Best player to never win a premiership?

[Moffo]

Is it Hindy?

 

[Rhino_NQ]

touchy question. Wally Lewis comes to mind but considering he was playing in what was a very high quality brisbane competition when he was at his peak and from memory was a gf winner it is hard to say that if it was in the competition we have known it to be since expansion outside of NSW whether he would have won a premiership.

If you went from say 1988 onwards Hindy's name is the first that comes to mind. Michael Bani a close second

 

[Jason Maher]

Arthur Summons

 

[Geohood]

Slater
Cronk
Smith
Inglis

 

[Marshall_magic]

Wayne Pearce
Andrew Ettingshausen
Cam Smith
Billy Slater

 

[The Eagle]

touchy question. Wally Lewis comes to mind but considering he was playing in what was a very high quality brisbane competition when he was at his peak and from memory was a gf winner it is hard to say that if it was in the competition we have known it to be since expansion outside of NSW whether he would have won a premiership.

If you went from say 1988 onwards Hindy's name is the first that comes to mind. Michael Bani a close second

LOL Micheal Bani was awful once he left Manly,completely woeful

It will be Paul Gallen

 

[Geohood]

Do they have to be retired? Or not won a premiership so far? Cause I'm sure there would be heaps more.

 

[The Eagle]

Or......Nathan Brown

I hated that little prick

 

[BranVan3000]

Cameron Smith

 

[parra-matters]

Wayne Pearce, Steve Roach, Paul Sironen, Hindy, Cayless, ET, Mundine (just ask him).
Gavin Miller the list goes on.

 

[Red Bear]

Florimo, Larson, Fairleigh, Moore

 

[Rhino_NQ]

forgot about ET, multiple NSW/Aus rep, 300+ games for one club, one GF loss. Add a crapload of tries and he might have it just over Hindy

 

[leaguebythefireplace]

Mark Soden, Matt Seers, Alan Tongue, Lance Thompson...all these guys never played any rep footy either...UNIMMORTALS

 

[Noa]

Hindy lol.

Good honest player but far better players then him havent tasted success on the ultimate day

 

[Lowdown]

Wally
Smith
Slater
inglis

4 immortals/in waiting that haven't won a premiership in the NSWR/NRL comp. well two of them will resolve this tomorrow.

 

[Perce]

Needs more The Dugan.

 

[El Diablo]

i think MG had Steve Rogers as his number 1 when he did his list of top 5 players never to win a premiership

 

[Son of Minto]

Has anyone said Slater/Smith/Cronk yet?

 

[some11]

Carl Webb.

 

[Leaguefan22]

Has anyone said Slater/Smith/Cronk yet?

Yep.