MacDonald to go North??

[MilanDragon]

https://www.5thtackle.com/2018/06/15/macdonald-to-head-back-north/

Sorry it wouldn’t let me copy the article across.

I’m not against this, while he has value we could potentially get more upside from a Lomax/Herbert and they would come cheaper. If he’s going in 2020, I’d say let him go in 2019.

Imagine a back three of Dufty, Lomax, Herbert - add field in the mix.

 

[Gm5]

keep him for next year, he's not on much coin is he? in saying that if we're making a play at a big name and need the cash then flick him

 

[latemail]

Thank f**k
Got a heart as big as s pea

 

[Drag Queen]

https://www.5thtackle.com/2018/06/15/macdonald-to-head-back-north/

Sorry it wouldn’t let me copy the article across.

I’m not against this, while he has value we could potentially get more upside from a Lomax/Herbert and they would come cheaper. If he’s going in 2020, I’d say let him go in 2019.

Imagine a back three of Dufty, Lomax, Herbert - add field in the mix.

Are you taking the piss?

 

[Bests Golden Boots]

While I appreciate his sometimes miraculous put downs, I’d like a winger that could run the length of the field.

 

[Drag Queen]

Thank f**k
Got a heart as big as s pea

Just poorly coached. He has so much potential that isn't being tapped.

 

[Coffs dragon]

Probably good for him....because last year his form went South!

 

[MilanDragon]

Are you taking the piss?

What makes you think I’m taking the piss?

If he goes he goes so be it. I was excited to get him, but I don’t think anyone could say he has asserted himself and is irreplaceable.

 

[TomRedVRiver]

What makes you think I’m taking the piss?

If he goes he goes so be it. I was excited to get him, but I don’t think anyone could say he has asserted himself and is irreplaceable.

It's the fact that you've posted a 5th tackle article. The least credible Rugby League "source" out there.

 

[MilanDragon]

It's the fact that you've posted a 5th tackle article. The least credible Rugby League "source" out there.

Ahhh - yes I thought it could be that.

But at the same time it’s a forum and if there’s some news why not post it. Gives us another talking point, though I’m sure we can bring this thread to be about Sacking Mary and Nighty too.. Guess we’ll find out by 2020 if it was right or not!

 

[Dragonslayer]

We've been over this ground in the Rumours thread and 5th tackle are as reliable as a 2 bob watch

 

[Dragons 09]

We've been over this ground in the Rumours thread and 5th tackle are as reliable as a 2 bob watch

True, but they are much more reliable than the 200 Baht watches!

 

[Brutalitops]

I firmly believe Nene has the potential to be a top class winger like Vunivalu.

He is still very young. This year he has improved tenfold. If he continues to improve he could reach scary heights.

Would prefer to keep him. His flaws are not inherent and are the type which will get better over time, as they already have.

It's the other wing I'm more concerned about. Let's see if Mann can make it his own

 

[Drag Queen]

I firmly believe Nene has the potential to be a top class winger like Vunivalu.

He is still very young. This year he has improved tenfold. If he continues to improve he could reach scary heights.

Would prefer to keep him. His flaws are not inherent and are the type which will get better over time, as they already have.

It's the other wing I'm more concerned about. Let's see if Mann can make it his own

Cheers to that.

 

[Dragons 09]

I firmly believe Nene has the potential to be a top class winger like Vunivalu.

He is still very young. This year he has improved tenfold. If he continues to improve he could reach scary heights.

Would prefer to keep him. His flaws are not inherent and are the type which will get better over time, as they already have.

It's the other wing I'm more concerned about. Let's see if Mann can make it his own

Totally agree about Nene. He has it in him, just needs a coach that can extract it out of him and he could be anything. I just wish someone would make him realise how big and powerful he is. if he ran with bad intent, damn, he would be a real beast to handle.

 

[Old Kogarah Boy 1]

https://www.5thtackle.com/2018/06/15/macdonald-to-head-back-north/

Sorry it wouldn’t let me copy the article across.

I’m not against this, while he has value we could potentially get more upside from a Lomax/Herbert and they would come cheaper. If he’s going in 2020, I’d say let him go in 2019.

Imagine a back three of Dufty, Lomax, Herbert - add field in the mix.

Can he take Lafai with him as a make weight.

 

[Crush]

Great player just poorly coached?
Thats a good one.
We have 5 players in Origin, I think the players are being coached well enough to develop to their potential.
Nene is a good player, not a great player though IMO.
Coach has nothing to do with it.

 

[Dragons 09]

Great player just poorly coached?
Thats a good one.
We have 5 players in Origin, I think the players are being coached well enough to develop to their potential.
Nene is a good player, not a great player though IMO.
Coach has nothing to do with it.

Can a good player become a great player?

 

[Crush]

Can a good player become a great player?

No

 

[Dragons 09]

No

You're fishing skills just keep on improving!