing is Keary has learned from Cronk that you don’t have to make the game so complicated.

When you have centres like Latrell Mitchell and Joseph Manu, it’s not about what you do before getting them the ball. It is simply about getting them the ball, and getting it to them early.

It is very much the same with James Tedesco.

You don’t need to create the hole. You just have to give Tedesco the ball with enough time so he can use his speed to create his own opportunity.

And whereas the Roosters use power running into early ball, Newcastle are trying so hard to get Kalyn Ponga into space, with Pearce playing deep into the defensive line, that it is taking away from Ponga’s greatest strength as a player.

ed7cb8e6c03cf35a03092b129676c5e6

Mitchell Pearce is struggling at the Knights. Picture: AAP
Ads by Kiosked

I just wonder if Pearce ever regrets his decision not to take up Nick Politis’soffer to stay at the Roosters to learn from Cronk.

No one will ever understand the hurt Pearce must have felt when the Roosters brought in Cronk over the top of him.

And people continue to say Pearce was at a stage of his career where he deserved to own a team.

But what can’t be disputed is the Roosters made the right call in bringing in Cronk. And it is Keary who has benefited most.

60a67a1e8dbb498f9d912ec1c942292b

Luke Keary is going from strength to strength for the Roosters. Picture: Phil Hillyard
Tomorrow night the Roosters take on Melbourne in the grand final rematch and the Keary-Cronk combination is flying.

Another performance like Keary produced last weekend against Cronulla would just about seal the 27-year-old’s place in the NSW halves this year.

Keary is going so well that many now believe he runs the team better on his own than when Cronk is playing beside him.

But don’t underestimate Cronk’s influence on the team.

Whether it be what he is doing behind the play to get his forwards into position, or just driving the game plan, he is still the best in the business at it.

He knows what to do and when to do it. And he rarely deviates from what he knows works.

Which goes to the core of his influence over Keary and other players in the team, notably Jake Friend.

But it is Keary who has really taken his game to a whole new level.

After setting up three tries against the Sharks, Trent Robinson said Keary was entering his prime.

But would that be the case if Cronk hadn’t arrived at Bondi, or if Pearce had stayed?


Who knows who would have ended up playing off the bench, but Politis was adamant at the time that signing Cronk was not designed to push Pearce out.

Yet Politis and Robinson felt compelled to base their decision on what they believed was in the club’s best interests.

Pearce took with him a tremendous motivation that he could be the man to lift Newcastle back into premiership contention.

But while his form last year seemed to justify the decision, this year Pearce is back playing like he is burdened by the expectation.

What we will never know now is how it would have transpired if Pearce had stayed at the Roosters, or whether it would have been Pearce or Keary who took the back seat.


similars

Whatever the case, Keary has taken his opportunity and he is running with it.

There is no looking back.

I spoke to Politis this week about how far the Roosters had come in recent years, and asked if this team now had the chance to do what the club did in 1974-75 under Jack Gibson and claim back-to-back titles.

“I think we are warming up to it,” Politis said.

“But I can’t rate it with those teams because they won two grand finals back-to-back.

“Round six is a bit early to go off and say things like that.”

But he did speak of Robinson’s influence, praising his calmness and his honesty.

Then Politis brought up Cronk. We didn’t even speak about the decision to let Pearce go.

However, Politis said Cronk’s arrival was a “big turnaround”.

“He has added so much to our club on and off the field,” Politis said.

“He is a wonderful person.”

Who wrote that article?
 

Yosh

Coach
Messages
11,307
Seems pretty reasonable. Wish Pearce would just keep it simple and just defend hard, kick long and give early ball to Ponga and our backs.
 

Knight Vision

First Grade
Messages
5,066
This situation reminds me of Mullo a lot. Never had the half he needed as many put it. It is why Brown took the massive gamble of moving Ponga from 1.
It certainly does lend some perspective to Browns decision. Also there arent any real quality halves coming onto the market over the next 2 years that Ponga wouldnt be better than.
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,335
It certainly does lend some perspective to Browns decision. Also there arent any real quality halves coming onto the market over the next 2 years that Ponga wouldnt be better than.

Put a serviceable ball player like say Corey Norman (who was available) in our 6 jumper and I firmly believe we are in the top 4 right now. Hell, even Tyrone Roberts (who was available) would have done the job for us.

Watson isn't a 6 (9 or 14), and Lino is a slow dancer - he tries to create for himself through footwork, but isn't quick enough to go through with it.

Neither are the answer.

We have loaded up the pressure on the guy who has shown every single time that he doesn't handle it well.

We tried to put Ponga to 6 for all the wrong reasons.
 
Top