What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Is this Mitchell Pearce's last chance in Origin?

How many State of Origin matches will Mitchell Piss play?

  • Zero

    Votes: 7 53.8%
  • 0

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • None

    Votes: 5 38.5%

  • Total voters
    13

Knightmare

Coach
Messages
10,716
Personally I think NSW choice of captain is more to blame for their losses. After all - the buck should stop with the captain.

Personally as a Queenslander I'm very pleased that NSW continue to pick Gallen as captain. He is a player who has a history of looking for shortcuts to win games. He consistently hogs the ball in a way that I believe disempowers other forwards in the team.

I could name about two or three players who would make better NSW captains.


Farah?
 

gUt

Coach
Messages
16,935
Only 24 years old, if we are lucky.. 30 more.

Well said. He knows what it's like to lose. His coach knows what it's like to lose. His coach knows that he knows what it's like to lose and said so publicly. He clearly needs more time to get used to the pace of Origin but once he does, Cameron Smith and Billy Slater will be retired and Thurston will be on his last legs. It's 2016.

Hodges will have retired from rep football so for Qld a rejuvenated YowYeh will complete a remarkable comeback. Cooper Cronk and Cherry Evans form a lethal combination when Thurston is injured for the 2016 series while Will Chambers and Greg Inglis score a combined record number of tries in an Origin series by centres. Ben Barba earns the nickname of "Sick Ones" for Qld, previously held by Matt Bowen.

Adam Reynolds has played halfback for the all-conquering South Sydney Rabbitohs for three straight NRL Premierships but as of 2016 has still never worn the sky-blue. Mal Meninga becomes the first coach to win an Origin series whilst not leaving his house.

South Sydney wins the 2016 premiership with Adam Reynolds at halfback for the fourth straight year, the club's fourth straight Grand Final victory against the Carney-led Cronulla Sharks. Mitchell Pearce is picked at half-back for the NSW Blues for the 2017 Origin series.
 

Desert Qlder

First Grade
Messages
9,364
24 and the most capped NSW Origin halfback.

I seriously have to take a moment to digest this fact. This is more than Johns, Sterling, Mortimer, Toovey et al.

This goes to the very heart of NSW woes, and why they continue to be the subject of derision by us Queenslanders. Origin for you is the playing of those who practice severe nepotism, rather than an opportunity to assert your dominance in our game.
 

Game_Breaker

Coach
Messages
14,968
Let the articles calling for his head begin

It's time for the NSW Blues to sack Mitchell Pearce and look for a new halfback

POSITIONS vacant. The NSW State of Origin team is seeking to employ a new halfback.

The successful applicant must be reliable and have the ability to work under extreme pressure.

Applicants must also possess exceptional organisational skills. Experience is preferred but not a necessity.

Duties include putting a stop to eight miserable years of sporting pain.

Please send full resume to Laurie Daley, c/o NSWRL, Driver Ave, Moore Park, NSW, 2021.

…And now back to last night’s game.

Mitchell Pearce is a wonderful competitor with a heart as big as his dad’s, the former Blues and Balmain legend Wayne Pearce.

No-one tries harder and he again gave it absolutely everything last night.

But at Origin level he falls a fraction short in overall class.

Pearce went into last night’s match knowing he need to produce the game of his life to survive. And he didn’t.

There were just too many errors.

One of his kicks was charged down midway through the second-half when the Blues were trying to get clear from their own territory on the final tackle.

A few plays later and Justin Hodges was over for the Maroons. It was the match-deciding try.

Five minutes earlier the Blues were on the attack, just 20 metres out, desperately needing the try to equalise.

The Roosters half-back needed to drill the ball into the in-goal for a repeat set or even kick to the corner for his winger.

He mis-kicked it, the Maroons regathered, and were off the hook.

Pearce a great player and club level and rarely makes mistakes.

He is second only to Thurston for engineering tries inside the opposition 20.

But it just wasn’t his night.

Just two minutes into the first half he knocked on early in the tackle count.

This great Queensland side is hard enough to beat without being gifted possession.

Even when there were just a few minutes to go and the game was still alive, he threw a terrible pass to Josh Dugan.

Pearce has had five seasons to prove himself at this level.

Next year it will be someone else’s turn, most probably South Sydney’s book young halfback
Adam Reynolds.

He’s got a stronger kicking game and has learnt to run the football at the Rabbitohs this year.

Laurie Daley had spoken for two weeks about the importance of a positive start but the Maroons took advantage of some awful Blues defence to open the scoring in the 10th minute.

Johnathan Thurston has scored few softer tries in his career, stepping and weaving his way around James Tamou and Robbie Farah.

At least the Blues weren’t blown away like they were in Brisbane.

A couple of minutes later Thurston took it to 8-nil when James Maloney was penalised for a late tackle on Cooper Cronk.

But from that point the Blues had the better of the first half. They clawed back with a try to James McManus in the 26th minute.

It was beautifully set-up by Josh Morris who sucked in three defenders to give the Newcastle winger the space.

Enjoying a huge territory and possession advantage, the Blues could have scored on another two occasions. They had 57 per cent of the ball.

Poor options and poor handing let them down.

Andrew Fifita didn’t come on until the 20th minute but had racked up nearly 80 metres by half-time.

But brute strength and size alone wasn’t going to crack open the Queensland line.

Pearce tried hard and ran himself a couple of times but couldn’t find holes.

The Blues needed to score first in the second-half.

Fifita gave them every hope with a strong surge and a magnificent pass to put Josh Dugan into the clear but the ball came loose.

Chances like that one have to be taken when you’re playing against as great as Queensland’s.

http://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/its-time-for-the-nsw-blues-to-sack-mitchell-pearce-and-look-for-a-new-halfback/story-fndv2twz-1226681029301
 

Yosh

Coach
Messages
11,892
Seriously how does Daley defend Pearce? Seriously, fu*k you.

I don't believe I had to listen to that sh*t Cameron Smith dished up when they took their shield. Seriously... Fu*k everyone involved in choosing Peace.
 

God-King Dean

Immortal
Messages
46,614
attachment.php
 

Usain Bolt

Bench
Messages
3,737
Why are people bagging him? He wasnt the one who slid off Thurston when he scored or missed the tackle on Hodges
 
Messages
2,259
I'm waiting to see the press conference where we get told how well he went.

Daley announced prior to Game 3 that even should a loss to NSW eventually be the result, would not deter him from choosing Piss to play Origin in 2014.

You guys don't get it: The entire NSW hierarchy wants Mythchell to become the Captain of the Blues. Nothing will impede them in their quest to maintain an open Origin slot for The Favourite Son. Heck, Daley even said that if they don't give him the halfback jersey, wunderkind Mythch can assume the Number 9 role for the Blues. Probably for a few years too. I'd reckon that they'd play him as Hooker for 2 or 3 series. They'd be stupid enough to make him Captain for his last series (when QLD are going for 13 in a row).

No reason he can't hit 30

Imagine just how good he'll be when he has lost a few more series.

24 and the most capped NSW Origin halfback.

I seriously have to take a moment to digest this fact. This is more than Johns, Sterling, Mortimer, Toovey et al.

This goes to the very heart of NSW woes, and why they continue to be the subject of derision by us Queenslanders. Origin for you is the playing of those who practice severe nepotism, rather than an opportunity to assert your dominance in our game.

One of the things that I said in my first posts here was that NSW were their own worst enemies. NSW had commisioned a thorough investigation of the Maroons winning streak and reached a number of reasonable conclusions. One suggestion was that NSW needed a full-time coach. Another was the NSW needed to select a core group of players in order to build stability plus garner experience and foster long term combinations.

I warned that it was a mistake to copy QLD's tactics if the selections weren't right. Firstly Stuart was not a good choice for Coach. He wanted Gallen (as Captain. I could not believe that), Gidley and Pearce. Consider that he also was directly responsible for Ennis and Minichiello and it is obvious that Stuart f***ed NSW with his selections. In other words, Stuart was the worst selection that NSW made; the rest of the stupid selections just followed that selection.

Pearce's selection has never been questioned by any of the Blues inner circle despite any number of poor showings. Doesn't that make the Blues fans ask some questions of their own about his tenacious selection and why he is pencilled-in to be there next year? Even before Game 3 had been played and not to be influenced or dissuaded by a Blues loss. Not one other player had been singled out for selection in 2014, yet Mythch has been guaranteed that his playing needn't be the issue which stands between him and a NSW jersey.

You guys had better stop complaining about Pearce and had better get used to the fact that he will be selected for years to come, and most certainly he will be eventually selected as Captain of NSW.
 
Last edited:

Yosh

Coach
Messages
11,892
Why are people bagging him? He wasnt the one who slid off Thurston when he scored or missed the tackle on Hodges

Look, I don't know how much you know about rugby league but when your halfback is knocking on, kicking it straight to the opposition every tackle, can't create a try to save his life, he is doing something wrong.

Pearce didn't make line break, he didn't get a repeat set, he didn't provide a try assist. He dropped the ball, he kicked it straight into the defender when we had momentum. I don't mind his defense but if he isn't offering anything in attack, why is he there?

Our forwards dominated the sh*t outta theirs. We just couldn't score. That's 100% down to the halves.
 
Messages
21,880
24 and the most capped NSW Origin halfback.

I seriously have to take a moment to digest this fact. This is more than Johns, Sterling, Mortimer, Toovey et al.

This goes to the very heart of NSW woes, and why they continue to be the subject of derision by us Queenslanders. Origin for you is the playing of those who practice severe nepotism, rather than an opportunity to assert your dominance in our game.



Huh?

The most capped NSW halfback ?

Pearce hasn't played more than Johns . Am I missing something ?
 
Messages
2,259
Laurie Daley to the press, after Game 3:


http://www.nrl.com/coach-daley-rues-blues-lack-of-execution/tabid/10874/newsid/73520/default.aspx






"With South Sydney halfback Adam Reynolds breathing down his neck after two fantastic years in the NRL, Mitchell Pearce's future must hang in the balance after his kicking game once again failed to fire.Pearce was under pressure leading into the game and admitted last week he would be unlikely to keep his spot should he fail to lead the Blues to victory.
Daley reiterated his support for the 24-year-old but refused to say if the under-fire Sydney Roosters No.7 would remain his first-choice for next year's series.
The 43-year-old has continued to back Pearce since taking on the job last year but said it was too early to be giving assurances about 2014.
"I think you reassess after every game, but unfortunately for us you have 12 months to wait and a lot can change," he said.
"It's not about the individual it's about sticking with what we want to do.
"I thought Mitch tried hard. It's a big question to ask 12 months away from the next game.
"I have been a big supporter of Mitch and always will be. But when things go wrong he is the guy to always cop it for whatever reason."
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
"i thought Mitch tried hard"

Hitler tried hard too.

If Daley can't see how bad Mitchell is then he should be sacked as coach.
 
Top